nOPEAHI.\A "nO-A06PO PErYAHPAHE" TOM III iuraPHI nOCAEABAIQA v OQEHKA HA Bh3AEHCTBHETO HI a.IHI 31 IIlIIHlqlBIH8 HII"MIHICTPI1l1BHm 181Y.IH8 I QMIHICTPI1l1BHMB HIHTUOJI B'IIQ ClIOIHCHltl "8MHICT )l,OIma,I(.N'!! 55728-BG linJIrAPIIH IIOC/leiJBaU{a Ol{eflKa fla Bo3iJeucmBuemO J-lU 3UKOJ-lU au OZPUHU1..fUSUJ-le J-lU adMUHUCmlJamUSHomo pezYJluIJuJ-le u adMUJ-lUCntpantUSHlVlKOHmpo/t 601Jxy cmOltUHCKama deuJ-locm JIB 2010 r. CBETOBHA 6AHKA OTAEn IIC1>I.1HAHCI.1PAHE 1.1 PA3BI.1TI.1E HA ....ACTHI.1R CEKTOP" ~EHTPAlIHA EBPonA 1.1 npI.16Al1TI.1~CKI.1TE CTPAHI.1 PErl.10H EBPonA 1.1 ~EHTPAlIHA A31.1R BAWIi1HrrOH. CAlli ©2010 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Developmentffhe World Bank 1818 H Street, N.W. Washington DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org All rights reserved 1 234 13 12 11 10 Manufactured in the Republic of Bulgaria First printing: November, 2010 Report No. 55728-BG HaCTOSIll.J:UIT TOM e ,ll,eJIO Ha cny)lUiTemr Ha Me)K,ll,YHap0,ll,HaTa 6aHKa 3a Bb3CTaHOB>lBaHe H pa3BHTHe / CBeTOBHa 6aHKa. KOHcTaTau,HHTe, TbJIKYBaHHSTa H 3aKlllOQeHHSTa, npe,ll,CTaBeHH B T03H ,ll,OKYMeHT, He OTpa3SBaT HenpeMeHHO MHeHHeTO Ha DOp,ll,a Ha H3nbJIHHTeJIHHTe ,ll,HpeKTOpH Ha CBeTOBHaTa 6aHKa HJIH Ha npaBHTeJICTBaTa, npe,ll,CTaBJISBaHH OT Hero. CBeTOBHa 6aHKa He rapaHTHpa TOqHOCrra Ha ,ll,aHHHTe, BKJIJOqeHH B ,ll,OKJIa,ll,a. )l,bp:JKaBHHTe rpaHHu,H, u,BeTOBeTe, HaHMeHOBaHHSTa H BCSKaKBa ,ll,pyra HHtPopMau,HS, nOKa3aHa Ha KapTHTe B HaCTOSIll.HS MaTepHaJI, He OTpa3SBaT CTaHOBHIll.e OT CTpaHa Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa 3a npaBHHS cTaryT Ha ,ll,a,ll,eHa TepHTopHS HJIH nOTBbp)l{:)leHHe, HJIH npHeMaHe Ha TaKHBa rpaHHu,H. B cnyqaH Ha eBeHryaJIHH HeCbOTBeTCTBHS, BO,ll,eIll. e aHrJIHHCKHST TeKCT Ha "flOG.Tle06aU(.a OlfeHKa Ha 6b30eucm6uemo Ha 3aKOHa 3a 02paHUt{a6aHe Ha ,ll,OKJIa,ll,a aOMUHucmpamU6Homo pe2YJlUpaHe U aOMUHucmpamU61lUR KOHmpOJl 6bPXy cmonaHCKama oei:JHocm ". MaTepHaJIbT B HaCTOSIll.aTa ny6JIHKau,HS e 06eKT Ha asTOPCKH npaBa. KonHpaHeTO H/HJIH npenpe,ll,aBaHeTO Ha qaCTH HJIH Ha u,snaTa ny6JIHKau,HS 6e3 pa3pellIeHHe MO:JKe ,ll,a npe,ll,CTaBJI>lBa HapYllIeHHe Ha 3aKOHO,ll,aTeJICTBOTO. Me:JK,ll,yHap0,ll,HaTa 6aHKa 3a Bb3CTaHOB5IBaHe H pa3BHTHe / CBeTOBHa 6aHKa HaCbpQaBa pa3npOCTpaHeHHeTO Ha CBOHTe pa3pa60TKH H 06HKHOBeHO ,ll,asa He3a6aBHO pa3pellIeHHS 3a Bb3npOH3Be)K,ll,aHeTO Ha qaCTH OT TSX. 3a nOJIyqaBaHe Ha pa3pellIeHHe 3a CPOTOKOITHpaHe HJIH npeneqaTBaHe Ha KaKBaTO H ,ll,a e qaCT OT HaCT05IIll.HS ,ll,OKJIa,ll" MOJIS, H3npaTeTe 3MBKa C nO,ll,p06Ha HHtPopMaIJ,HS ,ll,O: Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, CAIIJ., TeJI. 978-750-8400, tPaKC 978-750-4470, www.copyright.com/. BCHQKH ,ll,pyrH BbnpocH H 3anHTBaHHS, OTHaC5IIll.H ce KbM aBTopcKHTe npaBa H JIHIJ,eH3H, B TOBa qHCJIO, KbM CpO,ll,HHTe C TSX npaBa, CJIe,ll,Ba ,ll,a ce a,ll,peCHpaT ,ll,O otPHca Ha H3,ll,aTeJI5I - CBeToBHa 6aHKa, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USA, tPaKc 202-522-2422, eJIeKTpOHHa n0Ill.a: pubrights@worldbank.org. )l,H3aHH Ha KOpHIJ,aTa: DOPHC Drum6aHoB "_ · - .... I 'EKBMBAJIEH1"'HM EJJ:IIHIIIJ;II ~., ' " . - · " . - . . - " " - · · _ · - · · - - - _ · · -0 . . . . _ . __ · _ _ _ _ _ · · · _. _. _. ·· _ · · ____ · ·· _ _ _ __ · _ _ __ · __ . . _ " . _ · _ ·· _ ·· _ · _ . . . . " _ BAJIYTA b'bnrapCKH neB (nB.); BanYTeH KYPC K'bM 12 IOnH 2010 r. 1 eBpo = 1.95583 JIB. 1 IU.,Il.= 1.5557 JIB. «l>HHAHCOBArO)l,HHA 1 5lHyapH - 31 ,IleKeMBpH MEPHH E)l,HHHlJ)f BHlleupe3H,[(eUT: H KOMHCHH 3a MHHHcTepcTBo Ha ?T>T~T>~ OC 06lll.HHCKH C'bBeT ITECIT ITpoyqBaHe Ha 6H3Hec cpe)lam Ha npe)lnpmITH5ITa ITMC ITocTaHOBJIeHHe Ha MHHHCTepCKH C'bBeT ITliIT ITy6JIHQHO-QaCTHO napTHhopCTBO PI10K03 PerHOHaJIeH HHcneKTopaT 3a ona3BaHe If KOHTPOJI Ha 06lll.eCTBeHOTO 3)lpaBe PMC PeI.lIeHHe Ha MHHHCTepCKH C'bBeT CEM C'bBeT 3a eJIeKTpOHHH Me)lHH CI1P C'bBeT 3a HKOHOMHQeCKH paCTe)f( CI1Cl> CBeTOBeH HKOHOMHQeCKH CPOPYM lOJI lOpH)lHQecKo JIHu.e I1YPI1YP I1HCTHTYT 3a ynpaBJIeHCKO pa3BHTHe ECSPF OT)leJI cpHHaHcHpaHe H pa3BHTHe Ha QaCTHH5I ceKTOp NRR C'bBeT Ha I.lIBe)lCKaTa HH)lYCTpH5I H ThproBH5I 3a nO-)lo6po peryJIHpaHe Cb,lJ:1>PJKAHIIE liJIArO,l(APHOCTH .............................................................................................................viii PE3IOME ................................................................................................................................ ix rJIABA I BbBE,lJ;EHHE 1.1. 3HaqeHIfe Ha 30APAKC)l. ........................................................................................... 1 1.2. OGxBaT Ha OIJ,eHKaTa ....................................................................................................2 1.3. 113TOqHIfIJ,If Ha IfHcpopMaIJ,IfH ........................................................................................ 3 1.4. OCHOBHIf orpaHwleHIfH Ha aHaJIIf3a .............................................................................4 1.5. CTpYK'rypa Ha )J,OKlla)J,a.................................................................................................6 rJIABA II Olim KOHTEKCT HA OIl,EHKATA 2.1. PaMKa Ha rrOJIIfTIfKaTa ..................................................................................................7 2.2. OGIlJ,a IJ,eJI If CrreIJ,IfcpIfqHIf IJ,eJIIf Ha 3aKoHa ................................................................. 11 2.3. I1H)J,IfKaTopIf Ha OIJ,eHKaTa ............................................................................................ 12 rJIABA III nOCJIE,lJ;BAmA OIl,EHKA HA Bb3,lJ;EHCTBHETO HA 30APAKC,lJ; 3.l. ilpaBIfTeJICTBeHIf MepKIf If IfHIfIJ,IfaTIfBIf ...................................................................... 15 3.1.1. MepKIf 3a HaMaJIHBaHe Ha a)),MIfHIfcTpaTIfBHaTa If peryJIaTOpHaTa TeJKeCT ...·.....·...· 16 3.1.2. I1HCTIfTYIJ,IfOHaJIHIf IfHIfIJ,IfaTIfBIf ............................................................................... 19 3.1.3. 113BbpIIIeHIf OIJ,eHKIf Ha Bb3)J.CHCTBIfCTO, aHan:If3If H o6yQcHIDI ................................ 21 3.1.4. 3aKoHo)J,aTeJIHIf IfHIfIJ,IfaTIfBIf .................................................................................... 22 3.2. CbcToHHIfe If )J,IfHaMIfKa Ha KOJIIfqeCTBeHIfTe IfH)J,IfKaTopIf ......................................... 22 3.2.1. I1H)J,IfKaTopIf 3a Bb3)J,eHcTBIfe .................................................................................... 22 3.2.2. I1H)J,IfKaTOpIf 3a Herrocpe)J,cTBeHIf pe3YJITaTIf .................. ;......................................... 29 3.2.3. I1H)J,IfKaTOpIf 3a rrOCJIe)J,BaIlJ,If pe3yJITaTIf .................................................................. 29 3.3. CbcToHHIfe If )J,IfHaMIfKa Ha KaqeCTBeHIfTe IfHJ],IfKaTopIf .............................................. 34 3.3.1. ilocTIfraHe Ha IJ,e,1IfTe Ha 30APAKC)l.: pe3Y,1TaTIf OT rrpoyqBaHeTo ....................... 34 3.3.2. AHaJIIf3 Ha Ka3YCIf Ha peryJIaTOpHIf peJKIfMIf Ha MeCTHO HIfBO ................................. 36 3.4. OGoGIlJ,eHIfe Ha KO,1IfQeCTBeHIfTe If KaqeCTBeHIfTe aHaJIIf3If ........................................ 37 CbLJ:1>P'iKAHIIE ................. rJIABAIV OCHOBEH np06JIEM, nPHQHHH H CJIE~CTBHR HA np06JIEMA H nPEnOP'bKH 3A npOMEHH B 30APAKC~ 4.1. OCHOBHH npHlfHHH Ha np06JIeMa ("KopeHH Ha .lJ,'hPBOTO") ......................................... .40 4.2. CJIe.lJ,CTBHH Ha np06JIeMa ..............................................................................................42 4.3. OCHOBHH npenOp'hKH 3a npoMeHH B 30APAKC.ll. ...................................................... .44 6H6JIHOrPAcDHR ............................................................................................................... 45 nPHJIO)KEHHR npUJ10X(eHue 1: AHaJIH3 Ha C'hOTBeTCTBHeTO Ha JIHueH3HOHHHTe pe)lopMaUHH 3a C'hCTOHHHeTO Ha pe)l(HMHTe OT IIporpaMaTa 3a no .lJ,06po peryJIHpaHe 2008-2010 r ...........................................................................................51 npHJ10)KeHHe 3: 113n'hJIHeHHe Ha MepKHTe OT IIporpaMaTa 3a nO-.lJ,06po peryJIHpaHe 2008-2010 r. K'hM anpHJ12009 r. .......................................................................................... 56 npHJ1oX(eHHe 4: B'hnpOCHHK 3a COUHOJIOrHlfeCKO npoYlfBaHe cpe.lJ, 3aHHTepecoBaHHTe cTpaHH ..................................................................................................................................61 npHJ10)KeHHe 5: AHaJIl13 Ha oTroBopHTe Ha 3aHHTepecoBaHHTe cTpaHH Ha B'hnpOCHHKa OT COUHOJIOfHlfeCKOTO npoylfBaue .......................................................................................68 OueHKa Ha nOCTHraHeTO Ha ueJIHTe, 3aJIO)l(eHH B 30APAKC)"l .................................. 68 IIo.lJ,pe)l(.lJ,aHe no Ba)l(HOCT Ha ueJIHTe...........................................................................69 OueHKa Ha npHlfHHHTe, KOHTO Cn'hBaT eqmKacHoTo npHJIaraHe Ha 30APAKC.ll. .......69 fIO.lJ,Kpena Ha HanpaBeHHTe npe.lJ,JIO)l(eHHH ...................................................................70 npHJ1oX(eHue 6: 113CJIe.lJ,BaHe B'hpxy peryJIaTOpHHTe pe)l(HMH Ha MeCTHO paBHHIUe .........71 ProperneHHe 3a TaKCHMeTpoBH npeB03H ......................................................................71 KaTeropH3aUHH Ha 3aBe.lJ,eHHH 3a xpaHeHe H proBJIelfeHHH H XOTeJIH ..........................73 T'hprOBCKo y.lJ,OCTOBepeHHe (PemcTpHpaHe Ha ThprOBCKH 06eKT) ..............................75 ProperneHHe 3a CTpOe)l( ................................................................................................76 npHJ10)KeHUe 7: J1HueH3HoHHH pe)l(HMH H c'hIUeCTBYBaIUH pemcTpH C'hfJIaCHO H3HCKBaHHJlTa Ha 30APAKC.ll. ............................................................................................78 C'bJJ:1>P~J\HII:E ..... _"- ...... -_ .... _-- ..... ---_ ... _-. ... ----_._-.- ------""-_ ..... ---------_ .... --- ..... --._----_ ..... - .. _ TaoJ1uu,a 1: HH)],HKaTopH 3a H3n'bJIHeHHe, H3rr0JJ3SaHH rrpH nOCJle)],salll.aTa ou,eHKa ..................... 13 TaoJ1uu,a 2: MaKap l.fe no)]'06peHIDITa He ca rrOCTOHHHH - a rrOHHKora HMa H SJIOlliaSaHe - KJIaCHpaHeTO Ha b'bJIrapmI S "ITpaseHe Ha 6H3Hec" ce rro)]'06pjIsa CJIe)], 2004 r ............................. 25 TaOJ1Hu,a 3: IToCTHraHe Ha u,eJIHTe Ha 30APAKC)J, (s rrpou,eHT) .................................................. 35 TaoJ1uu,a 4: PaJrrpe)],eJIeHHe Ha H3CJIe)],samfTe pe)f(HMH rro 06lll.HHH ............................................. 36 TaoJ1uu,a 5: 0606lll.eHa MaTpHu,a Ha C'bCTOjIHHeTO H )],HHaMHKaTa Ha KOJIHl.feCTSeHHTe HH)],HKaTopH 3a H3rr'bJIHeHHe ............................................................................................................ 37 urypa 1: ECKaJIaTop Ha peryJIaTOpHHTe pe)f(HMH ........................................................................ 7 urypa 2: MaJI'bK 6pOll JIHu,eH3HOHHH pe)f(HMH ca H3MeHeHH OT 2003 r. HacaM .......................... 17 urypa 3: CaMO HjIKOJIKO JIHu,eH3HOHHH pe)f(HMa ca S'bSe)],eHH, a C'bSCeM MaJIKO pe)f(HMH ca OTMeHeHH S rrepHo)],a CJIe)], 2004 r. ................................................................................ 18 urypa 4: KJIaCHpaHeTO Ha b'bJIrapHjI crrope)], m06aJIHHjI HH)],eKC Ha KOHKypeHTocnoc06HocTTa Ha CH e HHCKO H He ce no)],06pjIsa ............................................................................................... 23 urypa 5: KJIaCHpaHeTo Ha b'bJIrapHjI rro HH)],eKca Ha KOHKypeHTocrroc06HoCT Ha HYP COl.fH JIeKO rro)]'06peHHe ........................................................................................................... 24 urypa 6: KJIaCHpaHeTo Ha b'bJIrapHjI cnope)], HH)J,eKCa "ITpaseHe Ha 6H3Hec" ce rro)],06pjIsa ................................................................................................................................... 26 urypa 7: b'bJIrapIDI 3aeMa 44-TO MjICTO crrope)], KJlacau,HHTa "ITpaseHe Ha 6H3Hec 2010" ............................................................................................................. 26 urypa 8: ITo HH)],eKC Ha peryJIHpaHe Ha rrpo)],YKTOBHjI rraJap b'bJIrapHjI 3aeMa )],06po MjICTO, cpaSHeHa C'bC cpe)],HOTO paSHHlll.e sEC .................................................................... 27 urypa 9: b'bJIrapCKHTe qmpMH He nocTasjIT 6H3Hec JIHu,eH3HHTe H paJpellIHTeJIHHTe cpe)], Hall-roJIeMHTe rrpel.fKH 3a 6H3Heca rrpe3 2009 r. (s rrpou,eHT) ................................................. 28 urypa 10: ~JI Ha qmpMHTe, KOHTO rrOCOl.fSaT perYJIHpaHeTo KaTO HaH-rOJIjIMaTa rrpe'fKa 3a 6H3Heca rrpe3 2009 r. (s rrpOu,eHT) .................................................................................. 28 urypa 11: BJIOlliaSaT ce CTOllHOCTHTe crrope)], CH Ha rrOKaJaTeJIHTe Te)f(eCT Ha perYJIHpaHeTo H eqmKacHocT Ha npasHaTa paMKa CJIe)], 2003 r., KaKTO H Ha nOKaJaTeJIjI rrp03pal.fHOCT Ha rrpaseHeTo Ha rrOJIHTHKH ....................................................................................... 30 urypa 12: ITo )],aHHH Ha CH Te)f(eCTTa Ha perYJIHpaHeTo S b'bJIrapHjI rrMa, )],oKaTo eqmKacHoCTTa Ha npasHaTa paMKa H rrp03pal.fHOCTTa Ha rrpaseHeTo Ha rrOJIHTHKH OCTasaT rrOl.fTH nOCTOHHHH ............................................................................................................... 31 urypa 13: HH)J,eKCHTe Ha HYP 3a b'bJIrapHjI rro OTHOllIeHHe Ha 6IOpoKpau,IDI, JIeKOTa Ha rrpaseHe Ha 6H3Hec H C'b3)],asaHe Ha cpHpMa rrpe3 2009 r. ca rro)]'06HH Ha Te3H OT 2006 r ......................................................................................................... 31 urypa 14: Crrope)], HYP MjICTOTO Ha b'bJIrapHH rro rroKaJaTeJIjI6IOpOKpau,HH e nO-JIOIliO OT Tosa rro nOKaJaTeJIHTe C'b3)],aBaHe Ha cpHpMa H JIeKOTa Ha rrpaseHe ............................ 32 urypa 15: BpeMeTo, KoeTO SHClllmIT MeHH)],)f(M'bHT Ha rrpoH3so)],cTseHa cpHpMa OT)],eJIjI 3a cnpasHHe C H3HCKBaHIDITa Ha )],'bp)f(aSHOTO peryJIHpaHe B b'bJIrapHH, e HaM~JIO C'blll.eCTseHO (2002-2009 r.)......................................................................................... 33 Hrypa 16: b'bJIrapHH ce KJlaCHpa no-)],06pe s cpasHeHHe C )],pynfTe CTpaHH OT peruoHa Ha Esporra H ll,eHTpaJIHa A3HH no 6pOH Ha )],HHTe, He06xo)]'HMH 3a nOJIYl.faSaHe Ha onepaTHBeH JIHu,eH3 npe3 2009 r ............................................................................ 34 Hrypa 17: )J,'bpSO Ha np06JIeMa.................................................................................................... 43 Kape 1: l1.3rpa)f()J,aHe Ha nHJIOTHa HHTerpau,HoHHa CHCTeMa Ha eJIeKTpOHHa 06JIaCT ..................... 19 " liJIArO,llAPHOCTM ..... " .. " " ........ ~... ... ..... . .... ....... -'"., ..... ~ " .. .. " T03H .ll,OKJIa.ll, e H3rOTBeH B paMKHTe Ha rrpO.ll,'bmKaBa~a amlJIHTHIIHa H KOHCY JITaHTCKa rrO.ll,Kperra B 06JIaCTTa Ha peryJIaTOpHaTa pecpOpMa, OKIDBaHa OT CBeTOBHa 6aHKa Ha 6'bJIrapCKOTO rrpaBHTeJICTBO B C'bTpY.ll,HHIIeCTBO C MHHHCTepCTBO Ha HKOHOMHKaTa, eHepreTHKaTa H TYpH3Ma. EKHrr'bT Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa 6eIIIe P'bKOBO.ll,eH OT EBreHH EBreHHeB, Crrell,HaJIHCT rro pa3BHTHe Ha IIaCTHH.H CeKTOp, OT.ll,eJI ,,o6pume eeponeiiCKU pecy.rtamopllu cpei>u", rrpCrrOpb'la HaUHOHaJIHa CTpaTerH5l OT )J,CBeT CThrrKH, K05lTO 6e O)J,06pCHa OT CbBcra 3a HKOHOMHQeCKa rrOJIHTHKa Ha 19 OKTOMBPH 2007 r. Te3H )J,Ba )J,OKJIa)J,a, Hape)J, C rrpoueca Ha KOHCYJITaUHH C )J,pym MHHHCTCpCTBa, 6H3Hec aCOUHaUHH H M03b'IHH TpbcToBe, Ha rrpaKTHKa rrporrpaBHxa rrbT5l Ha TIporpaMaTa 3a rro-)J,06po perYJIHpaHe 2008-2010 r., rrpHcra OT 6bJIrapCKOTo rrpaBHTCJICTBO rrpc3 2008 r. JijJyr )J,OKJIa)J, Ha CBeToBHa 6aHKa OT IOHH 2009 r. H3ThKBa Heo6xo)J,HMOCTIa OT CHCTeMeH, crrpaBe)J,JIHB H rrp03pa'IeH pelKHM Ha )J,bplKaBHHTe TaKCH. CBeToBHa 6aHKa H3rOTBH H )J,OKJIa)J, 3a a)J,MHHHcrpaTHBHHTe H perYJIaTOpHH 6apHcpH rrpc)J, 6H3Heca B bbJIrapH5l. IJ.eJITa Ha HaCTOHmaTa nOCJIe.llBama o-.eHKa Ha B'b3.lleHCTBHeTo Ha 30APAKC,LI, e: (1) .lla YCTaHOBH KaK 3aKOH'bT ce npHJIara, (2) .lla HJleHTH.H-,Hpa H o-.eHH B'b3.lleHCTBHHTa Ha 3aKoHa, H (3) .lla npe.llJI03\H npenOp'bKH 3a H3MeHeHHe H .llOn'bJIHeHHe Ha 3aKoHa. rnaea / IIO)J,'IepTaBa 3Ha'IeHHeTO Ha 3aKOHa KaTO 'IaCT OT pOJ15lTa Ha 6bJIrapCKOTo rrpaBHTCJICTBO 3a HaCbp'IaBaHe Ha perYJIaTOpHaTa pc¢opMa H rro)J,06p5lBaHC Ha 6H3Hec cpe)J,aTa; )J,c¢HHHpa o6xBaTa Ha oueHKara H rrpC)J,CTaB5l H3TO'lHHUHTe Ha H3rr0J13BaHaTa HH¢OpMaUH5l; H O'IepTaBa OCHOBHH OrpaHHQeHH5l rrpH H3BbplliBaHeTO Ha aHaJIH3a. rnaea II rrpC)J,CTaB5l paMKaTa Ha rrOJIHTHKaTa, KaTO )J,HcKyTHpa CbBMCCTHMOCTra II C rrpaBHTeJICTBeHHTe rrOJIHTHKH H rrOJIHTHKHTC Ha paBHHllJ,e EBporrellcKH CblO3 (EC), a CbllJ,O TaKa aHaJIH3Hpa H H5lKOH CrreUHaJIHH )J,OKYMeHTH Ha rrpaBHTeJICTBOTO rro BbrrpOCHTe Ha peryJIaTOpHaTa pe¢opMa. CJIe)J,Ba aHaJIH3 Ha 06llJ,aTa UeJI H crreUH¢H'IHHTe ueJIH Ha 3aKOHa, H H)J,eHTH¢HUHpaHe Ha HH)J,HKaTopHTe 3a H3rrbJIHeHHe, KOHTO ca H3rrOJI3BaHH 3a H3MepBaHC Ha Bb3)J,CllCTBHeTO Ha 3aKOHa. rnaea JJI rrpe)J,CTaB5l pe3YJITaTHTe OT rrOCJIe)J,BallJ,aTa oueHKa Ha Bb3)J,ellCTBHeTO, )J,OKaTO 3aKJIIO'lHTeJIHaTa Frzaea IV H)J,eHTH¢HUHpa OCHOBHH5l np06JIeM, pa3rJIelK)J,a rJIaBHHTe rrpH'lHHH H CJIe)J,CTBH5l Ha rrp06JIeMa H rrpe)J,JIara rrperropbKH 3a H3MeHeHHe H )J,OITbJIHCHHe Ha3aKoHa. OCH06HU pe3YllmamU &eBTBtBUBpaHe Ha OCHOBBBSI np06J1eM: lliHpOKa HaMeCa Ha ~p)I(aBaTa B CTOIIaHCKaTa )l,eiiHOCT, 113pa3.HBam;a ce B HaJIHlIHeTO Ha rOJUlM 6poii peryJIaTOpHH ~, B'bBe)l,eHH OT CIIelVlaJIHH 3aKOHll, KOeTO BO)l.H )l,O HaMaJIeHa ecpeKTHBHOCT Ha 1paH33KIijUlTe · 11 Ha KOmcypeJITOCIIOC06HOCTTa Ha HKOHOMHKaTa. OUCHKaTa CC OCHOBaBa Ha KOJlH'ICCTBCHH H Ka'lCCTBCHH aHaJlH3H. B T03H )],OKJIa)], e H3nOJI3BaH Ha60p OT KOflU'I,eCmee1lU HH)],HKaTOpH 3a H3MepBaHe Ha B'b3)],eifcTBHeTO Ha 3aKOHa H Ha nOCTHraHeTO Ha 06ll1,aTa H Cnell.HqmqHHTe My ll.eJIH B nepHO)],a OT BJIH3aHeTO My B CHJIa npe3 2004 r. )],0 KpM Ha 2009 r. I1,ueHTHeKTHBHoCT Ha npaBHaTa paMKa (KaTo HanpHMep, B ypelK)1,aHeTO Ha cnopoBe HJIH B npoTHBonOCTaBJIHeTO Ha peryJIall.HH) H np03paqHOCT npH npaBeHeTo Ha nOJIHTHKH. · I1Hll:HKaTOpH, KOHTO nOKa3BaT HanpCll:bK: 06ll1,a TelKeCT Ha peryJIHpaHeTO (KaTo HanpHMep, BpeMeTo, KoeTO BHCI1IHJIT MeHH)1,lKM'bHT H3pa3XO)],Ba 3a )],eHHocTH, CB'bp3aHH C peryJIHpaHeTO), a)1,MHHHCTpall.IDI (HanpHMep, )],OKYMeHTall.HJI, HeHYlKHO pe)],eHe Ha OnaI1IKH HJIH HeHYlKHo npe)],OCTaBJIHe Ha )],OKYMeHTH OT cTpaHa Ha 6H3Heca), JIeKOTa Ha npaBeHe Ha 6H3Hec (OTKpHTOCT Ha npaBHaTa 6H3Hec paMKa, KOHKypeHll.IDI H peryJI3IJ.HH, TPY)],OBO peryJIHpaHe) H )],pyrH. · 11 Hll:HKaTOpH, KOHTO nOKa3BaT HaU-rOJlHMO nOll:06pcHHC: )J,5IJI Ha HHHpaHe Ha BH)],OBeTe pelKHMH, KOHTO peryJIHpaT CTonaHCKaTa )]'eHHocT; 3alll,HTa Ha cB060.l1.HaTa CTonaHCKa HHHll.HaTHBa; H JICHO OqepTaBaHe Ha rpaHHll.HTe 3a a)],MHHHCTpaTHBHa HaMeca B CTonaHCKaTa .l1.eHHOCT Ha ll.eHTpaJIHO H Ha MeCTHO HHBO. Pe)],Hll.a BaiKHH ll.eJIH, 06aqe, KOHTO ca 3aJIOlKeHlf B 30APAKC,lJ., Bce olll,e He ca nOCTHrHaTH, B TOBa qHCJIO: a) yBeJIH~IaBaHe Ha np03paqHOCTTa npH B'bBelK)1,aHe Ha peryJIaTOpHH pelKHMH; 6 HaMaJIJIBaHe H3TOqHHll.HTe Ha KO IIll.IDI q e3 rry6JUIqHOCT B pa60TaTa Ha a;:WllHIfCTpanmHIfTe OpraHll rro rrpllJIaraHeTO Ha HOpMaTllBHllTe aKTOBe, CBbp3aHll C a.D.MllHllCTpaTllBHOTO peryJIllpaHe II a.D.MllHllCTpaTllBHll» KOHTPOJI BbPXY CTOrraHCKaTa .D.eifHOCT, KaKTO II Ha rrpllqllHllTe 3a T»XHaTa rrpOM»Ha; r) OrpaHllqaBaHe II HaMaJI»BaHe Ha 06IIJ,eCTBeHO HeOrrpaB.D.aHOTO 06peMeH»BaHe Ha CTOrraHCKaTa .D.eifHOCT; e) rrpeMaXBaHe Ha HopMaTllBHllTe rrpe.D.rrOCTaBKll, KOllTO MoraT .D.a .D.OBe.D.aT .D.O OrpaHllqaBaHe Ha KOHKypeHlJ;ll»Ta. · llOJIHTHKaTa 3a nO-,lJ,06po perYJIHpaHe B Ii'bJIrapHH He ce npOBejK,lJ,a nOCJIe,lJ,OBaTeJIHO H CHCTeMHO, a nO,lJ,06peHHHTa ca 6aBHH. B pe3YJITaT Ha TOBa ce Ha6JIIO.D.aBaT rrllKOBe II Crra.D.OBe B rrOCTll)KeHll»Ta Ha perYJIaTOpHaTa peMpMMTe, KOMTO KaH,nM,naTCTBaT 3a nOJIyqaBaHe Ha JIMu,eH3MM, perMcTpau,MM, pa3pellleHM5I MJIM y,nOCTOBepeHH5I, He nOJIyqaBaT ,nOCTanqHO HHI, MllHllCTepCKli CbBeT, 2009 r.; Hapb4HllK 3a 113rOTBj/He Ha OI.\eHKa Ha Bb3~eHCTBHeTO Ha 3aKOHO~aTeJICTBOTO, HIIH, 2007 r.; OI.\eHKa Ha Bb3~eHcTBlieTo Ha peryJIaI.\HHTe, IIpaKTH'IeCKIi Hapb4HllK, ACOI.\llaI.\llj/ 3a MOHIiTopllHr Ha ynpaBJIeHHeTO (CbC C'b~eHCTBHeTO Ha AAMP), Co0pMaIJ,HOHeH, HHCTHTYIJ,HOH8J1eH H HopMaTHBeH xapaKTep - I1pe)),CTaBJISlBaT OrpaHHqeHHSl 3a H3B'hplIIBaHe Ha OIJ,eHKaTa. · CnenHcJmKa Ha npaBHaTa CHCTeMa. M3I.J,SlJIO 06II1,HSlT xapaKTep H Bce06xBaTHOCTTa Ha 3aKOHa I1paBSlT MHoro TPY)),HO )),a ce Ol1pe)),eJIH )),8J1H H B KaKBa CTel1eH Ha6JIIO)),aBaHHTe B'h3)),eiicTBHSl ca pe3YJITaT HMeHHO OT ))'eiicTBHeTo Ha 30APAKC,ll, HJIH ca pe3YJITaT OT )),PYfH HHTepBeHIJ,HH, 3aKOHo)),aTeJICTBO H Q->aKTopH. B 6'hJIrapCKaTa I1paBHa CHCTeMa 3aKOHo)),aTeJIHaTa iiCpapXHJI BKJIlOqBa KOHCTHTYIJ,HJITa, 3aKOHHTe H 110)),3aKOHOBHTe HopMaTHBHH aKTOBC. D'hJIrapCKaTa I1paBHa CHCTeMa He 1103HaBa T.Hap. "KOHCTHTYIJ,HOHHH 3aKOHH", KOHTO iiepapXHqeCKH 6Hxa CTOSlJIH Ha)l 06II1,HTC 3aKOHH (30APAKC,ll e 06II1, 3aKOH) H 6Hxa peryJIHp8J1H OCHOBHHTe I1PHHIJ,HI1H, C KOHTO 06II1,HTe 3aKOHH CJIC)),Ba )),a ce C'h06p83SlBaT. B JIOrH"leCKa 110CJIe)),OBaTeJIHOCT 06II1,HTe H Cl1eIJ,H8J1HHTe 3aKOHH CJIe)),Ba )),a Cl1eIJ,HQ->HIJ,HpaT I1paBHHTC HOpMH Ha KOHCTHTYIJ,Hfla OT 06II1,HTe K'hM Cl1eIJ,H8J1HHTC 110JIO:lKeHHSl, )),OKaTO Cl1eIJ,H8J1HHTe 3aKOHH, Ha CBoii pe))" CJIe)),Ba )),a Cl1eIJ,HQ->HIJ,HpaT H 0I1epaIJ,HOH8J1H3HpaT 06IIl,HTe 3aKOHH. 3a C'h:lK8J1eHHC, Me)K)J,Y 3aKOHHTC MHoro qeCTO B'h3HHKBaT JIOrH"leCKH I1POTHBOpeqHSl. B TaKHBa CJIY"laH e He06xo)),HMO TDJIKYBaHe Ha BOJISlTa H HaMepeHHeTO Ha 3aKoHo)),aTCJISl. TaM, K'h)),eTo HMa KOHQ->JIHKT Me)K)J,y 06IIl, H CI1CIJ,H8J1eH 3aKoH, ce I1pHJIara I1paBHJIOTO Ha Cl1eIJ,H8J1HHSl 3aKOH (lex spetialis derogat generalis). TOBa I103BOJIJIBa Ha Cl1eIJ,H8J1HHTC 3aKOHH )),a c'h)),'hp:lKaT KJIaY3H H 110JIO:lKCHHJI, KOHTO npoTHBOpeqaT Ha OCHOBHHTC I1paBHJIa, C'h)),'hp:lKaIIl,H ce B 06II1,HTe 3aKOHH, H B )),CiiCTBHTCJIHOCT )),a rH OTMCHSlT. ll.(o ce OTHacSl )),0 perYJIHpaHeTO, 30APAKC,ll e 06II1, 3aKoH, KoiiTO ypc:lK)),a Haii-06IIl,HTC I1PHHIJ,HI1H Ha peryJIHpaHCTO. KOHKpeTHOTO I1pHJIO:lKeHHe Ha Te3H I1PHHIJ,HI1H B pa3JIH"lHHTe HKOHOMH"leCKH OTpaCJIH, KaTO eHcpreTHKa, TDprOBHSl, I1pOMHlIIJIeHOCT H )),p., e I1pe)),MeT Ha )),pyrH Cl1eIJ,H8J1HH 3aKOHH. TaKa Hal1pHMCp, 3aKOH'hT 3a eHepreTHKaTa I1pC)),BH)K)J,a JIHIJ,eH3HOHeH pe:lKHM 3a I1POH3BO)),HTeJIH Ha eHeprHJI C Ha)), 5 MB HHCT8J1HpaHa MOIIl,HOCT. B T03H cnyqaii, JIHIJ,eH3HOHHOTO H3HCKBaHe 110 3aKoHa 3a eHepreTHKaTa TpSl6Ba )),a e B C'hOTBeTCTBHe C 110CTaHOBKHTe Ha 30APAKC,ll. Ha npaKTHKa, MaKap H C 110-HHC'bK npaBeH cTaryT, peryJIaIJ,HHTe Ha 3aKoHa 3a eHepreTHKaTa MoraT ,n;a OTMCillIT 06II1,HTe 110JIO:lKeHHSl Ha 30APAKC,ll (KaTo Hal1pHMep c'b,n;'bp:lKaT I1paBHJIa, KOHTO I1poTHBOpeqaT Ha 06II1,HTe I1PHHIJ,HI1H Ha 30APAKC,ll). · JIHnca Ha npeLlBapHTeJJHa OneHKa Ha 3aKoHa. Hc C Hal1paBeHa I1pe,n;BapHTeJIHa OIJ,eHKa Ha 3aKoHa. nOpa)),H T83H I1pHQHHa 06II1,am IJ,CJI H Cl1eIJ,H(pHQHHTe IJ,eJIH Ha 3aKoHa, KaKTO H C'hOTBeTCTBaIIl,HTe HH,n;HKaTopH 3a H311'hJIHeHHe, He ca Q->0pMYJIHpaHH 110 SlceH Ha"lHH OT caMOTO Ha"l8J1O. He ca ol1pe,n;eJIeHH H 6830BHTe CToiiHOCTH Ha HH,n;HKaTopHTe. B H,n;e8J1HHJI cnyQaii, I1pe,n;BapHTeJIHaTa OIJ,eHKa c'h,n;'hp:lKa Ha60p OT IJ,eJIH H HH.n;HKaTopH 3a H3n'hJIHeHHe, C KOHTO III,e ce H3MepBa Hal1pe,n;'hK'hT, KaKTO H 6830BHTe cToiiHOCTH, CI1PSlMO KOHTO III,e ce OIJ,eHSlBaT eQ->eKTHTe OT B'b3,n;eiicTBHeTo. B HaCTOJIIII,HSl cJIYQaii, IJ,eJIHTe H HH,n;HKaTopHTc ca KOHcTpYHpaHH 110CJIe,n;BaIIl,O H CI1PJIMO TSlX ca onpe,n;CJIeHH H OIJ,eHeHH eQ->eKTHTe H 110JI3HTe OT 3aKoHa. · npHche~HHBBaHeTo Ha IihJlrapHB KhM EC OKala cepHolHo BJlHBHHe BhpXy HKOHOMHKaTa Ha cTpaHaTa, ThO KaTO TO H1HCKBame BhBexmaHeTO Ha MHo~eCTBO HOBH peryJlanHH. nOCJIe,n;BaIIl,aTa OIJ,eHKa Ha B'b3)),eiicTBHeTO Ha 30APAKC,ll 110KpHBa CBeTOBHa 6aHKa, OI1CP, EK, CBeToBHIUI FlKOHOMFlQeCKFI $OPYM (CI1;l t-{-JI'{\'U('\1\n.n:rp,..uu u f'nllT... ~npu [ .....' t...ci3'T' ITAr,,) h'Lnr".lnf"'fI''':l r·TvUT-::lLI ..... V<:l; V'~" .. ."n.." e.n:MH CneUMaJIeH nepMO.n: OT pa3BMTMeTO Ha HaUMOHaJIHaTa MKOHOMMKa, a MMeHHO, npeMMHaBaHeTO Ha CTpaHaTa OT pe)l(MM Ha aCOUMMpaHO K'hM n'hJ1HOnpaBHO qJIeHCTBO B EC. OT e.n:Ha CTpaHa, romlM 6POM peryJIall,MM Tp»6Baille .n:a ce ManTMpaT C orne.n: MHTerpMpaHeTO Ha E'hJIrapM» K'hM EC M HerOBMTe acquis communautaire. ,lJ,06pe M3BeCTHO e, qe M3MCKBaHM»Ta Ha 06lll,HOCTIa MMaT C'hlll,eCTBeHO BJIM»HMe B'hPXY palMepa Ha a.n:MMHMCTpaTMBHMTe PalXO.n:M.6 OT .n:pyra CTPaHa, HaJIMll,e 6eIlle CMJIeH HaTMCK M paCT»lll,a nOTpe6noCT OT onTMMM3MpaHe pOJI»Ta Ha ny6JIMqHaTa a.n:MMHMCTpall,M» B CTonaHCKaTa .n:eMHOCT M HaMaJI»BaHe Ha peryJIaTOpnaTa Te)l(eCT B'hPXy 6M3Heca. CJIe.n:OBaTeJIHO, npe3 aHaJIM3MpaHM» nepMO.n: peryJIaTOpHaTa cpe.n:a M ny6JIMQHaTa MMMHMCTpall,M» 6»xa 06eKT Ha BJIM»HMeTO Ha B3aMMHO npOTMBOpeQalll,M CM ljJaKTOpM, KoeTO HeM36e)l(HO .n:OBe.n:e .n:o KOJIe6JIMBM M HenOCJIe.n:oBaTeJIHM pe3yJITaTM. · B Ji'bJIrapHH JIHnCBa CHCTeMa 3a MOHHTopHHr Ha H3n'bJIHeHHeTO C ((OH((PeTHH ((OJIHqeCTBeHH HH~H((aTOpH 3a O~eH((a Ha a~MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa H peryJIaTOpHaTa Te2(eCT B'bpXy 6H3Heca. ,lJ,MCKYCMMTe 3a peljJopMa Ha perYJIaTOpnMTe pe)l(MMM CTapTMpaxa npe.n:M OKOJIO e.n:Ho .n:eceTMJIeTMe. 110 TOBa BpeMe 6»xa JIaHCMpaHM npOeKTM Ha ,lJ,enapTaMelITa no Me)I(.LJ:YHapo.n:HO palBMrne (DFID) Ha BeJIMK06pMTaHM» M Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa 3a HaMaJI»BaHe Ha MMMHMCTpaTMBHMTe 6apMepM npe.n: 6M3Heca. BC'hlll,HOCT, npMeMaHeTO Ha 30APAKC,lJ, e e.n:MH OT KmOQOBMTe nOKalaTeJIM 3a M3n'hJIHeHMe npM BTOPM» CTPYKTYpeH 3aeM OT CBeTOBHaTa 6aHKa 3a 6'hJIrapCKOTO npaBMTeJICTBO (PAL II), KOMTO Ha6mo.n:aBa nOCTM)I(eHM»Ta Ha npaBMTeJICTBOTO K'hM Kpa» Ha 2003 r. A C'h3.n:aBaHeTO Ha n'hpBMTe rMilleTa 3a 06CJIY)I(BaHe Ha 6M3Heca B 06lll,MHMTe BM.n:MH M l1alap.n:)I(MK e pe3YJITaT OT YCMJIM»Ta no npoeKT Ha ,lJ,enapTaMeHTa no Me)I(.LJ:YHapo.n:HO pa3BMTMe. CMcTeMaTa 3a MOHMTopMHr Ha M3n'hJIHeHMeTO, 06aQe, npo.n:'hJI)I(aBa .n:a e cJIa60 palBMTa. TOBa 3aTpy.n:H»Ba Oll,eH»BaHeTO na B'h3.n:eMcTBMeTo Ha 3aKoHa OT 2004 r. nacaM. KOJIMQeCTBeHM Oll,eHKM na I.VIJIOCTHaTa peryJIaTOpHa Te)l(eCT ce npaB»T BC»Ka ro.n:MHa OT HaM-palJIMtIHM M3TOtIHMll,M. 110H»Kora M3MepBaHM»Ta ce pa3JIMtIaBaT, ThM KaTO ce M3nOJI3Ba 7 palJIlftlHa MeT0.n:OJIOrM» 3a Oll,eH»BaHe Ha e.n:HO M C'hlll,O »BJIeHMe. OCBeH TOBa, JIMnCBaT Oll,eHKM na a.n:MMHMCTpaTMBHaTa Te)l(eCT B'hPXY CTonaHCKaTa .n:eMHocT B E'hJIrapM», KOMTO .n:a ce 6a3MpaT na 06lll,OnpMeTM MeTo.n:OJIOrMM, KaK'hBTO e Mo.n:eJI'hT Ha CTaH.n:apTHMTe pa3xo.n:M (Standard Cost Model).8 CJIe.n:oBaTeJIHO, Oll,eH»BaHeTO na B'h3.n:eMcTBMeTO Ha 3aKOHa B'hPXY HMBOTO Ha MMMHMCTpaTMBHaTa Te)l(eCT B E'hJIrapM» CJIe.n: 2004 r. e CMJIHO 3aTpy.n:HeHO. 6 KaTO H3n0JI3Ba MO)l.elIa Ha CTaH)l.apTHHTe Pa3XO)l.H (Standard Cost Model), IIIBe)l.CKaTa AreHUIDl 3a HKOHOMJ1'{eCKO H perHOHaJIHO pa3BHTHe e H.3'fHClIIDIa, 'Ie TOBa BlIIDlHHe Bb31IH3a Ha 99% OT a)l.MHHHcTpaTHBHHTe Pa3XO.ll.H B XpaHHTeJIHaTa HH.ll.YCTPillI H 73% - B CeJICKOTO CTonaHCTBO (B)I(. NRR, 2008). 7 Crrope)l. M3ClIe)l.BaHe Ha CBeToBnaTa 6aHKa, HarrpHMep, rrpeMHHaBaHeTo OT Hai'i-He61IarOnpIDITHIDl KOM Hali 6naronpilllTHMK KBapTIDI Ha 6M3Hec perynMparreTo, BO)l.M )10 rO)l.MIIIeH pbCT OT 2,3 nyHKTa na EBII (B)I(. Djankov, S., et. aI., 2006). IIpoyqBaHIDl na EBponei'icKaTa KOMHCM>l nOKa3BaT rro-cKpoMHO BnIDlnMe na nO)l.06p>lBaneTO na perylIaU;MHTe BbPXY pbcTa Ha EBII. CbrnacHo H3Cne.ll.BaHillI Ha EK, aKO B uenH>l EC ce npIDIO:JKaT MepKH 3a HaMaJJ}lBaHe Ha a)l.MHHHCTpaTMBHaTa Te:JKeCT C 25% (cbrnacHo JIHca60ncKHTe UelIH), EBII me ce nOBHIIIH Me:JK.ll.Y 1.1 M 1.9%, B 3aBHCHMOCT OT H3n0JI3BanHTe MO)l.elIH. E)1Ha cMMynauIDl Ha MO.ll.ena QUEST BO,n:M )l.0 YBenHqenHe na EBII C OKono 0.3% npe3 2020 r., KaTO eeKTbT MO:JKe.ll.a e OT nopH,n:bKa Ha 0.7%, aKO na3apHTe ca .ll.OCTaThqnO rDBKaBH H KOHKypeHTHH. Cnope)l. cHMynaI~illI C .ll.pyr MO)l.en (WorldScan), EBII me ce nOBHIIIM C 0.6% .ll.0 2020 r. 3a EC (EC, 2007). IIo-HaTaThK, B KOHBepreHTHaTa nporpaMa Ha EbnrapIDl 3a 2009-2012 r. (2010) ca nOCO'leHH .ll.Be pa3J1M'IHH ou;eHKH Ha BnIDlHMeTO Ha HaMaJJ}lBaHeTO Ha a)l.MHHHcrpanmHaTa TeJKeCT BbPXY 6H3Heca. Cnope)3, nbpBaTa oueHKa, HaMaJIeHHeTO Ha perYlIaTopHaTa Te:JKeCT C 20% 6H .ll.OBenO )3,0 HapacTBaHe Ha EBII C 0.72% )l.0 2025 r., a cnope,n: BTopaTa - C 1,44%. B nO-)l.aJIe'lno 6b)l.eme, )l.0 2055 r., CbrnaCHO H3Cne)3,BaHe Ha NRR (2009) e H3'1HCneHO, 'Ie TOBa 6H )l.OnpHHeCJIO 3a HapacTBaHe Ha EBII 3a nepHO)l.a C 1,6%. ,D,pyrn H3CJIe)l.OBaTelIH ca H3qHCJIHnH, 'ie «... B .n:op:JKaBHTe, KOHTO He ca H3nbJIHMlIH Bce06xBaTHH nporpaMH 3a peryJIaTOpHa peopMa, KaTO EbnrapIDl, rrpeKHTe pa3XO)3,H 3a rrpe)l.rrpIDlTIDlTa Bb3J1H3aT Ha 10% )l.0 15% OT EBII» (BJK. ,D,JKeliKb6c EH)J, ACOIIIHeihc IOpbrr JIHMHTIi,ll H HHCTHTyr 3a rra3apHa HKOHOMHKa, 2009). Ta3H ou;eHKa 06a'le He BKJIIOqBa HaMaJIeHaTa eeKTHBHOCT Ha HKOHOMHKaTa. 1.5 CmpYKmypu HU i)OJUlui)u CJIe)l,BamaTa T:7aea 11 Ha )l,OKJIa)l,a pa3rneJK)l,a 06mHSI KOHTeKCT Ha 30APAKCll. H Ha OIJ,eHKaTa. TSI )l,eqmHHpa paMKaTa Ha rrOJIHTHKaTa, 06maTa IJ,eJI H CrreIJ,H¢HqHHTe IJ,eJIH Ha 3aKoHa, H rrpe)l,CTaBSI Ha60pa OT HH)l,HKaTOpH, KOHTO ce H3rrOJI3BaT 3a H3MepBaHe Ha H3ITbJIHeHHeTO. T:7aea 111 rrpe)l,CTaBSI pe3YJITaTHTe OT rrOCJIe)l,BamaTa OIJ,eHKa Ha Bb3)l,eHCTBHeTo. TIbPBHSlT rro)l,pa3)l,eJI rrpe)l,JIara )l,OITbJIHHTeJIHH aHaJIH3H Ha MepKHTe Ha rrpaBHTeJICTBOTO 3a HaMaJISlBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa TeJKeCT BbPXY 6H3Heca, pa3JIHqHHTe HHCTHTYIJ,HOHaJIHH HHHIJ,HaTHBH, HanpaBeHHTe OIJ,eHKH Ha Bb3)l,eHCTBHeTo (OB) H npOBe)l,eHH o6yqeHHSI, KaKTO H 3aKOHO)l,aTeJIHHTe HHHIJ,HaTHBH. fJIaBaTa KOM6HHHpa KOJIHqeCTBeHH H KaqeCTBeHH MeTO)l,H Ha aHaJIH3. ll.orrbJIHHTeJIHHTe KaqeCTBeHH MeTO)l,H ce OCHOBaBaT Ha: (1) COIJ,HOJIOmqeCKO npoyqBaHe cpe)l, KJIlOqOBH 3aHHTepecoBaHH cTpaHH no BbnpocH OTHOCHO H3nbJIHeHHeTO Ha OCHOBHaTa H CneIJ,H¢HqHHTe IJ,eJIH Ha 30APAKCll. H rnaBHHTe HHcTpYMeHTH 3a TSlXHOTO rrOCTHraHe, H (2) CrreIJ,HaJIHO co6cTBeHo H3CJIe)l,BaHe BbPXY npHJIOJKeHHeTO Ha qeTHpH perYJIaTOpHH peJKHMa Ha HHBO MeCTHa a)l,MHHHCTpaIJ,HSI. BTopHSlT nO)l,pa3)l,eJI npe)l,CTaBSI CbCTOSlHHeTO H )l,HHaMHKaTa Ha HH)l,HKaTOpHTe 3a Bb3)l,eHCTBHe H HH)l,HKaTOpHTe 3a pe3YJITaTH. B KpaSl Ha rnaBaTa ca o606meHH HaH-BaJKHHTe pe3YJITaTH H H3BO)l,H OT nOCJIe)l,BamaTa OIJ,eHKa Ha Bb3)l,eHCTBHeTo. Ha OCHOBaTa Ha nOCJIe)l,BamaTa OIJ,eHKa Ha Bb3)l,eHCTBHeTO Ha 30APAKCll., B nOCJIe)l,HaTa T:7aea IV e H)l,eHTH¢HIJ,HpaH OCHOBHHSlT np06JIeM, pa3rne)l,aHH ca rJIaBHHTe npHqHHH H CJIe)l,CTBHSI OT np06JIeMa H ca HanpaBeHH OCHOBHH rrpenopbKH 3a nO)l,06pSlBaHe Ha 3aKoHa B TpH 06JIaCTH: HHcTPYMeHTaJIHa, HHCTHTYIJ,HOHaJIHa H HKOHOMHqeCKa. rJIABAII OBIU KOHTEKCT HA OUEHKATA l~(lWjU OlJ(?[)l]Ullj(l ]JClAU((ll1W HO nO//u171W((117UZ, 1(W110 lW32JleJ/f()u 'T,(LHCCmlVdOC17l C npCWWne/lCnWeHWne nO/lWIHlKU II IIh'W1W I llW:W EGlJOllei'ic}(u ('"6103 (Ee), KWO}W U Ii aOKy.llCW7Ul, Cf3"bjJ3(1JW C pe2lj;wnwpUU171U peqjop.HG. CJze(k:a W{(1.;7U3 lUI 06U{GlJW II cnequgJUllHwne qe/IU NO ,3wanw II mw/)uqupUJll' lUI ltHdlllannopwne, llpe.3 l{OWnU c(:' 2.1. PUMKa na nO.llUmUKama llOJ1HTHKaTa Ha nO-,llo6po peryJ1HpaHe e OCHOBeH npHopHTeT Ha EC, Tbi i KaTO TH e Ba~eH fj)aKTop 3a nOCTHraHe Ha ueJ1HTe Ha JIHca60HcKaTa cTpaTerHH. Y C'bB'bpllleHCTBaHeTo Ha peryJIaIJ,HHTe HMa 3a IJ,eJI ,lla OCHryPH 3aIIJ,HTaTa Ha rryfiJIHqHHTe HHTepecH rro Ha~IHH, KOHTO .a;a rro.a;Kpeml, a He .a;a rrpeqH Ha pa3BHTHeTO Ha HKOHOMHqeCKaTa aKTHBHOCT. PeryJIaTOpHaTa paMKa H YCJIOBHR.Ta, KOHTO .a;'bpiKaBaTa C'b3.a;aBa 3a pa3BHTHe Ha fiH3Heca, ca cpe.a; OCHOBHHTe aKTOpH 3a B'b3.a;eiicTBHe B'bpXY HeroBaTa aKTHBHOCT H 3a CTHMYJIHpaHe Ha HKOHOMHqeCKIUI paCTeiK. EK CTapTHpa rrpe3 2002 r. MalIJ,afiHa rrporpaMa 3a YC'bB'bpllleHCTBaHe Ha aLJ;MHHHCTpaTHBHoTO perYJIHpaHe . .L1.'bpiKaBHTe-qJIeHKH Ha EC 3arrOQHaxa rrOeTarrHH .a;eiicTBHR. 3a rro.a;ofipR.BaHe Ha fiH3Hec cpe.a;aTa H Ha KaqeCTBOTO Ha HOBOTO 3aKOHo.a;aTeJICTBO, 3a .a;a ce rro.n:OfiPH KOHKYpeHTOCrrocofiHocTTa Ha eBporreiicKaTa HKOHOMHKa. 3aKOHO,llaTeJ1HHTe nporpaMH Ha eBponeiicKHTe ,ll'bp~aBH HaC'bp1JaBaT HaMaJ1HBaHeTO Ha HaMecaTa Ha ,ll'bp~aBaTa. TIpHHIJ,Hrr'bT, KoiiTO TpaiiHo e 3aJIerHaJI B 3aKOHo.a;aTeJIHHTe rrporpaMH Ha eBporreiicKHTe .a;'bpiKaBH, e HaMaJIR.BaHe Ha HaMecaTa Ha .a;'bpiKaBaTa, a KoraTO HaMecaTa e HeH36eiKHa, peiKHMHTe ce rpa.a;HpaT B rrOCOKa OT "rrO-TeiK'bK" K'bM "rro-cJIafi" (BiK. cI>Hrypa 1). I cJ)Hrypa 1: ECKanaTOp Ha perynaTopHHTe pem_H_M_H_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Q ~---------------------------------------------------- KOHTpO.lI CBo6o~a HaH-TeJKKIDIT peJKHM (OT me)l,Ha TOqKa Ha )l,bpJKaBHaTa HaMeCa) e JIHll,eH3HpaHeTO, )l,OKaTO HaH-JIeKHHT peJKHM e YBe)l,OMJIeHHeTO (BJK. Hrypa 1). B paMKHTe oa EC aJITepOaTHBoH CPOPMH KaTO "C'bperyJIHpaOe" H "caMoperyJIHpaOe" OT cTpaoa oa 6H30eca C'bUJ.O ce C1JHTaT 3a "no-llo6po peryJIHpaoe". EK npellJIOXm oOBa aM6HlJ,H030a nporpaMa 3a OaMaJIHBaOe oa oeoyxcuaTa TejKeCT. Ha OCHOBaTa Ha 06HOBeHaTa JIHca60HCKa CTpaTerHH rrpe3 2006 r. EK rrpe)l,JIO)l(H HOBa, OII.J,e rro aM6Hll,H03Ha rrporpaMa 3a HaMaJIHBaHe Ha HeHY)l(HaTa a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHa TeJKeCT OT CbII.J,eCTBYBaII.J,OTO 3aKOHOBO YCTPOHCTBO B EBporreHcKIDI Cb103. E)l,HO rO)l,HHa rrO-KbCHO EBponeHcKHHT CbBeT 0)l,06PH 06II.J,HOCTHa ueJI 3a pe)l,yUHpaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa Te)l(eCT C 25%)l,0 Kpa» Ha 2012 r. 3a lla oTroBopH oa lJ,eJITa oa HOBaTa nporpaMa Ha EC, Ji'bJIrapHH pa3pa6oTH oaU;HOOaJIOH nporpaMH C MepKH 3a HaMaJIHBaHe oa allMHoHcTpaTHBHHTe 6apHepH H YJIeCOHBaHe C'blllaBaOeTO oa 6JIarOnpHHToa 6H30ec cpella. B OTfOBOP Ha HOBaTa HHHUI1aTHBa Ha EC B 06JIaCTTa Ha rro-)l,06pOTO perYJIHpaHe nbJIrapHH propa60TH )l,Be CneUHaJIHH rrpOrpaMH, a HMeHHO: HaUHOHaJIHaTa nporpaMa 3a pe¢opMH (2007-2009 r.) H IIporpaMaTa 3a rro-)l,06po perYJIHpaHe 2008-2010 r., KOHTO ca npe)l,CTaBeHH rrO-)l,OJIY. HalJ,HOOaJIOaTa nporpaMa 3a pecpopMH (2007-2009 r.) e OCOOBeo cTpanrH1JeCKH lloK:yMeoT oa 6'bJIrapCKOTo npaBHTeJICTBOTO, KoiiTo OKa3a B'bl}leUCTBHe 8'bpXy MepKHTe 3a nO}106pHBaHe oa 6H30ec cpellaTa. )],oKYMeHThT HMarne 3a ueJI )l,a cHcTeMaTH3Hpa YCHJIHHTa Ha )l,bp)l(aBHaTa a)l,MHHHcTPauHH, HenpaBHTeJICTBeHHH ceKTop H COll,HaJIHHTe napTHhopH 3a pe¢opMHpaHe Ha 6bJIrapCKaTa HKOHOMHKa C ome)l, rrOCTHraHeTO Ha BHCOKH H YCTOHqHBH TeMrrOBe Ha HKOHOMHqeCKH paCTe)l( H YBeJIHqaBaHe Ha 3aeTOCTTa B cTpaHaTa. TOBa e nbpBaTa Hall,HOHaJIHaTa rrporpaMa 3a pe¢opMH (HIIP) 3a nbJIrapHH, KOHTO 6erne rrpe)l,CTaBeHa Ha EK H Ha OCTaHaJIHTe )l,bp)l(aBH-qJIeHKH B HaqaJIOTO Ha MapT 2007 r. 3a oTrrpaBHa TOqKa Ha TroH rrporpaMa ca H3rrOJI3BaHH llHTerpHpaHHTe HaCOKH 3a paCTe)l( H 3aeTOCT, rrperrOpbqBaHH OT EC npH ¢OpMYJIHpaHeTo Ha rrOJIHTHKH H MepKH 3a rrOCTHraHeTO Ha ueJIHTe Ha 06HoBeHaTa JIHca60HcKa cTpaTefHH. BCbII.J,HOCT, HIIP 6erne propa60TeHa B OTroBOp Ha rrpe)l,H3BHKaTeJICTBaTa, rrOCTaBeHH rrpe)l, )l,bp)l(aBHTe-qJIeHKH Ha EC B 06HOBeHaTa JIHca60HcKa cTpaTefHH. TH e cTpaTerHqeCKH )l,OKYMeHT, KOHTO OqepTaBa Cpe)l,HOCpOqHaTa paMKa OT MepKH H rrpHopHTeTH Ha npaBHTeJICTBOTO B 06JIaCTTa Ha MaKpo- H MHKPOHKOHOMHqeCKOTO proBHTHe, nroapa Ha Tpy)l,a H proBHTHeTO Ha qOBernKHH KarrHTaJI. E)l,Ha OT crreUH¢HqHHTe rrpHopHTeTHH 06JIaCTH Ha HIIP e rrO)l,06p5lBaHe Ha 6H3Hec Cpe)l,aTa. )],eHcTBIDITa Ha 6bJIrapCKOTo rrpaBHTeJICTBO 6Hxa HaCOqeHH KbM HaJIaraHe H YTBbp)l()l,aBaHe Ha rrpHHUHnHTe Ha )l,06POTO yrrpaBJIeHHe, KaTO ce ThpCH OnTHMaJIHOTO CbOTHorneHHe Me)l()l,Y a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHo perymlpaHe H onpOCTHBaHe Ha OT)l,eJIHHTe a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHH pe)l(HMH. IJ.eJIerne ce H HaMaJIHBaHe Ha BpeMeTo 3a H3)l,aBaHe Ha JIHueH3H H propernHTeJIHH 3a 6H3Heca. HIIP rrpe)l,BH)l()l,arne rrO)l,06p5lBaHe Ha 6H3Hec Cpe)l,aTa B )l,Be OCHOBHH HanpaBJIeHHH: )l,06po ynpaBJIeHHe B )l,bp)l(aBHaTa a)l,MHHHCTpaUHH H HaMaJI5lBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe H perYJIaTOpHH 6apHepH rrpe)l, npe)l,npHeMaqeCTBoTo. ,lJ,pyra CnelJ,HcpH1JOa nporpaMa e llporpaMaTa 3a nO-}lo6po peryJIHpaHe 2008-2010 r. IIpe3 2008 r. MHHHcTepcKHHT CbBeT 0)l,06pH IIporpaMa 3a nO-)l,06po peryJIHpaHe 3a rrepHO)l,a 2008 2010 r., HaCOqeHa KbM nOCTHraHe Ha YCTOHqHBOCT Ha rrpoll,eca 3a Cb3)l,aBaHe Ha )l,06pa perYJIaTOpHa cpe)l,a. IJ;eJITa Ha IIporpaMaTa 6erne HaCOqeHa KbM HaMaJIHBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe rrpeqKH rrpe)l, 6H3Heca H rrO)l,06p5lBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHoTO peryJIHpaHe. OqaKBarne ce H3rrbJIHeHHeTO Ha IIporpaMaTa.n;a Cb3)l,a)l,e cpe.n;a 3a npOBe)l(.n;aHeTO Ha e¢eKTHBHa rrOJIHTHKa 3a no-.n;06po peryJIHpaHe B nbJIrapHH B KOHTeKCTa Ha JIHca60HcKaTa CTpaTerHH Ha EC, Hall,HOHaJIHaTa rrporpaMa 3a pe¢opMH (2007-2009 r.), CTpaTerHHTa 3a HaCbpqaBaHe Ha HHBeCTHUHHTe (2005-2010 r.) H Hall,HOHaJIHaTa cTpaTerHH 3a HaCbpqaBaHe Ha MaJIKHTe H Cpe)l,HHTe npe.n;npIDITHH (2007- 2013 r.). PeaJIH3HpaHeTo Ha MepKHTe Ha IIporpaMaTa 3a rro-.n;06po perYJIHpaHe HMarne 3a ll,eJI .n;a 3alIJ,HTaBa 06lIJ,eCTBeHHTe HHTepeCH. 3a rrOCTHraHeTO Ha Ta3H ll,eJI, Ii'hJIrapH5I Tp5l6BaIIJe )l,a IBrpa,IJ,H )l,OCTaThqeH Karrall,HTeT 3a C6JIll)KaBaHe C )l,06pHTe eBponeiicKH peryJIaTOpHH npaKTHKH. B llporpaMaTa ca o6oco6eHH qeTHpH cnell,mlmqHH ll,eJIH, HaCOqeHH K'hM HaMaJI5IBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe npeqKH npe)l, 6H3HeCa H nO)l,06p5lBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHOTO perYJIHpaHe, KaKTO CJIe)l,Ba: · llpeMaxBaHe H 06JIeKqaBaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHH pe)KHMH; · C'h3)l,aBaHe H YKpenBaHe Ha HHCTHTyll,HOHaJIHaTa CTpYKTypa 3a npHJIaraHeTO H KOHTpOJIa Ha nOJIHTHKaTa 3a nO-)l,06po peryJIHpaHe; · AKTHBH3HpaHe Ha )l,HaJIOra C'hC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH; · YC'hB'hpIIJeHCTBaHe Ha peryJIHpaHeTO Ha 06lIJ,HHCKO HHBO H YKpenBaHe Kanall,HTeTa Ha 06JIaCTHO H 06lIJ,HHCKO HHBO 3a npOBe)K)l,aHe Ha )l,06PH perYJIaTOpHH nOJIHTHKH. 3a H3n'hJIHeHHeTO Ha ll,eJIHTe Ha llporpaMaTa ca pa3pa60TeHH KOHKpeTHH MepKH. 3a nOCTHraHe Ha n'hpBaTa Cnell,HqmqHa ll,eJI, npe)l,BH)l,eHaTa M5IpKa BKJIfOqBaIIJe H3B'hpIIJBaHe Ha CHCTeMaTHqeH nperJIe)l, 3a OTCTpaH51BaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe npeqKH H nO)l,06p5lBaHe Ha peryJIHpaHeTO Ha CTOnaHCKaTa )l,eiiHOCT B C'hTpY)l,HHqeCTBO C'hC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH. KaTO HaqaJIHa CThnKa B Ta3H HaCOKa 651xa npe)l,BH)l,eHH KOHKpeTHH a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHH pe)KHMH, KOHTO )l,a 6'h)l,aT npeMaxHaTH H 06JIeKqeHH no npe)l,JIO)KeHH5I Ha 6H3Hec opraHH3all,HHTe. B llporpaMaTa 6e BKJIIOqeHa H M5IpKa B'hB Bp'h3Ka C aHra)KHMeHTa Ha Ii'hJIrapH5I no H3rr'hJIHeHHeTO Ha llporpaMaTa 3a )l,eiiCTBHe Ha EK 3a HaMaJI5IBaHe Ha HeHY)KHH5I a,IJ,MHHHCTpaTHBeH TOBap OT C'hlIJ,eCTBYBalIJ,OTO 3aKOHOBO YCTpoiiCTBO B EBponeiicKH5I C'hI03. llpeMaxBaHeTo HJIH 06JIeKqaBaHeTO Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe pe)KHMH, B'hBe)K)l,aHeTO Ha aJlTepHaTHBH Ha perYJIHpaHeTO H HaMaJI5IBaHeTO Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHH5I TOBap Tp5l6Bame )l,a ce H3B'hpIIJBaT KaTO ce OTqHTa pOJI5ITa Ha )l,'hp)KaBaTa 3a Ona3BaHe Ha Hall,HOHaJIHaTa CHryPHOCT H 06lIJ,eCTBeHH5I pe)l" H3KJIfOqHTeJIHHTe H CYBepeHHHTe npaBa no CMHC'hJIa Ha qJI. 18, aJI. 1-4 Ha KOHCTHTYll,H5ITa Ha Peny6JIHKa Ii'hJIrapH51, KaKTO H Heo6xo)l,HMOCTTa 3a 3alIJ,HTa Ha JIHqHHTe H HMYlIJ,eCTBeHHTe npaBa Ha rpa)K)l,aHHTe H IOpH)l,HqeCKHTe JIHll,a H Ha OKOJIHaTa cpe)l,a. qacT OT MepKHTe no n'hpBara Cnell,HqmqHa ll,eJI Ha llporpaMaTa 3a nO-)l,06po perYJIHPaHe 651xa CB'hp3aHH H C )l,eiiHOCTHTe no HHTerpHpaHe Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe yCJIyrH Ha npHHll,Hna "enH30)l,H OT )KHBOTa" H "6H3Hec C'h6HTH5I" C ll,eJI Y JIeCH5IBaHe H OnpOCT5IBaHe Ha )l,OCT'hna H npe)l,OCTaB5IHeTO Ha KOMnJIeKCHH YClIYrH Cneu.uanHo BHUMaHue Ha peeJI0pMupaHeTo Ha perynaTopHuTe pe~UMU e OT.lleneHO U B .llpyru Hau.UOHanHU cTpaTerUqeCKU .ll0KYMeHTu. TaKHBa cTpaTerUqeCKH )l,OKYMeHTH ca: HaU:HOHaJIHaTa CTpaTemqeCKa pepqaBaHe Ha npe)l,npHeMaqeCTBOTo, 6JIarOnpH5ITHaTa 6H3HeC cpe)l,a H )l,06pOTO ynpaBJIeHHe". CTpaTerHqeCKHTe npHopHTeTH Ha HCPP ca )l,OPa3BHTH B Ce)l,eM Hall,HOHeKTH H Bb3,ll.eHCTBH5I Ha peryJIHpaHeTO BbPXY rrpeKHTe u.efleBH rpynH H ,ll.pymTe 3aHHTepeCOBaHH CTpaHH (B)K. Ta6flHu.a 1). Crreu.Hq>HQHHTe u.eflH npe,ll.CTaB5IT rro-HerrOCpe,ll.CTBeHHTe pe3YflTaTH H rrOCfle,ll.Hu.H OT HHTepBeHu.H5ITa 3a CbOTBeTHHTe u.efleBH rpyrrH. IIo TalH npHQHHa Crreu.Hq>HQHHTe u.eflH HMaT nO-BH,ll.HM H H3MepHM xapaKTep B cpaBHeHHe C rro-llIHpoKaTa u.efl. ,[(pyroTo CbIll,eCTBeHO palflHQHe Me)K,ll.y ,ll.BeTe rpyrrH u.eflH e TOBa, Qe ,ll.OKaTO rrOCTHraHeTO Ha cneu.Hq>HQHHTe u.eflH e cBbp3aHo C KOHKpeTHa HHTepBeHu.H5I, nOpO,ll.eHa OT KOHKpeTeH 3aKOH HflH cneu.HaJIHH nporpaMH, TO nOCTHraHeTO Ha 06Il1,aTa u.efl e no,ll. BflH5IHHeTO Ha rro-mHpOK Kpbr OT 3aKOHH, rrporpaMH HflH cbBKyrrHocT OT crreu.HaJIHH HHTepBeHu.HH. nOpa,ll.H pa3JIH'IHOTO C'b,ll.'bp~aHHe H POJIH Ha OOmaTa ueJi H cneUH.H'IHHTe ueJiH HMa C'bmeCTBeHH pa3JIH'IHH npH nO,ll.Oopa H .OpMYJIHpaHeTO Ha HH,ll.HKaTOpHTe 3a H3MepBaHeTO HM. IIH,ll.HKaTopHTe 3a H3MepBaHe Ha 06Il1,aTa u.efl ca cBbp3aHH C 06Il1,OTO CbCT05lHHe H ou.eHKHTe 3a KOHKypeHTocnoc06HoCT Ha cTpaHaTa, fleKOTaTa 3a npaBeHe Ha 6H3HeC H a,ll.MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa Te)KeCT. IIH,ll.HKaTopHTe, H,ll.eHTHq>Hu.HpaHH B Ta6flHu.a 1, npe,ll.CTaBfl5lBaT e,ll.HH H,ll.eaJIeH Ha60p, KOHTO MO)Ke ,ll.a 6b,ll.e npOMeH51H 3a BC5IKa KOHKpeTHa cHTYau.H5I H CTpaHa, B 3aBHCHMOCT OT HaJIHQHeTO H Ha,ll.e)K,ll.HOCTTa Ha CTaTHCTHQeCKaTa HHq>0PMaU.H5I. IIpH e,ll.Ha rro-HecHrypHa CHTYaU.H5I e rro-,ll.06pe KOflHQeCTBeHHTe HH,ll.HKaTOpH,ll.a ce ,ll.OnbflH5IT C KaQeCTBeHH aHaJIH3H, 6alHpaHH OCHOBHO Ha KOHKpeTHH H3Cfle,ll.BaHH5I, npoYQBaHH5I H HHTepBlOTa, KaKTO e nOKalaHO B HaCT05lIll,H5I ,ll.OKfla,ll.. I Ta6mtu,a l' IiIHAMKaTopM 3a M3n'bJIHeHMe, M3non3BaHM npM ou,eHKa Ha Bb3AeHCTBMeTo Ha 30APAKCA D;eJ1 E+eKT BIIJI. fta IIH,IlIIKIlTOpa RrrO'IIIIIK fta HHtoPMllQllfl 0 )J,a orpaHH'lH )];0 06meCTBeHO B Ii orrpaBp:aHH rpaHHUH b KOJIII'leeTBeHU IIH,IlIIKIlTOpU lQ a)l;MHIIHCTpaTHBHOTO perylIHpaHe H 3 A KOHTPOJIa BbPXY 6H3Heca Ii p:a )J, 1. TeMII Ha HapaCTBaHe Ha 6BfI. HCM, CBeToBHa 6aHKa rrOBHIJ1H KOHKYpeHTOCIlOc06Hocrra E 2. I1H)];eKCIi Ha I - TIpaBeHe Ha 61i3HeC, D; Ha CTPanaTa. H KOHKypeHTOCrroc06HoCT. CM, HYP, OMCP, E C 3. I1H)J;eKCH 3a JIeKOTa Ha rrpaBeHe Ha Mo)];eJI Ha JI T 6H3nec. CTaHAapnlHTe pa3xon:H B 4. TIoKa3aTeJIH 3a a)l;MHHHcTPaTHBHa H Te)KeCT. E Ka'leeTBeHU IIH,IlIIKIlTOpH MHeHillI Ha Kmo'lOBHTe COUHOJIOrn'leCKO 3aHHTepecoBaHH cTPaHH rro rrpoY'lBaHe rrOCTHraHeTO Ha OfimaTa ue:I. 1. 3aIJ1HTa Ha CB060tVIaTa PECYPCH, CTOrraHCKa HHHUHaTIiBa. HEIIOCPE)J.- KOJIHIIeeTBeHU IIH,IlIIKIlTOpft 2. jlCHO O'lepTaBaHe Ha rpaHHUHTe CTBEHH C 3a a)l;MHHHc'rpaTHBHa HaMeCa B PE3YJITATH 1. Te)KeCT Ha perYJIHpaHeTo. IT CTorraHCKaTa n:CMHOCT Ha 2. EIi>HKacHocT Ha rrpaBHara paMKa. HaUHOHaJIeH E UCHTPaJUIO H Ha MeCTHO HHBO. n 3. PaBHHme Ha 61OpoKpaTH'IHocT. CTaTHCTH'IeCKH D; 3. OrpaHH'IaBaHe H rrOCTOJlHHO 4. JIeKoTa Ha rrpaBeHe Ha 6H3Hec. HHCTHTyT, H naMamIBane Ha 06meCTBenO ITOCJIE,lJ.BA 5. )].JiJI OT BpeMCTO, rrOCBeTeHO Ha fIpoY'lBaHe Ha 6H3Hec HHaHcoBH pa3XOJJ:H Ha 6H3Heca THJITa (IffiCm q 4. TO'lHO n:eli>HHHpane na H CBCToBHa 6aHKa 3a nOKpHBane Ha H BHn:OBeTe pe)KHMH, KOHTO a)l;MHHHCTparHBHaTa Te)KeCT. M3CJIen:BaHe na H peryJIHpaT CTorraHCKaTa 7. )].JiJI Ha li>HpMIiTe, onpen:e.JU!mH rrpen:rrpilllTIiJl, ,[IeHHocT. pe)KHMIiTe KaTO OCHOBen rrpo6JIeM TIpaBeHe Ha 61i3HeC, n; 5. Y BeJIHqaBaHe Ha Ha p;eHHocrra CH. OMCP, MC, M, E npo3paqHOCrra npli BbBe)K,1laHe 8. liPOM Ha peryJIaTOpHHTe pe)KHMH HapoP;Ho cb6paHHe, JI Ha pery.rfH'IHHTe f.\eJIII. TeXHHTe ,n:eikTBillI. H3CJIC;J,BaHillI, IUrrepBIOTa H 06cb)K,1laHHJI. IA"'TntlU."U' r ..... rT".:lCOU:l t"\T :::Ii£lTnnlATCt HHouKamopu Ja 6'bJOeUCm6Ue (Oucomes) I1HAHKaTOpHTe 3a B'b3AeifcTBHe ca CB'bP3aHH C nOCTHraHeTO Ha 06rn;aTa ueJI. Te ce OTHaCHT K'bM nO-llIHpOKHTe nOCJIeAHUH OT nOJIHTHKaTa H H3JIH3aT H3B'bH npHKOTO H HenOCpeACTBeHO BJIHHHHe B'bpXy UeJIeBHTe rpynH. TaKHBa HHAHKaTOpH ca, KaKTO CJIeABa: (1) I1HAHKaTopH 3a HKOHOMHqeCKH B'b3AeHCTBHH (TeMn Ha HapaCTBaHe Ha EBII, HHAeKCH Ha KOHKYpeHTOCnoc06HoCT, HHAeKCH 3a npaBeHe Ha 6H3Hec, nOKroaTeJIH 3a MMHHHcTpaTHBHa Te)l(ecT); (2) I1HAHKaTOpH 3a COUHaJIHH B'b3AeHCTBHH (3aeTocT H nroap Ha TpYAa, COUHaJIHO BKJIloqBaHe, HHAeKCH 3a A06po A'bp)l(aBHO ynpaBJIeHHe H aAMHHHCTpaIJ,HH, IIy6JIHqHOCT H HHj)GUJl nOapa30e':1 en mOUOl/eHl1 OOn6J11IUme/1HU WW//1CW C 02.lZeU npeoDW15WWle HCl ()Z]J0}-{u t lerWJI111<1 U3(-npWHWle nOCJWdHmqumu oqeHKO. Te311 IlG 11 UI1WJIWJ (Hlll/W311 ce OClWGUHWn Ita: (1) COl{U(U102ll 1 IeClfO npolPwwle l{JHOlWGll 3Ull1nnepeCOBlll-iLl cmpww 110 B-MljJOCLl Ol1UIOCIW lL"3111dlteH.llenW lW ()6u~UJna qe/l u cnel~U¢W--l1-l11me qe./ll1 LU 30APAl{C'!f: U ) cnequcv11w Il.3CJle(kWHC 1IQ ltemUjHl pez!pWmOjJllU pe.}fCZt:HU ria HUBO Aleennw (l(1,"HlllllcmpaZpl51. BmOp1l51111 11 Oc}PC13 cJeJI npe(krnaRH peay.CUTla11lume no llllrhncwnopu ;:W H7},')uetlCITUwe II llHDW{W1l0pU 3Ct pe3y./1mW1HI. HW)UKwnOln1771e 311 G:10JfCeUU pecypcll HC ca WW}W.3Upmlll noparJu OClfO(-31Hl1ne OZpal-llllleHU51 npea Ol!CHKwna. dW'KymupalHl no-c~ope. lIOC.lled'-{(lma l{(Icm 11(1 2/WBonw o(jo6U{OGO lwil-(-UlJlf}lllme pe3.ljJll1WmU 11 3{l1C/IU)l{ellW-L 3.1 IIpa8umellCJn8eHu MepKu U uHuquamu8u OT HaqaJIOTO Ha 2004 r. HacaM 6'bJIrapCKOTo npaBIfTeJICTBO IfHIfUIfIfpa pe,llHua .ll.eHHOCTIf 3a MO.ll.epHIf3IfpaHe Ha peryJIIfpaHeTo. C DIXHOTO If3n'bJIHeHIfe, o6aqe, e nOCTIfrHaT caMO qaCTIftleH ecpeKT If He e rapaHTHpaHa CIfCTeMHOCT If YCTOHqIfBOCT Ha npoueca no C'b3,lJ,aBaHe Ha nO-.ll.o6pa perynaTOpHa cpe.ll.a. ITpe.ll.npHeTHTe HHHIJ,HaTHBH B OOJIaCTTa Ha aJl:MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa H peryJIaTOpHaTa petIJopMa MoraT Jl:a ce CHCTeMaTH1HpaT B CJIe.ll.HHTe HHKOJIKO rpynH: · MepKIf 3a HaMaJUmaHe Ha a.ll.MIfHIfCTpaTIfBHaTa If perynaTopHaTa Te)J(eCT; · I1HCTIfTYUIfOHaJIHIf IfHIfUIfaTIfBIf; · HanpaBeHIf oueHKIf Ha B'b3.ll.eHCTBIfeTO, aHaJIH3If If npOBe.ll.eHIf o6yqeHIf»; · 3aKOHOnaTeJIHIf IfHIfIIHaTIfBIf. 3.1.1 MepKU au Ua.M(l.IIJlouue uu ui)MuuucmpumuBHumu u pezYJtumopuumu me:m:ecm Cnope..u n'bpBHH ro..uHIIIeH OTIIeT Ha IIporpaMaTa 3a no-..u06po peryJlHpaHe 2008-2010 r. npe3 OTIIeTHHH nepHo..u ..uo anpHJl 2009 r. ca npeMaXHaTH H 06JleKIIeHH 06I1l,o 25 a..uMHHHcTpaTHBHH pe)l(HMa. B C'bTpy..uHHIIeCTBO C'bC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH ca H..ueHTHHrypa 2), KOCTO C PC3YJITaT OT BbBC)IQaHCTO Ha neT HOBH pC)l(HMa H npeMaXBaHCTO Ha )1,Ba pC)l(HMa. OCBCH TOBa, 06IIJ,0 CC)1,CM )1,OnbJIHCHHH H H3MeHCHHH ca HanpaBCHH npH rneCT pC)l(HMa. HaH HHTeH3HBHO e BbBe)IQaHeTO Ha HOBH pe)l(HMH npe3 2009 r., KoraTO ca BbBeD,eHH TpH pC)l(HMa, )1,OKaTO npcMaxHaTHTc pe)l(HMH (no C)1,HH Ha rO)1,HHa) cc OTHaCHT CbOTBeTHO 3a 2004 H 2007 r. (B)l(. <1>Hrypa 3).17 1_CI)_H_rv;..;.p_a_2_:_M_a_n_b_K_6..;..p_o_"_n_H_L\_e_H_3_H_O_H_H_H_p;..;.e_>K_H_M_H_c_a_H3_M_e_He_H_H_o_T_2_0_0_3_r_,_H_ac_a_M ______·_____~, ... _ 45 40 35 30 · o6:w: 6pOH 20 15 10 5 o 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 1i13TO'lHI1K: CTaTI1CTI1Ka Ha aSTOpl1Te, OCHOSaBall.la ce Ha nonpaBKHTe S 30APAKCA. 16 06H. L1.B, 6p. 98, 14 HoeMBpH 2008 r. Ii IIpe3 2007 r. Ii'bJIrapCKa CTOnaHCKa KaMapa npoBe)J,e H3CJIe)J,BaHe B'bpXy He3aKOHOC'bo6pa3HOTO npHJIO)l(eHHe Ha perYJIaTOpHH pe)l(HMH B Ii'bJIrapIDI. IieIlIe HanpaBeH H3BO)J,'bT, 'Ie e,!l.HH JIHQeH3HOHeH pe)l(HM ce npHJIara HenpaBoMepHo OT QeHTPaJIHaTa a)J,MHHHcTPaQH.lI, )J,OKaTO MeCTHam a,!l.MHHHCTpaQH.lI npHJIara He3aKOHHO 60 JIHQeH3HOHHH pe)l(HMa. C'bIQOTO ce OTHaC.lI H 3a 6JIH30 190 pemcTPaQHoHHH pe)l(HMa, npilllaraHH OT QeHTPaJIHaTa a)J,MHHHcTPaQH.lI, H OKOJIO 370 pemcTPaQHoHHH pe)l(HMa OT MeCTHaTa a,!l.MHHHcTPaQH.lI, KaTO npH TOBa MeCTHaTa a,!l.MHHHcTpaQH.lI npHJIara HerrpaBoMepHo H 750 pa3peIlIHTeJIHH pe)l(HMa. 3a C'b)l(aJIeHHe, JIHnCBaT rro-aKTyaJIHH Mrypa 3: CaMo HflKOI1KO I1ML\eH3MoHHM pe>KMMa ca B'bBeAeHM, a C'bBCeM Mal1KO pe>KMMM ca OTMeHeHM B nepHoAa Cl1eA 2004 r. 2 : · HOBH 1 o I 2°111 I I 2005 2006 'l1li 2008 2009 -1 V13TO'lHl-tK: CTaTl-tCTl-tKa Ha aBTOpl-tTe, OCHOBaBall.\a ce Ha nOnpaBKl-tTe B 30APAKCA. TIo OTHOlIIeHMe Ha BbBe)l(,[(aHeTO Ha elIeKTpoHHM yClIyrM HarrpaBeHMTe aHaJIM3M rroKa3BaT, qe Te MoraT ,ll,a 6b,ll,aT eqmKacHo Cpe,ll,CTBO 3a HaMaJIHBaHe Ha a,ll,MIIHMCTpaTIIBHaTa Te)KeCT. TIpaKTUKaTa no BHe,ll,pHBaHe Ha eJleKTpOHHU YCJlyru, 06aQe, nOKa3Ba HHKOU CJla60CTU, a MMeHHO: · Y clIyrMTe ca pa3pa60TeHII rro IIH,ll,IIBM,ll,YaJIHII rrpaBIIlIa B paMKIITe Ha OT,ll,elIHIITe Be,ll,OMCTBa II He MoraT ,ll,a 6b,ll,aT elIeMeHT OT e,ll,IIHHa cpe,ll,a 3a e-yclIyrii. · Pa60THIITe rrpOIJ,eCII 3a II3rrblIHeHIIe Ha YClIyriiTe ca rrpoeKTMpaHII no HaqIIH, y,ll,06eH 3a a,LJ,MIIHMCTpaIJ,II.SITa, a He 3a rroTpe6MTena. · JIIIrrcBa HaIJ,MOHaJIeH MO,ll,elI Ha rrpaBIIlIa 3a pa60Ta C elIeKTpOHHII ,ll,OKYMeHTM. 3a npeO,ll,OJlHBaHe Ha Te3U CJla60CTH npaBHTeJlCTBOTO e npe,ll,npueJlO CJle,ll,HUTe CTbnKU: · TIpIIeTII5IT 3aKOH 3a elIeKTpOHHOTO ynpaBlIeHIIe (3Ey)18 rrpe,ll,BM)I(,[(a aBTOMaTII3MpaHe Ha a,ll,MIIHMCTpaTIIBHIITe rrpOIJ,e,ll,ypII, OCMryp5lBaHe Ha rrp03paqHOCT Ha rrpOl~eCMTe B ,ll,bp)KaBHaTa a,ll,MIIHMCTpaIJ,M5I, HaMaJI5IBaHe Ha Bb3MO)KHOCTIITe 3a KopynIJ,IIOHHM npaKTIIKII, KaKTO II Ha a,ll,MIIHIICTpaTIIBHIITe Pa3XO,ll,M. 3EY perlIaMeHTIIpa e,ll,HOKpaTHOTO Cb3,ll,aBaHe M MHorOKpaTHOTO M3rr01I3BaHe Ha ,ll,aHHII, 3a,ll,blI)KeHMeTO 3a Me)K,ll,yBe,ll,OMCTBeH 06MeH Ha e-,ll,OKYMeHTII, CbBMeCTIIMOCTTa Ha IIHcpopMaIJ,IIOHHMTe CIICTeMM H IIHcpopMaIJ,MOHHaTa CMryPHOCT. 3aKOHbT IJ,elIM II CbKpaIll,aBaHe Ha BpeMeTO 3a rrpe,ll,OCTaB5IHe Ha a,LJ,MMHIICTpaTMBHII YCJIYm Ha rpa)l(,[(aHIITe II 6II3Heca. CbC 3EY ce rrOCTaB5I OCHOBaTa 3a CbIll,eCTBeHa pecpopMa B ,ll,eHHOCTTa Ha a,ll,MIIHIICTpauII.aTa rrpii pa60TaTa H C HOBIITe IIHcpopMaIJ,MOHHII TeXHOlIorMM II CbBMeCTHOTO II3n01I3BaHe Ha xapTIIeHII II elIeKTpOHHII ,ll,OKYMeHTII; · CTapTIIpa II3rpa)K,ll,aHeTO Ha IIHTerpaIJ,MOHHa CIICTeMa Ha erreKTpOHHOTO rrpaBMTelICTBO, K05lTO lIMa 3a IJ,err OCMryp5lBaHe II M3rpa)K,ll,aHe Ha MO,ll,elI 3a MHTerpMpaHO elIeKTpOHHO yrrpaBlIeHMe Ha periiOHaJIHO II IJ,eHTpaJIHO HIIBO. Cb3,ll,a,ll,eH e nOpTaJI Ha erreKTpOHHOTO rrpaBMTelICTBO - www.egov.bg. TOBa e TOQKaTa 3a ,ll,OCThn ,ll,0 BCIIQKII erreKTpOHHII yClIyrII, rrpe,ll,OCTaB5IHII OT IJ,eHTpaJIHaTa a,LJ,MIIHIICTpaIJ,II5I. CIICTeMaTa rrpe,ll,JIara IJ,eHTpaJIII3IIpaH rro,ll,XO,ll, KbM yrrpaBlIeHMeTO Ha ,ll,OKYMeHTII, pa60THII rrpOIJ,eCII, Cb)J,bp'lKaHIDI l1 nOnl1Tl1Kl1. B cncu,l1anCH p(3)J,cn C npC)J,CTaBCH KaTanor no Bl1)J,OBC perynaTOpHl1 pC'lKl1Ml1; · I1Hl1u,l1l1paHa e nl1nOTHa l1HTCrpau,l10HHa Cl1CTCMa Ha CneKTpOHHa 06naCT (I1I1CEO), KOwrO l1Ma 3a u,en l13rpa)K)J,aHe Ha l1HTerpau,l10HHa l1mppaCTpYKTYPa, KOwrO )J,a )J,a)J,e Bb3MO'IKHOCT Ha l1HCTl1TYU,l1l1TC B Tpl1 06naCTl1 - Eyprac, ,lJ,06pl1':{ l1 CTapa 3aropa - )J,a ynpaBmlBaT no-ecKTl1BHO )J,CHHOCTTa Cl1 l1 )J,a npC)J,OCTamIT a)J,Ml1Hl1CTpaTl1BHl1 ycnyrl1 no cneKTPOHCH nbT (B'IK. Kape 1). 3a nO,ll06pjJBaHe Ha 06IlJ,CCTBeHl1jJ ,llOCThn ,ll0 a,llMl1Hl1CTpaTl1BHO 06cnY'IKBaHe ce BbBe)K)J,a CTaH,llapTl13l1paHC Ha ycnyrl1TC l1 npou,cCl1Te. OpraHl1TC Ha ,llbp'IKaBHa BnaCT l13rpa'IK,llaT e,llHO MjJCTO 3a ,llOCThn ,ll0 a,llMl1Hl1CTpaTl1BHl1 ycnyrl1 Ha npl1Hu,l1na "C,llHO rl1illc". 06cnY'IKBaHe Ha "e,llHO rl1illC" C BbBe,lleHO OT 77% OT CTPYKTYPl1TC Ha u,eHTpanHaTa a,llMl1Hl1CTpau,IDI, 96% OT 19 06naCTHl1TC l1 82% OT 06IlJ,l1HCKl1Te a)J,Ml1Hl1CTPau,l1l1. I Kape 1: li1arpa>KAaHe Ha minOTHa MHTerpau,MoHHa CMCTeMa Ha eneKTpoHHa o611aCT ITo ITpoeKT ,,IbmOTHa HHTerpaIUlOHHa CHCTeMa Ha eJleKTpoHH8 06J1acT" (IIMCEO) ca H3rpa,n;eHH 'IpH "eJleK'IpOHHH 06J18CTH" - Jiypr8C, ,lJ;06pH'I H CTapa 3aropa. B OCHOBaTa Ha npoeKTa ca T.H8p. "perHOHaJIHH nopnum", KOHTO .ztaB8T B'b3MO)I(HOCT Ha rp~aHHTe H Ha 6H3Heca eJleKTpoHHO ,lla 38JIBJlBaT, cJle)ljJT H nonyqasaT a,n;MHHHCTp8THBHH YCJIYfH, npe)lOCT8BJIHH OT 06JIacTHaTa H 06IIU1HCKHTe a,n;MHHHc'IpaU;HH B C'bOTBeTH8T8 06J18CT. TOBa oCHrypna "BP8T8" KbM a,n;MHHHcTpaIJ;IDITa 24 qaca B )leHOHOIIJ;8eTO, 7 )lHH B ce)lMHQaTa. P83pa6oTeHOTO nporpaMHo pemeHHe )laBa B'b3MO)KHOCT 3a CBbp3BaHe Ha P83J1HqHHTe a,n;MHHHC'IpaTHBHH ycJIYfH C P83JIH'IHH HHCPOPMau;HOHHH H3TOqffHIJ;H, Ha 683aTa Ha CT8H)l8PTH3HpaH HHTepcpeHc. B 'IpHTe nHJlOTHH pemOHaJIHH nOpT8JI8 ~ H 6H3Hec'LT MoraT )la HaMepAT HHcpopMaQIDI 38 100 YCJIYfH, llpe)lOCTaBjJHH OT CbOTBeTHHTe a,n;MHHHCTpaIJ;HH B pemoHa, C IlbJIBO OnHCaHHe Ha HOpMaTHBHaTa ype)l6a, npou;e.u:ypHTe H cpoKOBeTe 38 peaJlH3Hp8He, KaKTO H He06xo)lHMHTe 06p83u;H H CPOPMYIDIpH. BCjJKa o6IIJ;8HcKa MMHHHC'Ip8IJ;IDI, BKJOOQeHa B npoeKTa, npe)lJlara Qpe3 CbOTBeT8HjJ pefHOHaneH nopY8JI no 5 a,n;MHHHc'IpaTHBHH yCJIYfH. OT CTaPTa Ha 'IpHTe pemOHaJIHH npoeKTa )lO KpruI Ha M. MaPT 2009 r. ca OCblI(ecTBeHH Ha,n; 200 TpaH38KIJ;HH. Cpe)lHO Ha )leH nOPT8JIHTe ce nOCelI(asaT OT OKOJlO 350 n0Tpe6HTeJlH. H3TO'-iH~K: MAAAP (2009). HHcmumyquoHWlHU uHuquamu6u C'bBeTbT 3a HKOHOMH'IeCKH paCTe~ (CUP) ce npeB'bpHa B'bB Ba~eH KOHCYJlTaTHBeH cjlOpYM no B'bnpOCHTe Ha no-tJ.06pOTO peryJlHpaue. Cb3,lla,llCHl1jJT npC3 aHanl13l1paHl1jJ nepl1o)J, CbBeT 3a l1KOHOMHQCCKH paCTe'IK (Cl1P), npC,llCC,llaTCnCTBaH OT Ml1Hl1CThpa Ha HKOHOMHKaTa, ce npeBbpHa BoB Ba'lKeH ny6nHQHO-QaCTeH KOHcynTaTHBeH 0PYM. CbBCThT, CbBMCCTHO C CKCnCpTl1 Ha Ml1Hl1cTepCTBoTO Ha HKOHOMl1KaTa, pa3pa60TH MepKH 3a BbBe)K)J,aHe Ha npl1HU;l1nl1TC Ha nO-,ll06po pcrynl1paHC, npl1CTl1 OT MC Ha 3 aBrYCT 2006 r. E,llHa OT OCHOBHl1TC MepKl1 6eille Cb3)J,aBaHe Ha jJceH pernaMeHT 3a B3al1Mo)J,eHCTBl1C Me'IK)ly OpraHl1Te Ha l13IIbnHl1TCnHaTa BnaCT l1 6l13HCC OpraHl13aU;l1l1Te npl1 OCbIlJ,eCTBjJBaHC Ha IIOnl1Tl1KaTa Ha nO-,ll06po perynl1paHc. McpKl1Te IIpe,llBl1'IK,llaT QpC3 npC,llBapl1TenHl1 l1 IIOCne,llBaIlJ,l1 ou,eHKl1 Ha Bb3,llCHCTBHeTo Ha HOBl1 HOpMaTl1BHl1 aKTOBe ,lla ce YCTaHOBl1 npaKTHKa Ha aHanH3 l1 MOHl1TOpl1Hr BbPXY 06naCTl1 Ha 3aKOHO,llaTCnCTBOTO l1 npaBonpHnaraHeTO, KOHTO MoraT ,lla 20 CD3,lla,llaT np06nCMl1 3a l1KOHOMl1QCCKl1TC cy6eKTl1. TSiCHOTO C'bTpYtJ.HH'IeCTBO Me~y 6'bJlrapCKOTo npaBHTeJlCTBO H CBeToBHaTa 6auKa HMa 3a pe3YJlTaT HanpetJ.'bKa B 06J1aCTTa Ha peryJlaTOpHaTa pecjlopMa, KoiiTo Ji'bJlrapHSI 19 MMAP (2009). 6eJle)KH B nOCJle,Ll,HO BpeMe. CBeTOBHaTa 6aHKa OKa3Ba nO,lJ,Kpena Ha 6'bJlrapCKOTO npaBHTeJICTBO nO,lJ, cpOpMaTa Ha aHaJIHTHqHa H KOHCYJITaHTCKa pa60Ta B CcpepaTa Ha peryJIaTOpTHaTa pecpOpMa. IhpBIUIT C'bBMeCTeH ,lJ,OKna,LJ, Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa H MHHHcTepcTBo Ha IIKOHOMHKaTa II eHepreTIIKaTa aHaJIH3lIpa a,lJ,MHHIICTpaTIIBHHTe npOlJ,e,LJ,yplI B TpH OTpaC'bna Ha IIKOHOMHKaTa - ryPH3'bM, XpaHHTenHa rrpOMlIIIIneHOCT H cyxOrr'bTeH TpaHCrrOpT - H npH30BaBa 3a HaMaJIj)'BaHe II OrrpOCTj)'BaHe Ha Hj)'KOH a,lJ,MIIHIICTpaTHBHII pe)KIIMH, KOIITO ca 06peMeHlITeJIHlI 3a 61I3HeCa. ,ll,OKna,lJ,'bT H3ThKBa H 1I3JIlIIIIHO Te)KKOTO peryJIHpaHe Ha HIIBO MeCTHa BJIaCT. E,lJ,HH ,lJ,pyr ,lJ,OKna,lJ, ,,llollumuKama fla E'bII2apWl 3a pe2YltamOpfia peqJOpMa e EepOneUCKU51 C'b103: C6.11UJlCaeGlle C flGll-do6pume pe2YllamOpflU npaKmUKU e Eepona", rrpenOp'bqBa HalJ,IIOHaJIHa CTPaTerml. OT ,lJ,eBeT CThrrKII, KOj)'TO 6eme O,lJ,06peHa OT C'bBeTa 3a IIKOHOMlIqeCKa nonlITIIKa Ha 19 OKTOMBPH 2007 r. Te3H ,lJ,Ba ,lJ,OKna,lJ,a, Hape,lJ, C rrpolJ,eca Ha KOHcYJITalJ,HII C ,lJ,pyrlI MHHHcTepcTBa, 61I3Hec aCOlJ,HalJ,HII H M03'bqHH Tp'bCTOBe, Ha npaKTHKa nporrpaBHxa rr'bTj)' Ha I1porpaMaTa 3a rro-,lJ,06po perynlIpaHe 2008-2010 r" rrpHeTa OT 6'bJIrapCKOTo rrpaBIITenCTBO rrpe3 2008 r, ,ll,pyr ,lJ,OKna,LJ, Ha CBeToBHaTa 6aHKa OT IOHH 2009 r. 1I3ThKBa Heo6xo,lJ,HMOCTTa OT CHCTeMeH, CnpaBe,lJ,JIHB H np03paqeH peJKHM Ha ,lJ,'bp)KaBHIITe TaKCH. B ,lJ,OKna,LJ,a ce oT6enj)'3Ba, qe Hj)'Ma e,lJ,HHHa nonHTHKa no OTHomeHHe Onpe,lJ,eMHeTO Ha ,lJ,'bp)KaBHHTe TaKCH. TOBa e e,lJ,Ha OT npHqHHHTe 3a ,,6ypHOTO" pa3BIITlIe Ha TapHcpHTe, KOIITO BKJ1IOqBaT ,lJ,'bp)KaBHH TaKCH, ,lJ,On'bnHHTeJIHO HaToBapBam.H 6H3Heca, oco6eHo MaJIKIITe H Cpe,lJ,HIITe npe,lJ,npHj)'TIIj)'. I1o-HaTaThK ,lJ,OKna,LJ,'bT nOCOqBa, qe npaBHaTa paMKa Ha pe)KIIMa Ha ,lJ,'bp)KaBHHTe TaKCH e He3a,lJ,OBOnIITenHa, a HHCTHTYlJ,HOHaJIHaTa paMKa 3a MOHIIToplIHr Ha onpe,lJ,enj)'HeTo H O,lJ,05pj)'BaHeTo Ha ,lJ,'bp)KaBHIITe TaKCH e TB'bp,lJ,e cna5a. I1pHJIaraHeTo Ha OCHOBHHTe npenOp'bKH Ha ,lJ,OKna,LJ,a Bce om.e rrpe,lJ,CTOH ,lJ,a ce BII,lJ,H. Ch3,lJ,a,Ll,eHO 6ewe 3BeHO 3a nO-,LI,06po peryJlHpaHe. TIporpaMaTa 3a nO-,lJ,05po peryJIlIpaHe 2008-2010 r, npe,lJ,BH)K,lJ,aIIIe C'b3,lJ,aBaHeTO Ha 3BeHo 3a nO-,lJ,06po perynlIpaHe, KoeTO 6eIIIe npenOp'bqaHO II OT CBeToBHa 5aHKa. C npoMeHHTe B Y CTPOHCTBeHIIj)' npaBHnHIIK Ha MC H HerOBaTa a,lJ,MHHHCTpalJ,Ifj)' OT cpeBpyapH 2009 r,21 Ha ,lJ,lIpeKlJ,Hj)' "CTpaTemqeCKO nnaHHpaHe H ynpaBneHHe" B MC 5j)'xa B'b3JIO)KeHH CPYHKlJ,HHTe no KOOp,lJ,HHHpaHe, H3n'bnHeHHe, II OTqlITaHe Ha TIporpaMaTa 3a nO-,lJ,05po perynHpaHe. TaKa ,lJ,HpeKlJ,Hj)'Ta 3anOqHa ,lJ,a H3n'bJIHj)'Ba CPYHKlJ,HHTe Ha 3BeHO 3a nO-,lJ,05po peryJIHpaHe. lliKonKO MeCelJ,a nO-K'bCHO, cne,lJ, H,lJ,BaHeTO Ha BJIaCT Ha HOBOTO npaBIITenCTBO, HOBHj)'T Y CTpOHCTBeH rrpaBHnHHK Ha MC II Ha HerOBaTa a,LJ,MIIHIICTpalJ,Hj)' B'b3nO)KH H3n'bnHeHHeTO Ha Te3H CPYHKlJ,HH Ha ,lJ,HpeKlJ,Ifj)' "l1KoHOMIIQeCKa H COlJ,HaJIHa nOJIHTHKa", CqHTaHO OT OKTOMBPH 2009 r. TIpe,lJ,CTOH BTOpH rrperne,lJ, Ha TIporpaMaTa, C lJ,en ,lJ,a ce OTQeTaT HOBHTe peaJIHOCTII II rrplIopHTeTHTe Ha HOBOTO npaBHTenCTBO. A!J.MHHHcTpaUHHTa Ha MC HHHUHHpa Ch1,L1,aBaHeTO Ha HHTepHeT nOpTaJl 1a KOHCYJlTalJ,HH. B oTroBop Ha HY)K,lJ,aTa H pa36IIpaHeTo, Qe ,lJ,HaJIOr'hT C'bC 3alIHTepecoBaHHTe CTpaHII e KnIOQOB 3a ycneIIIHoTo peaJIH3HpaHe Ha ronj)'Ma qaCT OT MepKHTe B TIporpaMaTa 3a nO-,lJ,05po peryJIHpaHe, Be,lJ,Hara CJIe,lJ, HeHHOTO npHeMaHe cTapTHpa HHTepHeT nOpTaJI 3a o6m.ecTBeHH KOHcynTalJ,HII Ha a,lJ,pec: www.strategy.bg. B'bBe,lJ,eHO 5eme H3HCKBaHeTO BCHQKH HopMaTIIBHH aKTOBe, CB'bp3aHII C a,lJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHoTO perynlIpaHe, ,lJ,a ce ny5JIlIKYBaT Ha nOPTaJIa HaH-MaJIKO 30 ,lJ,HH npe,lJ,H BHaCj)'HeTO HM Ha 3aCe,lJ,aHlIe Ha MHHHcTepcKHj)' C'bBeT. Dille npe,Ll,H nOpTaJla 3a KOHCYJlTaUHH 6ewe Ch1,L1,a,Ll,eH A,LI,MHHHCTpaTHBHHHT perHCThp. IIpe,lJ,H T03H nOpTaJI 5eIIIe C'b3,lJ,a,lJ,eH PemcThp Ha a,lJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe CTpyKryPII II Ha aKTOBeTe Ha opraHlITe Ha H3n'bnHIITenHaTa BnaCT?2 B'bnpeKII qe Bce om.e e ,lJ,OCThrreH B IIHTepHeT npOCTpaHCTBOTO, T03H perHCThp OT,lJ,aBHa He e aKryaJIH3HpaH. KaKTo 5eIIIe cnOMeHaTO no-rope, C'bm.eCTBYBa H om.e e,lJ,HH HOBOC'b3,lJ,a,lJ,eH pemCThp (www.egov.bg). ToM: e MHoro nO-,lJ,06pe opraHH3HpaH TeXHIIQeCKH, HO C'bm.ecTBYBaT pe,lJ,HlJ,a npo6neMH OTHOCHO aKryaJIH3lIpaHeTO My. HOBOTO npaBHTeJlCTBO npOtJ,'bJl3\H pec()OpMaTa. lieme C'bltJ,atJ,eH C'bBeT la atJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHa pec(JOpMa, KOHTO tJ,a pa60TH no np06JleMHTe Ha atJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa pec(JopMa, B T.'I. H HaMaJlHBaHeTO Ha atJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHaTa Te3\eCT. C nOCTaHOBJIeHHe Ha MC OT aBryCT 2009 r. 6ellIe C'b3,n;a,n;eH C'bBeT 3a a,n;MHHHcTpaTHBHa pe3i)euCntoue 33 H3MepB3He H3 MejKJl:YH3p0;:J:H3T3 KOHKypeHTocnoco6HOCT H3 b'bJIr3pHH C3 H3nOJI3B3HH H3CJIe;:J:B3HHH H3 CBeTOBHHH HKOHOMHQeCKH 4»OPYM (CHopMHpaHe Ha 6H3Heca H npe,IJ,JIO)KeHHe 3a THXHOTO HaMaJIHBaHe, ,lJ,OKJIa,lJ, Ha KOHCOPll,HYM "I1poeKT: A,IJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHH Te)KeCTIf 3a 6lf3HeCa", 1 IOHIf 2009 r. 29 06H. ,[(E. 6p. 34 OT 25 anpHJI 2006 r., nOCJI. H3M. ,[(E. 6p. 44 OT 12 IOHH 2009 r. 30 06H. ,[(E. 6p. 38 OT 9 Mali 2006 r. 31 CJIe,lJ,BaIl\HHT KOJIH'IeCTBeH aHMH3 Ha nepIfO,lJ,a CJIe,lJ, 2003 r. If3n0Jl3Ba HH,IJ,HKTOpHTe 3a H3MepBaHe Ha If3n'hJIHeHHeTO. npe,lJ,CTaBeHH B Ta6JIHlI,a 1. }fm)uKamopume 3a 6110:JICeHU peC)pcu (inputs) He ce pa3me)K,IJ,aT KJIaCHpaHe ITO OTHOCHTenHO MHCTO, e HarrpaBeHO CrrelJ,HMHO H3QHCneHHe 3a MHCTOTO, KOeTO CTpaHaTa 6H 3aena, aKO 6pOHT Ha YQaCTBallJ,HTe B Te3H cpaBHeHHH crpaHH e 100. TOBa rr03BOMBa ~a ce rrOCTHrHe rrO-rrpelJ,H3HO cpaBHeHHe Ha ~HHaMHKaTa Ha cTpaHaTa rrpe3 H3CJIe~BaHHH rrepHo~. Cnopell KJIaCa~HHTa Ha CII, KOHKypeHTocnoc06HocTTa Ha IibJIrapHH e HHCKa H no a6COJIIOTHO, H no OTHOCHTeJIHO MHCTO. no a6comoTHo MHCTO bbnrapHH ce Hape)l()],a Me)l()],y 70-Ta H 80-Ta rr03HlJ,HH, a ITO OTHOCHTenHO MHCTO ce ~BH)I{H OKono cpe~aTa Ha KnaCalJ,HHTa (B)I{. Hrypa 4). Cne~ ~IyBCTBHTenHOTo rro~o6pHBaHe Ha KOHKypeHTocrroc06HocTTa rrpe3 2004-2005 r., ~HHaMHKaTa Ha pa3BHTHe Ha T03H H~eKC e OTpHlJ,aTenHa, rropa~H rrocne~BMOTO BnOlIIaBaHe Ha a6conlOTHaTa H OTHOCHTenHaTa rr03HlJ,HH. Hrypa 4: KnacHpaHeTo Ha DbJ1rapHH cnopeA rno6anHHH HHAeKc Ha KOHKypeHTocnoco6Hocna Ha [; CHt:IJ e HHCKO H He ce nOAo6pHBa ----~----,------------------*--- 90 80 70 60 50 ~VIHCTO 40 30 20 :..0 o 2004 2005 2006 2007 ~008 2009 l'I3T04HI1K: Global Competitiveness Report (WEF, 2004-2009). CbHrypa 5: KJ1aCHpaHeTo Ha EibnrapHfI no HHAeKca Ha KOHKypeHTocnoc06HoCT Ha HYP COqH J1eKO nOA06peHHe 90 80 · 60 · · .. 50 40 ~-~.------~----~ · · 30 20 10 o 2006 2007 2008 2009 1-13TO'lHI-IK: World Competitiveness Yearbook (IMO, 2006-2009). ,l1,aHHHTe Ha HYP IlOKa3BaT JleKO IlOIl:OOpHBaHe Ha Il03HIJ,HHTe Ha CTpaHaTa. TIo ,ll.aHHlf Ha HHCTlfTYTa 3a ynpaBJIeHCKO pa3BHTHe (HYP) E'bJIrapIDI 3aeMa Me~ 67-MO If 77-MO M.HCTO OT o6Il1,o 100 CTpaHH (BX\:. Hfypa 5). ,n:lfHaMlfKaTa Ha pa3Blfme Ha T03H lfH,ll.eKC o6aqe e 6JIafOnpH.HTHa H no a6COJIIOTHO, H no OTHOClfTeJIHO M.HCTO. CTpaHaTa C BC.HKa lf3MlfHaTa ro,ll.HHa nO,ll.06p.HBa KJIaClfpaHeTo Clf If ce nplf6JIlf)KaBa K'bM Cpe,ll.HaTa fpyna. nOIl:OOpeHHH Ha oH3Hec Cpell:aTa B b'bJlrapHH ce OTQHTaT H CllOpell: HHII:eKCa -"npaBeHe Ha oH3Hec". TIpe3 nOCJIe,ll.HlfTe neT rO,ll.lfHlf E'bJIraplf.H e nOCTlffHaJIa C'bIll,eCTBeH ycnex no OTHoweHlfe Ha M.HCTOTO Clf B KJIacau,IDITa «[Jpa6eHe Ha 6U3f1eC». MaKap qe B H.HKOlf 06JIaCTlf OTHOClfTeJIHlfTe n03lflJ,HH Ha CTpaHaTa OCTaBaT HenpoMeHeHH (HanpHMep, 3aIll,HTa Ha lfHBeCTHTopHTe) HJIH ,ll.Oplf ce BJIOWaBaT (HanpHMep, 6poii Ha npOlJ,e,ll.yplfTe H BpeMe 3a nOJIy~IaBaHe Ha pa3peWHTeJIHO 3a CTpOe)K), E'bJIraplf.H e nOCTlffHaJIa nO,ll.06peHlf.H B MHoro ,ll.pym 06JIaCTlf (B)K. Ta6JIHu,a 2). TaKa HanpHMep, HaMaJI.HBaHeTO Ha 6po.H Ha np0lJ,e,ll.yplfTe, BpeMeTO 3a peflfCTpalJ,H5I, Pa3XO,ll.HTe no perlfCTpHpaHeTO, KaKTO H pa3Mepa Ha MHHHMaJIHH.H KanlfTaJI HanpaBlfxa CTapTlfpaHeTO Ha HOB 6H3Hec 3HaqlfTeJIHO nO-JIeKO OT 2004 r. HacaM. fIo,ll.o6HO HaMaJIeHlfe ce OTqlfTa If nplf 06Il1,aTa ,ll.aH'bqHa CTaBKa If 6po.H Ha ,ll.aH'bqHlfTe nJIaIll,aHlf.H. Ta6nMu,a 2: MaKap 'Ie nOAo6peHMRTa He ca nOCTORHHM - a nOHRKora MMa 14 BnowaBaHe - KnacMpaHeTO Ha 6'bJ1rapMR B "npaeeHe Ha 6U3Hec" ce nOAo6pRBa cneA 2004 r. PemCTpllpaHe Ha qmpMa IlonyqaBaHe Ha pa3peIlleHile 3a cTpollTenCTBO PerlCTp"paHe Ha co6cTBeHocT 1.3 34.8 HaceneHlle, o6xBaHaTo OT OT o 6.2 I1H~eKc Ha pa3Kp"BaHe Ha llHKKa: TOBa KllaCl1paHe He OT'lI1Ta nOClle,AHIilTe npOMeHIII B MeTO,AOIlOrlilSlTa Ha ,AOKJI~a "npaBeHe Ha 61113Hec 2010". I Cl»Mrypa 7: 6"bJ1rapMA 3aeMa 51-BO MACTO cnopeA KI1aCa4MATa "npaBeHe Ha 6M3Hec 2010" 120 97 100 82 80 H 715 60 51 52 54 48 4243 40 27 28 29 31 lii 22 26 17 18 21 20 11 4 68 o I :x; :s: '" :s: a: :s: :x; :s: ~ '" :s: :x; :s: '" :s: ro al :x; :s: ~ 0:: :s: '" :s: a. ,0 0:: :s: a. > 0:: :s: 0:: :s: "" 3 ':l: .:s: :x; .:s: :x; .:s: J: .:s: "" t::; .. J: q: ::I: q: ::I: :r 2 :1' (!) :r (\) ~ t::; t :s: ... al :::t: :r a. .... t::; ~ c :s: '" <'J \0 J: (!) :r: ro t::; t::; ... x (!) :1' a. '" c:[ '" <'J u '" 2 CJ LO ~ <'J ~ '" u ::.: en 0 2 <:; Cil 0 c u 0 c '"" :s: ::r .D a. a. t::; I w :3 0.. KKa: TOBa KJlaClilpaHe OT'lIilTa nOClle,AHI1Te npOMeHI1 B MeTO,AOIlOrIllHTa Ha ,AOKlla,Aa. TIoLlo6peHHHTa B 06JIaCTTa Ha peryJIHpaHeTO npOLl'bJI~aBaT. KaTO npHMep MO)l(e ,1l.a ce nOCOqH, qe cne,[( nOCne,[(HHH ,[(OKJIa)l ,,IIpa6eHe Ha 6U3Hec 2010 ", KOHTO BKJIlOqBa IIo'[(06peHIDITa ,[(0 IOHH 2009 r., HOBOTO npaBHTenCTBO HaMaJIH MHHHMaJIHHH BHeceH KaIIHTaJI 3a '[(PY)I(eCTBaTa C OrpaHHqeHa OTrOBopHOCT OT 5000 neBa Ha 2 neBa. TOBa e nOKa3aTenHO 3a CbIlleCTBYBaIllHH IIOTeHIJ,HaJI 3a 6b,[(eIllH no'[(06peHHH B pe,[(Hu,a HanpaBneHHH. no OTHomeHue peryJIUpaHeTO Ha np0JJ.YKTOBUH na3ap D'bJIrapHH JJ.eMOHCTpupa JJ.o6po n03UnUOHupaHe B cpaBHeHue C'bC cpeJJ.HHTe CTOHHOCTU 3a EC. KaTo M3nOJI3Ba MeTO,L(OJIOrMHTa, pa3pa60TeHa OT eKcnepTM Ha OHCP 3a M3qMCJIHBaHe Ha MH,L(eKCa Ha peryJIMpaHe Ha npO,L(YKTOBMH na3ap, eKMn Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa M3B'bpIIIH CneII,MaJIHO npoyqBaHe 3a D'bJIrapMH. Cnope,L( Hero npe3 2006 r. cTpaHaTa nOJIyqaBa OneHKa OT 1,8, KOeTO H Hape)l(,L(a Me)l():(y qelllKam Peny6JIMKa M YHrapuSI (B)l(. Mrypa 8). Ii'bJIrapMH Bce OIlle M30CTaBa OT cpe)),HoTo paBHMIlle 3a T03M nOKa3aTeJI OT 15-Te cTpaHM-qJIeHKM Ha EC M OT CTpaHMTe B OHCP, KOMTO ca npe,L(CTaBeHM C ,L(aHHM 3a 2003 r. (J)Hrypa 8: no HHAeKC Ha perynHpaHe Ha npOAYKTOBHH na3ap Ei'bJ1rapHH 3aeMa A06po MHCTO, cpaBHeHa Cbe cpeAHoTo paBHHw,e B EC 3.0 ---- ---2.11--' 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 o.S 0.0 PemJDlU ECIS OHCP Py:M'I>JOUI l.Jemn B'I>JU'apHH YHl'apHH ,zq,yrH * l10JDlCl CJIOBUHH 2006 PenyU.JIJIXa 2006 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 J.13TO"lHHK: CBeTOBHa 6aHKa, 2007 r. * ,ll,pym cTpaHH (bC cpeAeH AOXOA. H3CJIeJJ.BaHe Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa cpeJJ. npeJJ.npUHTUH, npOBeJJ.eHO npe3 2009 L, COqU, 'Ie 6'bJIrapCKUTe MeHUJJ.)K'bpU He nOCTaBHT U3UCKBaHUHTa 3a JIUneH3UH U pa3pemHTeJIHH cpeJJ. HaH-C'bUJ.eCTBeHHTe npeqKH 3a TeXHHH 6H3Hec. Haii-rOJIHM np06JIeM 3a 6'bJIfapCKMTe qmpMM e ,L(OCnn'bT )),0 Mrypa 9). JIMII,eH3MMTe M pa3pelllMTeJIHMTe ce nOCOqBaT KaTO npeqKa caMO npM 5.37% OT oTroBopMTe npe3 2007 r. M 32 2.09% OT OTrOBOpMTe npe3 2009 f. 32 )],.aJI Ha qmpMHTe, KOHTO H36HpaT "JIHueH3HH H pa3peIIlHTeJIHH" KaTO HaH-rOJIBMaTa opeliKa, KOBTO cpeIUaT. Ha 4>Mrypa 9: 6'b11rapCKMTe cl>MPMM He nOCTaBflT 6M3Hec JlML\eH3MMTe M pa3peWMTeJlHMTe cpeA HaM roneMMTe npe"lKM 3a 6M3Heca npe3 2009 r. (B npOL\eHT) ."'Ye aM-re.lleMlf.,r8JlllH£Ypa 10). T03H )J,IDI HaMaJUlBa no)J, 9% npe3 2009 L, KoeTO npe)J,cTaBJUIBa C'hlIJ,eCTBeHO nO)J,06peHHe?3 B CpaBHflTeJIeH nJIaH TOBa nOCTHlKeHHe e 3a6eJIelKHTeJIHO, B'hnpeKH qe npe3 rO)J,HHHTe TeH)J,eHlI,H.SlTa He e e)J,H03HaqHa. HanpHMep npe3 2002 r. T03H )J,HJI e 6HJI 6JIH30 17%, a npe3 2007 r. TOM )J,OCTHra 21,2%.34 ITo T03H nOKaJaTeJI E'hJIrapHH e B MHOro )J,06po nOJIOlKeHHe KaKTO B cpaBHeHHe C'hC cTpaHHTe OT 113TOQHa EBpona H UeHTparma A3HH, TaKa H cnpHMO CTpaHHTe C )J,OXO)J,H Ha QOBeK OT HaCeJIeHHeTO nO-BHCOKH OT cpe)J,HHTe. 4>Mrypa 10: Afln Ha cl>MpMMTe, KOMTO nOCO"lSaT peryJlMpaHeTo KaTO HaM-ronSiMaTa npe"lKa 3a 6M3Heca npe3 2009 r. (s npOL\eHT) lliGpllHH CTpIlHH r:::::iI % or ~ 0Dp~ ~C~OIIlITO I1Poap_:cuo BlIA-rIl!IJlIM&:ape_ 50 J::; ~ 40 ~ S!i j I:! r---:1 , r · iii $!I ! ~ .. 20 ~ ~ - ~ r- R ~ I'l !. ;-- . 1 8 ,.:: ! 10 n c ~ l , II:Jma (200!1) IIKoHoMHKa 3a6ene>KKa: ARJ1 Ha ca nO)1,6paHH HHKOJIKO HH,ll,eKCa, KOHTO HaH-TOllHO oTpa3HBaT CbCTOHHHeTO Ha peryJIHpaHeTo. TOBa ca nOKa3aTCJIHTC 3a TC:JKCCT Ha pcrYJmpaHCTo, clPHKacHocT Ha npaBHaTa paMKa H np03paQHOCT Ha npascHeTo Ha nOJIHTHKH. flo TC3H HH,ll,CKCH EbJIrapHH HMa OUCHKH MC:JK,LJ,y 2,3 H 3,3 - npH :JKCJIaHO CbCTOHHHC Bb3MO:JKHO Hail-6JIH3KO )1,0 HyJIa (B:JK. urypa 11). MHCTOTO Ha D'bJIrapHH no Te3H HH)),eKCH e B HaU-He6JIarOnpHHTHaTa qaCT Ha KJlaCaUHHTa - Mexw;y SO-TO H 120-TO MHCTO (BJK. urypa 12). TIo OTHOCUTeJIHO M>ICTO BnJIrapu>I nona.n:a BnB BTopaTa nO-He6rraronpHHTHa nOJIOBUHa Ha KrraCauU>ITa - CJIe.n: 60-TO M>ICTO. Cnlll,aTa n03UuU>I no u36paHuTe nOKa3aTeJIU ce 3aeMa KaKTO no TOqKU, TaKa U no M>ICTO B KJIaCaUU>ITa. TIo BCUqKU OT aHaJIU3UpaHUTe nOKa3aTeJIU CTpaHaTa UMa nO-He6JIarOnpHHTHH n03UUUH B cpaBHeHue C 06lll,U>I UH.ll:eKC Ha KOHKypeHTocnoco6HOCT. OT H3CJle)),BaHHHTa Ha KOHKypeHTocnoc06HOCTTa Ha HYP C'bUlO ca no))'6paHH HHKOJIKO HH)),eKca, KOHTO HaU-TOqHO xapaKTepH3HpaT )),HHaMHKaTa H C'bCTOHHHeTO Ha peryJlHpaHeTO (BJK. Hrypa 13). TOBa ca nOKa3aTerrUTe 3a 6IOpOKpalJ,U>I, rreKOTa Ha npaBeHe Ha 6H3Hec H perucTpHpaHe Ha $upMa (3anOqBaHe Ha 6H3Hec). OT nrx B HaH-.n:06pO CbCTO>IHHe 3a Bnrrrapu>I e UH.n:eKCbT 3a BJIHHHUe Ha 6IOpOKpalJ,U>ITa. JijJyruTe .n:Ba UH.n:eKca UMaT CTOHHOCTU B He6JIaronpU>ITHaTa qaCT Ha rpa$uKaTa. Te ce Korre6a>rT npe3 ro.n:UHUTe B UHTepBaJIa MeJK.n:y 3,7 U 6 npu MaKCHMaJIHa CTOHHOCT 7. B .n:UHaMUqeH nrraH caMO npH UH.n:eKca 3a perucTpupaHe Ha $upMa ce Ha6mo.n:aBa no.n:06peHue B nepuo.n:a 2006-2009 r., KaTO CTOHHOCTTa My B Kpa>r Ha nepuo.n:a e no-.n:06pa, OTKOJIKOTO B HaqaJIOTO. TIpH .n:pyruTe .n:Ba nOKa3aTerr>I ce 3a6eJI>I3Ba BJIOlliaBaHe Ha CTOHHOCTUTe Cnp>IMO H3XO.n:HOTO nOJIOJKeHUe (BJK. urypa 13). el>Hrypa 11: BnowaBaT ce CTOMHoCTHTe cnopeA CHeI> Ha nOKa3aTenHTe Te>KeCT Ha perynHpaHeTo H e+HKacHoCT Ha npaBHaTa paMKa cneA 2003 r' l KaKTO H Ha nOKa3aTenR np03pal.fHOCT Ha npaBeHeTo Ha nonHTHKH cneA 2007 r. 4 3.) 2.5 2 1,5 1 0.5 o ' 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 _ _ T } f( C THd llerYJllllldH T O ....... EI .n:O KrraCUpaHeTO Ha BbrrrapU>I no OT.n:errHUTe HH.ll:eKCH, B .n:UHaMHqeH nJIaH CTPaHam ce npe.n:CTaB>I HaH-.n:06pe no OTHOllieHue Ha npaBeHeTO Ha 6U3Hec, KaKTO no a6corrlOTHO, TaKa U no OTHOCHTerrHO M>ICTO (BJK. urypa 14). TIo OTHOIlIeHHe Ha 6lOpoKpaUHHTa TeH.n:eHlJ,U>ITa e n03UTHBHa, .n:OKaTO npu Cb3.n:aBaHeTO Ha $HpMa KpaHHHTe CTOHHOCTH 3a nepuo.n:a cmBaT paBHU Ha HaqarrHUTe CTOHHOCTH, KaTO TPaeKTOpU>ITa Ha rpa$uKam UMa errHnCOBu.n:Ha $opMa (BJK. Hrypa 14). 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 2003 2004 200S 2006 2007 2008 2009 _ _ T e)I(t~(T lid IleP/llltpillieTO - Mil(TO ___ Te>KeCTliil perYllltpillieTO-OTli" MRCTO "_"E4!1IKilCIiOCT lid "lldSliilTi! IlilMKa -MRCTO -EliIrypa 14: CnopeA IiIYP MRCTOTO Ha 6'bnrapliIR no nOKa3aTenR 6IOPOKpaU.IiIR e no-nowo OT TOBa no nOKa3aTenlilTe C'b3AaBaHe Ha cPlilpMa iii neKOTa Ha npaBeHe 100 90 so 70 60 so 40 30 10 10 o 2006 1007 1008 2009 -neCHOTd Hd npaB'Ht" Ha 6113H'c OTH, M1HTO iI13T0'1HI1K: World Competitiveness Yearbook (IMO, 2006-2009). EAHH OT HaH-CTOHHOCTHHTC nOKa3aTeJIH 3a pcryJIaTOpHaTa TelKCCT e ACJI'bT Ha BpeMCTO, KOCTO BHcmHHT MCHHmKM'bHT OTAeJiH Ha ACHHOCTH, CB'bp3aHH C peryJIaU:HHTC. ,lJ,oKaTo npe3 2002 r. 3a TOBa e OTHBaJIO 3% OT BpeMeTO Ha BHCIIIH» MeHHA)I(M"bHT (3a npOH3BO)],CTBeHH q>HPMH B E"bJIrapH5I), npe3 2009 r. T03H )J,5IJI e 5% (B)I(. Q.>mypa 15). ,lJ,nHaMHKaTa Ha T03H nOKa3aTeJI MO)l(e )],a ce pa3)],eJIH Ha TpH eTana. fhpBH»T eTan, KOlho 06XBama C"bCTO»HHeTO )],0 2005 r., ce xapaKTepH3Hpa C"bC cJIa60 HapaCTBaHe Ha BpeMeTO, OT)],eJI»HO OT BHCIIIH» MeHH)J,)KM"bHT, KOeTO )],OCTHra 3,4% B Kpa» Ha eTana. P»3KO BJIOrnaBaHe Ha T03H nOKa3aTeJI ce 3a6eJI»3Ba npe3 BTOPH» eTan - OT 2005 r. )],0 2007 r., KaTO nOBHrnaBaHeTO Ha nOKa3aTen» BepO»THO e CBbp3aHO C npHBe)l()],aHeTO B CbOTBeTCTBHe C H3HCKBaHH»Ta Ha EC. TaKa npe3 2007 r. CTOHHOCTHTe Ha nOKa3aTen» Ha)],MHHaBaT 17%. TpeTH»T emn e CJIe)], 2007 r., KoraTO BpeMeTo, OT)],emIHO OT BHCIIIlf» MeHlf)],)I(MbHT 3a perYJIaTOpHH )],efiHocTH, CIIa)],a )],0 9% npe3 2008 r. rIpe3 2009 r. T03H nOKa3aTeJI CIIa)J,a)],o 5%. 4IM ryp a 15: BpeMeTo, KoeTO SMCWMAT MeHMA>KMbHT Ha npoM3soAcTseHa KaSHOTO perynMpaHe S 6bnrapMA, e HaManAno cbw,eCTseHo (2002-2009 r.) 20% 17.4% 18% ' 16% 14% 12% 10% 8% 6% .. 5-.0%..... .... ~l'O% 3.4% 4% 2% 0% 2002 2005 2007 2008 2009 \I13TO'lHHK: nf;Cn (2002, 2005, 2008-09), \I13CJ1eABaHe Ha CBeTOBHa 6aHKa cpeA npeAnpHRTHR (2007), npOyYBaHe Ha aAMHHHcTpaTHBHHTe H peryJ1aTOpHH pa3xoAH (2009) 3a MeHHA>f{bPH Ha npoH3BoAcTBeHI1 q,I1PMI1 B 6bJ1rapI1R. 3a6eJ1e)!(Ka: TpR6Ba Aa ce nOA'lepTae, 'le npe3 2008 r. 11 2009 r. BbnpocbT e 3aAaAeH no pa3J1I1'leH Ha'lHH B cpaBHeHHe c npeAI1WHI1Te npoY'lBaHI1A.B npeAI1WHHTe npoyYBaHI1A ce nHTa, KaKbB AAJ1 OT BpeMeTo Ha BI1CWHR MeHI1A)!(MbHT ce OTAeJ1R 3a cnpaBAHe c peryJ1au,I1I1Te B paMKI1Te Ha eAHa ceAMI1u,a, AOKaTO npe3 2008 r. 11 2009 r. ce nl1Ta 3a BpeMeTO, KoeTO BI1CWHRT MeHI1A)!(MbHT oTAeJ1A 3a peryJ1au,I1H B paMKI1Te Ha 12 Meceu,a. TeiKeCTT8 H8 peryJlHp8HeTO B OT,QeJIHHTe OTP8CJlH e P83J1H1fH8. enope,n: ,n:aHHH OT H3Crre,n:BaHeTO Ha a,n:MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe H peryrraTopHH PalXO,n:H B E'brrrapHH npe3 2009 r., MaKap qe cpe,n:HHHT BHClll MeHH,LOK'bp Ha npOH3Bo,n:CTBeHa qmpMa OT,n:errH caMO OKorro 5% OT BpeMeTO CH 3a cnpaBHHe C peryrraUHHTe (B)K. Hrypa 15), MeHH,LOK'bpHTe Ha HOBH npoH3Bo,n:cTBeHH qmpMH H Ha l1T rrrapHH 3aeMa ,n:06pa n03HUHH B paMKHTe Ha perHOHa Ha EBpona H IJ,eHTpaJIHa A3HH (B)K. mypa 16). Cf)Mrypa 16: 6bJ1rapMA ce KnacMpa nO-A06pe B cpaBHeHMe C APyrMTe cTpaHM OT perMoHa Ha EBpona M ~eHTp. A3MA no 6POA Ha AHMTe, He06xoAMMM 3a nony...aBaHe Ha onepaTMBeH nMu.eH3 npe3 2009 r. 811 III ~ fO 8 ---: ~ ~ a "I - (I ~ l- v ., ... a i g tI ~ lit .. .. ""l ---"! r-"""'l -" t:l ---"! ~ ct C'I !:! a l- ~ I!: ~ 20 ,.........., ~ I·· 10 . T~ . · , (2008) _1Ittp~-.. iz ..., ·...., 1i13TO'lHHK: 1i13CI1eABaHe Ha npeAnpHRTHRTa, CBeTOBHa 6aHKa, 2009 r. 3.3 C'bcmoSlHue U ()uHaMUKa Ha Ka'lecmOeHume uH()uKamopu K3KTO 6ewe oT6eJUI33HO no-p3HO, 06~HTe Orp3HHQeHHJI npH H3B'bpWB3He H3 Ol(eHK3T3 H3 B'bl.lleiicTBHeTO np3BSlT 13.1l3Q3T3 33 H1MepB3He H3 l(eJlHTe H3 30APAKC)1, MHoro .IleJlHK3TH3. TOBa HaJIO:tKH H3nOJI3BaHeTO Ha KOM6HHHpaHH MeTO.llH 3a aHaJIH3. B .IlOn'bJIHeHHe Ha KOJIH"leCTBeHH5f aHaJIH3 Ha .IlaHHH H HHcpopMaU;H5f OT Pa3JIH"IHH HaU;HOHaJIHH H Me:tK,IJ,yHapO.llHH H3TOqHHU;H, 6eme npOBe,lleHO CneU;HaJIHO COU;HOJIOrHqeCKO npoyqBaHe cpe,ll npe,llCTaBHTeJIH Ha 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH, B T.q. 6H3Hec JIH,llepH, KJIlOqOBH eKcnepTH H npe,llCTaBHTeJIH Ha ny6JIHqHH HHCTHryU;HH, H 6Hxa H3CJIe,llBaHH qeTHpH OT HaH-qeCTO npHJIaraHHTe pe:tKHMa no,ll cpopMaTa Ha H3CJIe,llBaHe Ha Ka3ycH B TpH Pa3JIHqHH no rOJIeMHHa 06~HHH. IlO,llpo6HHTe H3CJIe,llBaHHH ca npe,llCTaBeHH B IlpHJIo:tKeHHe 4 (B'bnpOCHHK Ha COU;HOJIOrHqeCKOTO npoyqBaHe), IIpHJIo:tKeHHe 5 (Pe3YJITaTH OT COU;HOJIOrHqeCKOTO npoyqBaHe) H IlpHJIo:tKeHHe 6 (Ilpeme,ll Ha peryJIaTOpHH pe:tKHMH Ha MeCTHO HHBO). 3.3.:1. HocmuzaHe Ha qe.llume Ha 30APAKC,ll: peaY.Ilmamu om npoY'lOaHemO OCHOBH3T3 nOJl33 OT npoYQB3HeTO, npOBe)leHO 13 T01H )lOKJI3)l, ce C'bCTOH B onpe)leJlJlHe H3 p3BHH~eTO H3 nOCTHr3He H3 l(eJlHTe, 13J10jKeHH B 33KOH3. 3a u;eJIHTe Ha aHaJIH3a, U;eJIHTe ca pa3,lleJIeHH B TpH rpynH. fl'bpeama zpyna C'b,ll'bp:tKa u;eJIHTe, KOHTO ca nOCTHrHaTH. Y CJIOBHeTO 3a nonanaHe B Ta3H rpyna e npe06JIanaBa~aTa qaCT OT OTrOBopHTe Ha peCnOH,lleHTHTe ,lla ca "Han'bJIHO nOCTHrHaTa" H "nOCTHrHaTa B'bB BHCOKa CTeneH". Bmopama zpyna BKJIlOqBa u;eJIHTe, KOHTO ca nOCTHrHaTH caMO qaCTHqHO. B Ta3H rpyna C'bOTHOmeHHeTO Ha peCnOH,lleHTHTe, KOHTO O,l106pHBaT, pecneKTHBHO, He O,l106pHBaT TB'bp,lleHHeTO, qe ,lla,lleHa u;eJI e nOCTHrHaTa, e paBHO. Tpemama zpyna ce C'bCTOH OT u,eJIHTe, KOHTO He ca nOCTHrHaTH. B Ta3H rpyna OTrOBopHTe Ha npe06JIa,llaBa~aTa qaCT OT peCnOH,lleHTHTe ca HJIH "nOCTHrHaTa B HHCKa CTeneH", HJIH "nOCTHrHaToTo e nO-CKOpO 06paTHO Ha u;eJITa". Pa3npe,lleJIeHHeTO Ha u;eJIHTe e npe,llCTaBeHO B Ta6JIHu,a 3. IIOCTHrHaTo-1 IIoCTHr IIoCTHr TO e no . HaTH B'bB HaTH B CKOPO BHCOKa HHCKa 06paTHO Ha CTeneH CTeneH ueJlTa 1. TOQHO ,ne$HHHpaHe Ha BH)l,oBeTe pelKHMH, KOHTO 20 CTOnaHCKaTa ,neiiHOCT, KaTO orpaHIl'1H ,no 06Il\eCTBeHO onpaB,naHH rpaHHUH a,nMHHHcrpaTHBHOTO peryJIHpaHe H a.r:\MHHHCTpaTHBHIDi KOHrpOJI, OC"hIl\eCTBHBaHH OT mpllmBHHTe opraHH H OT OpraHHTe Ha MeCTHOTO 0 50 40 10 2. OrpaHHqaBaHe BbBeJKjJ,aHeTO Ha HOBH peryJIaTHBHH pelKHMH (JIHueH3HoHHH HJIH pemcrpaUHoHHH) qpe3 H3HCKBaHeTO 3a II3rOTB.!IHe Ha MOTHBHpaHO CTaHOBHIl\e 3a Heo6xo,nHMocTTa OT TOBa peryJIHpaHe H npe,nBapHTeJIHO YBe,nOM.!lBaHe Ha 20 1. YBeJIHQaBaHe Ha np03paQHOCTTa npH BbBelK,Il,aHe Ha 0 20 50 30 2. HaMaJI.!lBaHe H3TOQHHUHTe Ha KopynuH.!I Qpe3 orpaHHQaBaHeTO Ha ,Il,HCKpell.HOHHaTa BJIaCT Ha 10 10 60 3. OCHrypHBaHe Ha ny6JIHQHOCT B pa60TaTa Ha a,ll,MHUHCTpaTHBuHTe opraHH no npHJIaraHeTo Ha HopMaTHBHHTe aKTOBe, CB"hp3aUH C a,ll,MHHHCTpaTIfBHoTO peryJIHpaue H KaKTO If MOTHBHTe 3a T.!IXHaTa 0 20 40 40 4. OrpaUHQaBaHe H nOCTO.!lHHO HaMaJI.!lBaHe Ha 06Il\eCTBeHo HeOnpaB,Il,aHOTO 06peMeH.!lBaUe Ha CTOnaHCKaTa 0 20 50 30 5. IIpeMaxBaHe Ha HopManIBHHTe npe,ll,nOCTaBKH, KOHTO MoraT ,na ,nOBe,ll,aT ,no orpaHHQaBaHe Ha 10 20 35 35 113T04HHK: npoY4BaHe Ha aBTOpHTe (BH<. npHIlOHYHKUI10HaJIHOCT 11 Bepcml Ha aHrJ1I1HCKl1 e311K. o 3aKOn"bm ne e aCOl{uupan K"bM onpeoeJlen ((C06Cm6enUK», Koumo oa nocu omzo6opnocm 3a npWlazanemo MY, oa KOnmpOJlupa mn"bJlnenuemo My u oa npeoJlaza npOMenu 6 cJlyltau na neo6xooUMocm. JIl1IICaTa Ha TaKaBa OTrOBopHOCT He MO)I(e )1,a ce KOMrreHCl1pa HI1TO OT 06ll1,aTa a)1,MI1HI1CTpauml Ha MI1HI1CTepCKI1H CbBeT, HI1TO OT )1,pyro YHKUI10HaJIHO 111111 ceKTopHO MI1HI1CTepCTBO. TIpe)1,Bl1)1, 3aKJIIOqeHRHTa Ha T0311 )1,OKJIa)1" 3aKOHbT He ce e rrpeBbPHaJI B I1HTerpaJIHa qaCT OT 06ll1,a CTpaTerl1H 3a HaMaJIHBaHe Ha a)1,MI1HI1CTpaTI1BHaTa Te)I(eCT BbPXY 6113HeCa 11 OrpaHl1qaBaHe Ha 61OpOKpaTl1QHaTa HaMeca. Ta311 )1,eHHOCT 113l1CKBa rrOCTOHHHI1 YCI1JII1H OT CTpaHa Ha )1,bp)I(aBaTa, 3alll,OTO 61OpOKpaUl1HTa HI1KOra He OTCThrrBa rr03l1Ul1l1 11 rrpaBOMOlll,RH 6e3 6I1TKa. JIl1rrCaTa Ha CTPYKTYpa, KOHTO )1,a HOCI1 OTroBopHocrra 3a 3aKOHa, e 3a6eAA3aHa e)1,Ba rrpe3 2009 r., KoraTO e HarrpaBeH HeycrreIIIeH Orrl1T 3a rrpeXBbpJIHHe Ha Te311 YHKUI1I1 KbM MI1HI1CThpa Ha rrpaBOC'b)1,l1eTO 11 MI1HI1CThpa Ha I1HaHCI1Te. 4.2 CAe(JcmsWl HU npOOJle.M.u · BHCOKH palXOAH Ha oH3Heca, CBbp3aHH C KaHAHAaTCTBaHe H rrOJIY'IaBaHe Ha JIHueH3HH, perHCTpaUHH, pa3pemeHHH H YAOCTOBepeHHH. Te311 Pa3XO)1,I1I1MaT KaKTO lfHaHcoBo 113pa)I(eHl1e, TaKa 11 113MepeHl1e, CBbp3aHO CbC 3ary6aTa Ha ueHHO BpeMe. B'bB I1HaHCOBO OTHOIIIeHl1e oc06eHO Ba)I(HI1 ca 3ary6l1Te, rrp0l13Tl1Qalll,l1 OT BI1COKI1Te TaKCI1 3a 113)1,aBaHe Ha pa3peIIIeHI1H. TIoHHKora Te311 TaKCI1 rro HI1KaKbB HaQI1H He ca CB'bp3aHI1 C peaJIHI1Te Pa3XO)1,11 3a 06CJIY)KBaHe Ha 6113HeCa, ace rrpeBpblll,aT B Cpe)1,CTBO 39 3a rrpepa3rrpe)1,eJIeHl1e Ha )1,OXO)1,11 B rroma Ha 61OpOKpaTl1QHaTa MaIIII1Ha. TIo T03H HaQHH ce rrOJIYQaBa )1,BYKpaTHO I1HaHCHpaHe Ha YCJIyrHTe: rrbpBO, )1,aHbKOrrJIaTUI1Te rrJIalll,aT H 61O)1,)KeThT pa3rrpe)1,eJIH pecypCI1 3a a)1,MI1HI1CTpaTHBHO 06cny)KBaHe Ha 6113HeCa 11, BTOPO, 3a Cblll,aTa yCJIyra ce IIJIalll,a OTHOBO, T03H rrbT rro)1, opMaTa Ha )1,OrrbJIHI1TeJIHO MaTepHaJIHO CTI1MYJIHpaHe Ha CJIY)KI1TeJIHTe B a)1,MI1HI1CTpauI1HTa. · IIpoueAypHTe rro H3AaBaHe Ha perHCTpaUHH, pa3pemeHHH H YAOCTOBepeHHH He ca np03pa'lHH. He ce 113rr0Jl3BaT 6JIOK CXeMI1 3a aHaJIl13 Ha rrpoue)1,ypl1Te B )1,'bp)KaBHI1Te I1HCTI1TYUI1I1. ~OPI1 eJIeMeHTapeH aHaJIl13 Ha KOHTO 11 )1,a e rrpOue)1,ypa MO)I(e )1,a YCTaHOBI1 KOJIKO 3a6aBeH 11 rrperrJIeTeH Me)K)1.y Pa3JII1QHH BbTpeIIIHH 3BeHa e )1,OKYMeHTo060pOTbT, KOJIKO MHoro HCHY)I(HI1 3BCHa 06pa60TBaT rrpCrrl1CKI1TC 11 KaK ce 11I1JIee ueHeH pecypc 3a HeHY)I(HH orrepaUI1I1. OrrTHMl13aUl10HHl1HT H paUl10HaJIeH rro)1,XO)1, He ce 113rrOJI3BaT Hl1TO rrpl1 C'b3)1,aBaHeTO Ha rrpoue)1,ypI1Te, HI1TO rrpH THXHOTO rrpHJIaraHe. KaH)1,I1)1,aTCTBalll,HTe HpMH He rrOJIYQaBaT )1,OCTaThQHa H a)1,eKBaTHa HHopMaUHH 3a XO)1,a Ha rrpoue)1.ypam. 3aHBJIeHRHTa He BHHam ce 06pa6OTBaT rro pe)1,a Ha THXHOTO rrO)1,aBaHe; Harrpl1Mep, l1pMa, KOHTO e rrO)1,aJIa )1,OKYMeHTH rro-KbCHO, MO)Ke )1,a rrOJIYQI1 peIIIeHl1e rrpe)1,11 )1,pyra l1pMa, KOHTO e KaH)1,I1)1,aTCTBaJIa rro-paHO. TOBa MO)Ke )1,a BO)1,l1 )1,0 Cepl103Hl1 rrOCJIe)1,I1UH , KaTO: o C"b30a6ane na 6"b3MOJICnOCmu 3a Kopynl{UR. JIl1rrCaTa Ha rrp03paQHOCT BHHarl1 Cb3)1,aBa Bb3MO)KHOCTH 3a KopyrrUHH, 3alll,OTO JIl1rrCBaT MeXaHl13Ml1Te Ha BbHIIIeH KOHTPOJI 11 caMoKOHTPOJI Ha )1,eHHOCrra Ha a)1,MI1HHCTpaUI1HTa. o Pa3pelUa6ane na eona cWllla 61OpOKpal{UR oa npeoR6R6a neo6ocno6anu UCKanUR. BbrrpeKl1 Bb3MO)KHOCrra )1,a rrOJl3Ba I1H0pMaURH 3a CbCTOHHl1eTO Ha l1pMHTe OT YHKUI10HHpalll,I1Te rry6JIHQHH pemCTpl1, 61OpOKpaTl1QHam MaIIII1Ha 39 HarrpIlMep, rrpe3 2000 r. TaKcaTa 3a pemCTpHpaHe Ha aIITeKa 6erne onpe,neJIeHa Ha 5 000 JIB. TOBa ,noBe,ne ,no JIIIrrca Ha anTeKII B CeJICKIITe paHoHII. CJIe,n nonpaBKa Ha 3aKoHa 3a JIeKapCTBeHIITe npo,nyKTII 3a xYMaHHa H3HCKBa rrpH BC>IKa rrpoue,uypa cpHpMaTa )J,a rrpe)J,CTaB>I )J,OK)'MeHT 3a aK1YarIHO C'b)J,e6HO C'bCTO>IHHe, KOeTO BO)J,H )J,O H3nHIllHH Pa3XO)J,H H )J,y6nHpaHe. B )J,pyr CJ1yqaH, HarrpHMep, 6IOPOKpaUH>ITa He rr03BOJ1>IBa Ha KaH)J,H)J,aTa rrpOCTO )J,a npe)),CTaBH )),eKnapaUH>I 3a qHCTO C'b)),e6HO MHHarIO. BMeCTO TOBa ce H3HCKBa CBH)J,eTenCTBO OT C'b)),a 3a TOBa 06CTO>ITenCTBO, KoeTO 03HaqaBa rrOHe )),ByKpaTHo xo)),eHe )),0 C'b)),a, 3arrna:r.u;aHe Ha HeMarIKa TaKca 3ae)),HO C MOHorronHaTa KOMHCHOHa Ha 06CJ1Y)Ima:r.u;aTa 6aHKa 3a rrpeBO)), Ha CYMaTa no CMeTKa Ha C'b)),a. · BHCOKHBT ,llBJI H3 CHB3T3 HKOHOMHK3 e nOpO,lleH OT rOJIeMHTe Te~eCTH, H3JIO~eHH OT 3,llMHHHCTP3THBHOTO peryJIHp3He H KOHTPOJI. TOBa BO)J,H )),0 3ary6a Ha 06:r.u;ecTBeHo 6narOC'bCTO>IHHe H H3HCKBa rrOBeqe 06:r.u;ecTBeHH pecypcH 3a KOHTpon H caHKUHH Ha cpHpMHTe OT CeHqeCTH>I 6H3Hec. BHCOKH>IT )],>In Ha CeHqeCTaTa HKOHOMHKa BnH>Ie 3ne B'bpXY 6H3Hec cpe))'aTa H 6H3Hec eTHKaTa, 3a:r.u;oTo rrOCTaB>I nerHTHMHHTe CPHPMH B HepaBHOCTOHHa KOHKypeHTHa n03HUH>I. · HeperJI3MeHTHp3HOTO BbBe~3He H3 peryJI3TOpHH pe~HMH OT CTPaHa Ha MeCTHHTe BnaCTH C'b:r.U;O orpamlqaBa rrpe)),rrpHeMaqeCKaTa aKTHBHOCT. · BJIOllIeHHBT 6H3Hec KJIHM3T pecpneKTHpa B nO-HHCKa HHBecTHUHoHHa aKTHBHOCT H HaMarIeHa KOHK)'peHTOCnoc06HOCT Ha HKOHOMHKaTa. HrypaTa no-)),ony rrpe))'cTaB>I Harne)),Ho OCHOBHH>I rrp06neM, OCHOBHHTe rrpHqHHH ("KopeHH") H rrocne)),HUH Ha rrp06neMa (npHqHHHO-cne)J,CTBeHHTe Bp'b3KH). Ci)Hrypa 17: Ha npoo.nelMa orpaH ..""eH o6xaaT H. 3aKOH_ - pa-- -~' 1: "".paM. ~. ""'H. pecyPCM orpa"M...eHO npMnaraHe Ha ·~M.....,.. ... an"ItOTO C"brnaCMe" Hee._IeTHaHa ,:~~tl~t'l1~ CMCTeMa 3. -.. "'tC:~i"~_ MOMTpon .. caH""'"" ,""nca "a aAMM"MCTpaTM , -~.... )~ 6ha~:"Jte BeH pentcn:..p " - - .. ' nM"ca Ma KOHTpoJ1HO 3 · ·HO .I1MnCa Ha OB .........-. orpaH......... ""......anc_ Ha HGaMTe peJKMMM OCHOBeH np06neM \!I3TOYHI1K: rpaI1KaTa e CbCTaSeHa OT aSTOpI1Te. 4.3 Ocn06JfU npenOp'l:iKU 3a npOMeJfU 630APAKC,a C orJIetl npeOtlOJIHBaHe Ha npHcbmHTe CJIa60CTH Ha 30APAKC,n; H peaJIH3HpaHe Ha no rOJIeMH nOJI3H OT HerOBOTO npHJIo*eHHe, ce npenOpbqBaT TpH rpynH OT npoMeHH B 3aKoHa. Te3H "pOMeHH HMaT 3a ueJ1 ,1l,a: (l) IIO,1l,06p}lT HerOBHTe a,ll,MHHHCTpaTHBHH pa:mope,1l,6H (HHCTPYMeHTMHH IIpoMeHH); (2) 3aCHJ1}1T HerOBam HHcTHryuHoHMHa IIO,1l,KpeIIa (HHCTHryUHOHMHH IIpoMeHH); H (3) YCTaHOB}lT ,1l,OIIbJ1HHTeJ1HH HOpMH IIpH OIIpe,1l,eJ1}1He Ha a,1l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe TaKCH (HKoHOMHqeCKH IIpoMeHH). IIo-KoHKpeTHo IIpeIIopbKHTe IIO rpY"H BKJ1IOQBaT, KaKTO CJ1e,1l,Ba: HHCTpYMeHTaJIHH npoMeHH · BbBe)K)laHe Ha HOBH KJIroQOBH npHHUHnH (HanpHMep, H36HrBaHe Ha ,Ll,y6JIHpaHeTo Ha nO,Ll,aBaHe Ha H,Ll,eHTHQHH ,Ll,OKYMeHTH 3a UeHTpaJIHaTa H 3a MeCTHHTe BJIaCTH) Ha a,Ll,MHHHCTpaTHBHO 06CJIYlKBaHe B 3aKoHa, KOHTO ,Ll,a ce OTHaCHT ,Ll,0 BCHQKH OTHOIlleHHH Me)K,Ll,y 6H3Heca H a,D,MHHHCTpaUHHTa; · I1pHJIaraHe Ha npHHUHna Ha "MbJIQaJIHBOTO CbrJIaCHe" no OTHOIlleHHe Ha pelKHMHTe Ha perHCTpaUHH; · illHPOKO npHJIOlKeHHe Ha ,Ll,eKJIapaUHH 3a CbOTBeTCTBHe, 3ae,Ll,HO C nO,Ll,XOMlUH MexaHH3MH 3a npOBepKa Ha Te3H ,Ll,eKJIapauHH, BMeCTO H3HCKBaHeTO 3a npe,Ll,CTaBHHe Ha oqmUHaJIHH ,Ll,OKYMeHTH, KOHTO ce H3,Ll,aBaT OT Cb,Ll,a HJIH ,Ll,pym a,D,MHHHCTpaTHBHH opraHH; · Onpe,Ll,eJ1}lHe Ha MHHHMaJIeH CPOK, B KOHTO KaH,Ll,H,Ll,aTbT 3a JIHueH3 HJIH palpeIlleHHe ,Ll,a MOlKe ,Ll,a OTCTpaHH Hepe,Ll,OBHOCTH B nO,Ll,a,D,eHOTO 3aHBJIeHHe; · 110,Ll,06pjlBaHe Ha Ha,D,30pa H KOHTpOJIa BbPXY MexaHH3Ma Ha caHKUHOHHpaHe BbTpe B a,D,MHHHCTpaUHjlTa H HaMaJ]}lBaHe Ha TOBapa BbPXY KOHTpOJIHpaHHTe qmpMH; · BbBe)K)laHe Ha HHCTpYMeHTapHYM 3a aHaJIH3 Ha CbOTBeTCTBHeTO Ha npe,Ll,JIaraHHTe peryJIaTOpHH pelKHMH C TpHTe rpynH KpHTepHH (HalJUOHaJllW CUzypHocm, llU'-I11U U uiwyU/ecm6eHU npa6a Ha zpaJICoaJJUme U OKOllHa cpeoa), CbrJIaCHO 3aKOHa. HHCTHTYUHOHaJIHH npOMeHH · Cb3,Ll,aBaHe Ha 3BeHO KbM a,D,MHHHCTpaumlTa Ha MHHHcTepcKHjI CbBeT, KOeTO ,Ll,a KOHTpOJIHpa npHJIaraHeTO Ha 3aKoHa H ,Ll,a HaJIara HaKalaHHjI Ha ,Ll,JIblKHOCTHHTe JIHua npH HeCnalBaHeTO My; · I13rpa)K)laHe Ha e,Ll,HHeH A,Ll,MHHHCTpaTHBeH pemCTbp Ha perYJIaTOpHHTe pelKHMH 3a nOJIYlJaBaHe Ha JIeCHO,Ll,OCTbnHa HHq,opMaUHjI H YKalaHHH 3a BCHlJKH npOue,Ll,ypH H BCHlJKH He06xo,Ll,HMH ,Ll,OKYMeHTH. HKOHOMH'IeCKH · BbBe)K)laHe Ha ,Ll,OnbJIHHTeJIHH npHHUHnH 3a onpe,Ll,eJ1}lHe Ha TaKCHTe 3a a,Ll,MHHHCTpaTHBHO 06CJIYlKBaHe; · PemaMeHTHpaHe palMepa Ha TaKCHTe Bb3 OCHOBa Ha npe,Ll,BapHTeJIHO npHeTH npaBHJIa; · BbBelK,Ll,aHe Ha npHHUHna "e,Ll,Ha npOue,Ll,ypa - e,Ll,Ha TaKca". BbBe)K)laHe Ha 3a6paHa 3a cb6HpaHe Ha ,Ll,OnbJIHHTeJIHH TaKCH npH ,Ll,OnbJIHHTeJIHH ,Ll,eHCTBHR no OTCTpaHjlBaHe Ha Hepe,Ll,OBHOCTH OT 3a}1BHTeJIHTe HJIH KaTO ,Ll,OnbJIHHTeJIHO MaTepHaJIHO CTHMYJIHpaHe Ha a,Ll,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe cnylKHTeJIH ,Ll,a H3nbJIH5IBaT CBOHTe 3a,Ll,bJIlKeHH5I. Te3H IIpeIIopbKH H IIpe,1l,J10)KeHHTe "pOMeHH MoraT ,1l,a 6b,1l,aT OT IIoma 3a 6bJ1rapCKHTe BJ1aCTH IIpH H3nomBaHeTO Ha 30APAKC)], 3a HaCbpQaBaHe Ha perYJ1aTOpHaTa peq>opMa. Ho Te Tp}l6Ba ,1l,a ce H3BbpIIIBaT IIapMeJ1HO H B CHHXPOH C ,1l,pyrH ,1l,eHHOCTH H MepKH, 3MO)KeHH B IIporpaMaTa 3a IIO-,1l,06po perYJ1HpaHe H ,1l,pym CBbp3aHH HHHUHaTHBH. E,1l,HH YCbBbpIIIeHCTBaH 3aKOH MO)Ke ,1l,a ce IIpeBbpHe B MOI.IJ;HO Cpe,1l,CTBO 3a OCbI.IJ;eCTB}lBaHe Ha pelIH ECK (2007). CbIIJ,eCTBYBaIIJ,MTe perYJIaUMM BbPXY CTorraHCKaTa ,neHHocT M OT,neJIHMTe ,nei1HocTM B EbJIrapIDI - aKTYarreH rrperrre,n M rrpe,nJIOJKeHM5I. )],OKJIa,n Ha ECK: CO~M5I. I1KoHOMMqeCKM M COUMarreH CbBeT, CTaHOBMIIJ,e Ha I1KoHOMMQeCKM5I H COUMarreH CbBeT rro "Bb3MOJKHOCTM 3a HaMal I51BaHe Ha a,nMMHHcTpaTMBHHTe npeQKM M rro,n06p5lBaHe Ha 6M3Heccpe,nam B EbJIrapM5I", 2009 r. KOHCOPll,MYM ,,)],JKeHKb6c EH,n ACOIlIMei1Tc IOpbrr JIMMMTM,n M I1HCTMTYT 3a rraJapHa MKoHoMMKa", PaJBMTHe Ha crroc06HoCTM 3a M3BbpllIBaHe Ha oueHKa Ha Bb3,nei1cTBMeTo Ha 3aKOHo,naTeJICTBO M nOJIHTMKH, 2009 r. )],oKYMeHT, M3fOTBCH 3a 3BeHoTo 3a rro-,n06po pcryJIMpaHe KbM a,nMMHMCTpall,M5ITa Ha MC, ~MHaHcMpaH OT EBponcHcKM5I COll,MarreH ~OH,n. )],oCThneH Ha www.strategy.bg KOHCOPUMYM ,,)],JKeHKb6c EH,n ACOlliMCHTC IOpbrr JIMMMTM,n M I1HCTMTYT 3a na3apHa HKoHoMMKa", 3a rro-,n06po 06IIJ,eCTBeHo yrrpaBJIeHMe: I1HcTHTYUMOHarrM3MpaHe Ha np0ll,eca no oueHKa Ha Bb3,nCHCTBHCTO B ,nbpJKaBHaTa a,nMHHMCTpall,M5I, IOHM 2009 r. )],OKYMCHT, M3rOTBCH 3a 3BCHOTO 3a no-,n06po pcryJIMpaHC KbM a,nMMHMCTpall,H5ITa Ha MC, ~MHaHcMpaH OT EBponci1cKM5I COll,MarrCH ~OH,n. )],oCThrreH Ha www.strategy.bg KOHCOPUMYM "npOCKT: A,nMMHMcTpaTMBHM TeJKCCTH 3a 6M3Hcca", Onpc,neJI5IHC M M3McpBaHC Ha a,nMMHMcTpaTMBHaTa TeJKCCT, rrpOM3TMQaIIJ,a OT 3a,nbJIJKCHIDITa 3a MH~opMMpaHc Ha 6M3Heca M rrpc,nrrOJKeHMe 3a T5IXHOTO HaMarr5lBaHe, IOHM 2009 r. npoYQBaHC cpc,n ~HPMM Ha a,nMHHMcTpaTMBHHTe M pcrYJIaTOpHMTe pa3XO,nM, Mai1-0KToMBPM 2009 r., A,nMHHMCTpall,M5I Ha MC. CBcToBHa 6aHKa (2010). EbJIrapM5I: PC~opMMpaHc Ha pCJKMMa Ha ,nbpJKaBHHTe TaKCM. BallIMHITOH: CAIlI.. CBcToBHa 6aHKa (2008). EbJIrapM5I: OueHKa Ha MHBCCTMUMOHHIDI KJIMMaT. BaIIIMHIl'OH: CAIlI.. 3aKOHH, llOCTaHOBJJeHHH H tlpyrH H3CJJetlBau.H tlOKYMeHTH: 3aKOH 3a OrpaHHQaBaHe Ha a,ll,MHHHCTpaTHBHOTO perymrpaHe H a)1,MHHHCTpaTHBHM5I KOHTPOJI BbPXY CTorraHCKam ,nCHHOCT. )],B, 6p. 55, 17 IOHM 2003 r.; 3aKoH 3a HC3aBMCMMMTC OUCHMTCJIM (2008). 06H. )],B, 6p. 98, 14 HOCMBPM 2008 r.. 3aKoH 3a CJICKTPOHHOTO yrrpaBJICHMC (2007). 06H. )],B, 6p.46, 12 IOHM 2007 r.. 3aKoH 3a ThprOBCKM5I pemcThp. 06H. )],B, 6p.34, 25 arrpMJI 2006 r., M3MCHCH, )],B, 6p.44, 12 IOHM 2009 r.. YKaJaHM5I 3a rrpMJIaraHC Ha 3aKoHa 3a OrpaHMQaBaHe Ha a,nMHHMcTpaTMBHoTO pcryJIHpaHC M a,nMMHHcTpaTMBHH5I KOHTPOJI BbPXY CTOrraHCKaTa ,nCi1HocT, 2004 r. )],OKYMCHT Ha CbBcTa rro MKOHOMMQCCKa rrOJIMTMKa KbM MC Ha EbJIrapIDI. Y cTpoiicTBeH rrpaBHJIHHK Ha MC M HerOBaTa a,ll,MMHMcTPall,M5I, )],B, 6p.1 0 OT 2009 r. nMC 192 3a Cb3,naBaHe Ha CbBeT 3a a,nMHHMcTpaTMBHaTa pe~opMa. )],B, 6p. 64 OT 2009 r. MMHMcTepcKM CbBeT (2010). _ _KoHBepreHTHa rrporpaMa 2009-2012. )],oKYMeHT Ha rrpaBMTeJICTBOTO Ha EbJIrapIDI. __(2009a). npOfpaMa Ha npaBIUeJICTBOTO 3a eBponeifcKo pa3B11T11e Ha EbJIrapI151 2009-2013. 'uoKYMeHT Ha npaB11TeJICTBOTO Ha EbJIrap11H. (20096). Onpe.lleJIHHe 11 113MepBaHe Ha a.llM11H11CTpaT11BHaTa Te)KeCT, np0113T11Qama OT 3a)lbJI)KeH11HTa 3a 11HQD OT qepDD D QBeTDD MenUB. 27. ,l1;eHHocTH B 06nacrra Ha eHeEreTHKaTIl. ltlltl ltl ltlltlltl H3BbpIIIBaHe Ha ,L{eHHOCTH, CB'bp3aHH C H3nOJI3BaHe Ha H,L{peHH CbOp'b)f(eHMj{ H JI.ll.peH 28. ltlltlltl ltlltlltl ltlltlltl MaTepHaJI H ,L{pyrH H3TO'IHHIJ,H Ha HOHH3HpamH JIblIeHMj{. Ynpa)f(HJlBaHe Ha cTpOHTeJIeH Hamop npH 29. ltlltl ltlltl ltlltl H3rE~aHe Ha CTPOHTeJIHH 06eKTH. H3B'bpllIBaHe Ha )f(eJIe30ITbTeH npeBo3 Ha II'bTHHIJ,H WHJIH TOBapH H IIpoBepKa Ha 30. TeXHHlIeCKaTa H3npaBHOCT Ha B03HnaTa H ltlltl ltlltl ltlltl npaBocIIoco6Hocrra H KBaJIH$HKal~HJlTa Ha i n<':EcOHaJIa. I H3BbpIIIBaHe Ha 06ll\eCTBeHH npeBo3H Ha 31 .· n'bTHHIJ,H H TOBapH C aBTOM06HJIeH TpaHCnOpT, ltlltl BKJIIO'lHTeJIHO Me)f(,L{YHapO,L{eH. I H3BbpIIIBaHe Ha npoBepKH Ha TeXHH'IeCKa . H3IIpaBHocT Ha n'bTHH npeBo3HH Cpe,L{CTBa, 32. peMoHT H TeXHH'IeCKO o6cnY)f(BaHe Ha TaKHBa ltlltl ltlltl Cpe,L{CTBa. i H3B'hpmBaHe Da YDBBepeaJlDaTa OOlQeBCn I 33. YeJJYT8 BJln B8 YeJ'I)TR, BKJIIOqeHB B 06XB8Ta Da YHHBepeaJ1BaTa OOlQeHCn YCJlYT8. 34. H3B'bpllIBaHe Ha nOll\eHCKH napH'!HH npeBO,L{H. ltl H3B'bpllIBaHe Ha ,L{eHHOCT KaTO neTHlll,eH ~~ - - - __ _____ ..... _ ....... __ ......... ..-.. ....1t..-.,... ..... , ~ ~ ~ nOcneABaw,a 04eHKa Ha Bb3AeMCTBHeTO Ha 30APAKCA »nPIiI110>KEHIiIR J1Ir1J1HH Ha....OBaJlHa HH)'JQecTBeHH earypHoeT, OKOJIR8 J1RneIDHOReH ~KpRTepRii HpaBBR8 oGineeTBeH pe~ epe~a ~HRTeH H eyaepeHRTeT IOJI TeXHH'IeCKO 06cn:y:)f(BaHe H peMoHT Ha 36. aBHaIJ,HOHHa TeXHHKa. 00 · npoHJBO~CTBO, BHoe uJRJlH paJOpoeTp8HeRRe I 37. Ha Dpe.pUTeJJBB p~ e'ItOp1ioJIreHRJI Ja ~aueKR~H. 38. Pap,HO- H TeJIeBH3HOHHa ,[(eHHocT. 00 0 ~ 113B'bpIllBaHe Ha npeB03 Ha roBapH no B'bTpeIllHH BO,[(HH II'bTHma. 00 40. Ilpe'[(ocTaBJIHe Ha COQHaJIHH YCJIym 3a .n.eQa. 0 113B'bpIllBaHe H y.n.ocTOBepJlBaHe Ha 41. 0 npoc\JecHOHaJIHO 06Y'IeHHe. 113B'bpIllBaHe Ha HHKEHH.R Pe2IDIMB l8 IIpol{eAYpa DO ofiJJ:eK'laBaUe 3aKOU OrroBOp Cl.eToJI:uBe ofiJJ:eK'laBaBe B BRK npeMaxBaae 4. llpeMHHaBaHe OT .flHueH3HOHeH KbM 3aKoH 3a M3X OOJleK'IeH JIHl\CU3HpaHc Ha perHcTPaUHoHeH pe*HM. IIpC,lIBIDK,ila cc ,lIa BCTcpHHapHO O,llo6peu C 3l1.lJ: Ha 3aKoHa 3a n.proBIDI Ha 6b,llC HanpaBCHO H3MCHCHHC 'III. 375 Ha 3aKoHa MC,lIHl\HHCKaT BCTCpHHapHOMC,lIH1IHHCKaTa ,lIPC6HOC 3a BCTcpHHapHoMe,1HlIHHCKaTa ,lIeHHocT. LJpe3 a lleHHocT ,lICHHOCT C PemeHHe .N'e 699 BeTepHHapHOMC,lI npeMHHaBaHc Ha pClKHMa B perHc'I'pal\HOHCH Hl\HHCKH OTna,lla Bb3MOlKHOCTra Ha a)J,MHHHc'I'pllTHBHIDI Ha Me OT 06.11.2008 r. oprau ,lIa OTKa3Ba H3BbplliBaHCTo Ha ,lIeHHOCrra PelKHMbT e OOneK'IeH npO,llyKTH no IlellCCb06pa3HOCT, a CbflIaCHO '111. 14, a3a OOCb*,llaHe. IIy6mlKYBau Ha nOp'I'aJIa 3a o6ll\eCTBeHH KOHCY1lTal\IiH www.stratcgv.bg 5. IIpel'\BIilKM cc ,lIa 6b,llC H3roTBeH npoeKT Ha 3aKOH 3a MOHI OOneK'IeH JIul\CH3 3a 3l1.lJ: Ha 3aKoHa 3a np0a3a OOCb*)1;aHe. IIy6JIHKYBaH Ha nOpTKEHHE 2 .. - - - ..- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - PmEIlMBla BpoQeAYpa DO 06JJeK..aB8Be 3aKOB OrroBop Ci.eTOJIIIIIe 06JJeKQaBUe B BIlK OpeMaUaBe CbXpaHJlBaHe, 2. CbKprullaBaHe Ha cpoKoBeTe 3a c1>rJlacYBaHe npeABapHTeJlHO Ha TIporpaMHTe Ha ynpaB,1eHHe Ha AeHUOCTHTe TIpOCKThT H8 31m H8 3YO e TpeTHpaHe, no OTna,llbl\HTe UanOJIOBHHa B 'iJI. 30 ce BKJIIOqeH B pa3KOMIIJIeKTOBa 38KOHO,Ll,8TeJIH8rn nporp8M8 C1>3,1laBaT HOBH aJIHHeH 7, 8 H 9, B KOHTO ce He, per,1aMeHTllpaT nO-KpaTKHTe cpoKoBe. H8 Me 38 p83r.1C*L\8HC H8 onOJJ30TBOpjIBaHe 25,06,2009 r. H/H,1H * )lo MOMeHTa cpoKoBeTe ca 30 ,IlHH. o6e3BpelK.llaHe Ha 3. TIaI>ta~BaHe Ha 06mHjI CPOK 3a OTna,ll1>l\H YfB1>plK.llaBaHeTO Ha WHpMeHHTe nporpaMH 3a ,IleilHOCTH C OTlIa,Il1>l\H C 30 ,IlHH, a B cJly'iail Ha e,llHOKpaTHo Bp1>mrufe 3a o'!'CTpaHJlBaHe Ha Hen1>JlHOTH ,IlO 75 ,IlHH: TIpe,llJlOlKeHO e OTna,llaHe Ha ,IleHCTBama pa3nope,ll6a ('iJI. 30, aJI. 4) - ,,)J,HpeKTOP1>T Ha pemOHaJIHam HHCneKl\HJf no OKOJlHaTa cpe,lla H BOAHTe, Ha 'iHJfTO TepHTOpHJf e CeAaJIHlI\eTO no ThprOBCKHJf pemcThp Ha JIHl\aTa, YTB1>plK.llaBa npoeKTa Ha lIporpaMaTa CJle,ll nOJI)''IaBaHe Ha CTaHOBHmaTa 3a C1>macYBaHeTO HM OT perHOHaJIHHTe HHcneKUHH lIO OKOJIHaTa cpe)la H BO)lHTe, Ha 'lHHTO TepHTOpHH ca H3BbpIlIBaT r~eilHOCTHTC» . 7. CTaHoBHme Ha MOCB: 3aKoH 3a MOCB lie3 npoMcHu Pa3peIlIeHHe Ha "OpraHH3auHHTe no On0JJ30TBOpjIBaHe ca ynpaB,1elme OpraHlf3al\HJf no oc06eH BHL\ IOpIiJlH'IeCKH Cy6eKT, KOHTO HMa Ha MOCB He npe,Ll,BH*L\8 OnOJI30TBOpliBaHe MO)laJIHTeTH cnpliMO OCTaHaJlHTe ThprOBCKH OTna,llbl\HTe OTna,Ll,8HC Ha pa3peIlIHTeJIUHJf cy6eKTH. Ha nbpBO MlICTO Te aKyMyJlHpaT pelKHM. npeOTCThneUH ny6JIH'IHH cpe)lCTBa 01' CTpaHa Ha ,Il1>plKaBaTa. Ha BTOPO MlICTO HlIMaT npaBO Jla pa1npe)leJIllT ne'iaJI6a. Ha TpeTO MliCTO Te MoraT ,Ila pa3XOlIBaT aKYMYJlHpaHHTe cpeACTBa caMO 3a onpe,lleJIeHH IreJIH H MHHaBaT crreIIHaaeH elKcroAeH O,llHT 3a TOBa. ETO 3amO Te CJle,llBa ,Ila OCTaHaT Ha pa3peIlIHTeJlCH pClKHM." i 8. H3MeHCHHlITa B 3aKoHa 3a 3all\HTa Ha 3aKoH 3a M3X lie:l IIpoMeHH Pa3peIlIeuHe Ha paCTeHHlITa 01' 28.03.06 r. IIO OTHOIlICHHe Ha 3amHTaHa JIHl\aTa, KOHTO paCTeHHJfTa pa3pcIlIHTeJIHHJf pelKHM ca B npoTHBOpe'lHe CbC M3X He IIpCrrBH*L\8 BHaClIT, 3aKOHa 3a OrpaHH'laBaHe Ha omarr8HC Ha pelKHMa 3a IIpo,llaBaT, a,IlMHHHCTPa'fHBHOTO peryJIHpaHe H pa3peIlIeUHe Ha JlHl\aTa, KOHTO pa3'i>aCOBaT H onaKOBaT a,IlMHHHCTpaTHBHHlI KOHTpOJI BbPXY BHaClIT, npOMBaT, pa3'i>acOBaT npoilYKTH3a CTOHaHCKaTa JleHHOCT, ThH KaTO pa3peIlIeHHeTO H onaKOBaT rrpOilYKTH 3a paCTllTeJlHa ce H:3)laBa 3a H3BbpillBaueTO Ha OT)lCJlHa c)leJlKa paCTHTCJlHa 3aIHlITa C 3amllTac IIHII AeHCTBlle, a PClKIIMbT no CbmeCTBO C TbprOBCKa UCH. ThprOBCKa lIeJI pemCTpaIIIlOHCH. 11,111 113BbpWBaT 3a nepHoila 2008-2010 r. He ce npe,llBHlKJIa PelKHM1>T 3a H3BbpuIBaHe Ha paCTInCJlHO 06JIeK'IaBaHe Ha pa'lpeIlIHTCJIHHJf pelKHM 3a paCTHTeJIH03amHTUH yClIym e 3amHTHH ycnym ThprOBHJf H rrpeonaKOBaHe Ha npoilYKTH 3a OTII8rrHa.'1. paCTHTelIHa 3aIl\HTa. PelKHMbT 3a H3BbpWBaHe 06H. )].B, 6p. 26/2006 r. Ha paCTHTeJIH03amlITHH yClI)'fH Be'IC C OTna,llHalI. i nOClleABa~a ou.eHKa Ha B'b3AeiiicTBHeTO Ha 30APAKCA » nplo1J10)KEHIo1S1 PeamMB3a npoQeA)'pa DO o6.lJeJCq8B8He 3aKOB OrrOBOP C'bCTORHBe 06JieJCq8B8He B BBK npeMauaBe 9. flpeMHHaBaHe KbM 0)]'06peHHe Ha 06eKTUTe 3aKoH 3a M3X1 06JIeK'IeH PerHC"rpHpaHe Ha CbrJIaCHO IBHCKBamurra Ha PerJlaMeHT BerepHHapHo MOCB 0'1~06peH e 3liJ( Ha 3aKoHa 3a 06eKTH 3a 1774/2002IEO .. IIpol\etJ.YpaTa no oLl06peHHe e MeilHl(HHCKaT BerepHHapHoMeLlHl~HHcKaTa 06e3BpelK,UaHe Ha B qJI. 229, all. 2, Komo npenpaIl.\a ICbM a ileHm)CT ileHHOCT C PemeHHe X! 699 CTpaHHqHH oLl06pHTeJlHaTa npOl\eLlypa no qlI. 228, aJi. 2-7. Ha MC OT 06.11.2008 r. lKHBOTHHCKH 061IeKqeHHerO Ha pelKHMa e B 3HaQHTelIHOTO npoilYKTH H Ha C"bKpamaBaHe na cpOKOBeTe. PelKHMbT e 06JIeK'IeH npoJ\YKTH. CbrlIaCHO KOJIOHa 2. nonyQeHH OT TJlX flpoeKTbT Ha 3D.)], e BHeceH B Hapo)]'HoTO Cb6paHue Ha 07.11.2008 L fi'LPBO 'Ie1'eHe Ha 12.03.2009 L a3a 06CblK,UaHe. IIy6J1HKYBaH Ha nop-raJIa 3a 06meCTBeHH KOHcYJITal\HH ~ www.strategy.bg 10. 113roTBeH e rrpoeKT Ha IIocTaHoBJleHHe 3a 3aKoH 3a MPPE 06,leK'IeH Pa3pellleHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHe H J\onblIHeHHe Ha HapeJ\6aTa 3a TeXHHQeCKHT flMC X! 225 01' 10.09.2008 L 3a JIHI~a CbmeCTBeHHTe H3HCKBaHHJI KbM cTPoelKHTe H e H3HCKBaHHJI 3a H3MeHeHHe H ilOn"bJlHeHHe H3BbplllBaHe Ha Ol(elUIBaHe CbOTBeTCTBHero Ha c'rpoHTelIHHTe KbM Ha HapeLl6aTa 3a Ol(eHJIBaHe Ha rrpoJ\YKTH. M3MeHeHHJlTa ca cBbp3aHH C rrpoAYKTHTe C"bmeCTBeHHTe H3HCKBamlJl CbOTBeTCTBHero HaMaJIJlBaHe 6poJl Ha H3HCKBamHTe ce KbM cTPoelKHTe H OueHJIBaHe Ha cTPoHTeJIHHTe J\oKYMeHTH, KaKTO H Ha cpoKa 3a H3L1aBaHe Ha CbOTBerCTBHero Ha npoLlYKTH pa3pelllenHe 3a OueHJIBaHe Ha CbOTBerCTBHeTO cTpoHTelIHHTe npotJ.YKTH. B cnyQaH, qe JIHueTO, KOero KaJI,lIH,lIaTCTBa, npe,llcrasH KOnHJI OT BaJIHJ\HH CepTH!pHKaTH 3a aKpe,llHTaI{HJI 3a CbmHJI o6xBaT 01' npoilYKTH, CTaH,lIapm H KOMnereHl(HH, 3a KOHTO KaHilHLlaTCTBa. 11. IIpe,llsHlK,Ua ce C H3MeHeHHe H J\onbJIneHHe Ha 3aKoH 3a MTI1IC flpe)]'CToH palr.1elKJ],aHe Pa3pellleHHe 3a 3aKoHa 3a aBTOM06HlIHIITe npeB03H ,lIa 6bJ\aT aSToM06HlIH M3rOTBeH e npoeKT na 3liJ(. H3BbplllBaHe Ha rrpeUH3HpaHH TeKCToseTe, orrpe).l;eJlJlmH HTe npeB03H IIpoBetWHa e cpema na cnyqaHHH 0J\06peHHeTo 01' cTPaHa Ha M\MHHHC"rpaUHJITa MIMIC CbC aBT06ycHH no OTHOIlJeHHe Ha cnyqaHHHTe aBT06YCHH 3aHHTepecoBaHHTe crpaHH, Ha npeB03H npeS03H, HO KaTO UJlJlO MJlpKaTa me 6b,lle 3ana'leHa. KOJITO He e nOCTHrHaTO CbrlIaCHe. flpe)]'CTOH BK.llO'IBaHe B laKOHo)],a1'CJIHa1'a nporpaMa HaMe 12. B npoeKTa Ha 3aKoH 3a H3MeHeHHe H 3aKoH 3a MIMIC flPC)]'C1'OH pa3rJIClKJ],aHC Pa3peIIleHHe 3a ilOnbJIHeHHe Ha 3aKoHa 3a aBTOM06HJIHHTe aSTOM06HJIH M3roTBeH e npoeKT Ha 3M,ll H3BbpillBaHe Ha npeB03H perHcTPaUillrra me ce H3KlIIOqH OT HTe npeB03H IIpose).l;eHa e cpema Ha TaKcHMerpoB tPYHKUHHTe Ha MIMIC, CbOTBeTHO MTI1TCcbc npeB03 M3nbJIHHTelIHa areHl(HJI "ASTOM06HlIHa 3aHHTepecoBaHHTe crpaHH, Ha a,lIMHHHcTpaUillI", H me ce OCbmecrBJlBa OT CbOTBeTHHTe 06Il\.\1HH CJIe,ll H3L1aBaHe Ha KOJITO He C nocTHruaTo pa'peillcHHe. TaKa cc ilaBa Bb3MOlKHOCT Ha CbfJIaCHC. 06mHHCKHJI CbBer ila onpeLleJIJI 6poJl Ha npC)]'CTOH BKJIIO'IBaHe B TaKcHMerpoBHTe aBTOM06HJIH Ha TepHTOpHJlTa laKoHo)],a1'CJlHa1'a nporpaMa Ha 06mHHam, KaKTO H YClIOBHJlTa H pe,lla 3a HaMC pa'lnpC,lICJIJlHerO HM nOMelKLlY HM. nPHIlO>KEHHE 2 P~MB3a IIpo..e~pa no 06JJeK1laBaBe 3aKOB OrroBop CLeToaBBe 06JJeK1l8BaHe B HBK npeMaXBaBe 13. B npoeKTa Ha 3aKOH 3a H3MeHeHHe H 3aKOH 3a ,nAT OTMenen KaTeropH3HpaHe LlonbllHeHHe Ha 3aKOHa 3a TYpH3Ma ce TYpH3Ma C PemenHe X! 47 OT 29 Ha TYpHcTH'lecKH npeLlBHlKL\a H3MeHeHHe B '1JI. 50, aJI. 2, C KoeTO HH)'apH 2009 r. Ha 06eKTH OTnaLla KaTeropH3HpaHeTo Ha MHHHcTepcKlliI CbBeT e caMOCTmrreJIHHTe 3aBeLleHlliI 3a xpaHeHc H npeMaxnaT pelKHMbT 3a pa1BllC'IeHlliI. KaTerOpH3all,H1I Ha 3aBeLlCHlliI 3a XpaHeHe H3BbH MeCTaTa 3a nOLlCllOH. UpOeh."'ThT ua 311)1, e Bneceu B HapOJlUOTO ch6pauHe ua 30.01.2009 r. UhPBO 'IeTene U9 12.03.2009 r. (()a39 06ch~9ue. 14. B npoeKTa Ha 3aKoH 3a HC3aBHCHMHTe 3aKoH 3a Ml:lET 06JIeK'IeU JIH~eH3uPaHc Ha O~CHHTellU ce npeLlBulKL\a 3aMllHa Ha He3aBHCHMHT PemenHe Xli 462 OT 01\eHHTCllH Ha LlOCeralIlm!lI llH~eH3HOHeH pelKHM C e OI~eHHTellU 15.07.2008 r. Ha pa31lH'IHH BHgOBe perHcTpa1\HOHell, KaTO perYllHpalleTO Ha MHHHCTepcKlliI CbBeT. aKTHBH LleHHocTTa Ha He3aBHCHMHTe 01\eHHTeJIH me ce PelKHMbT e npeXBbpJIeH 3a OCbmeCTB5IBa OT npo4>ecHOHaJIHa opraHH3a~H5I caMoperyllHpaHe OT 6paHlIloBa - KaMapa Ha He3aBHCHMHTe o~eHHTeJIH. opranH3a1\IHI. UpOeKl"bT U9 311)1, e Bueceu B HapOJlUOTO ch6panHe ua 16.07.2008 r. UpHfT H9 30.10.2008 r. 06UapOJlBaU J].B 6p. 98/2008 r. 15. CTaHoBHIIW Ha MTl1TC: B pe3Y1ITaT Ha 3aKOH 3a MTl1TC lie3 npoMenH JlH~eH3 3a KOHcY1!Ta~HH B EBponeiicKara KOMHClliI ITO rpaJKLlaHCKOT OITCpaTOp Ha np0611cMH, Bb3HHKHaJIU C LlOCThITa gO na3apa 0 MTHTC ne npe,!(BWk,il9 JIeTHlI~Ha Ha Ha3eMHO 06clIYlKBaHe, CTaHa lICHO, 'Ie He ca Bb3L1YXOITJIaB pa3rJIe~9Ue ua T03H Ha3CMHa LlCHHOCT naJIHue YC;IOBHHTa 3a OTnaJlane na JIHuen3a aHe pexmM. 3a OITCpaTOp ITO Ha3eMHO 06ClIYlKBaHC. 3aTOBa ce HaJIara ,!(a 6bLle 3ana3eHa Bb3MOlKHOCTra, npeLlBH,[\CHa B J].HpeKTHBa 96/67, fJIaBHa LlHPCKl\lliI "fpalKLlaHCKa Bb3L1YxOnJIaBaTeJIHa aLlMHHHCTpa1\lliI" Jl9 H3JlaBa oJl06peUHe npe,[\H npCnOCTaB5!mllilT Ha3eMHOTO 06clIYlKBaHe na 3anO ' IHe ,[\a OCbn~eCTBKBa LlellHocT Ha na3apa Ha Jla,[\CHO JIernm:c. TOBa 0,[\06peHlle H~e 6bLle H3L1aBaHO Bb3 OCHOBa Ha KCHH KpHTepHH, npoH3TH'I~U OT J].HpeKTUBa 96/67 U me 6bge 06Bbp3aHo C HCllHHTC npUHll,HnU CbrJIaCHO '1JI. 14, naparpa4> I OT J].upCKTUBaTa. 16. He3aKoHocbo6pa3eH pelKHM - HPOTHBOpC'IH Ha HapeLl6H Ha M,nAAP PelKHMbT ce e aLlMHHHcTpHPaJI PemcTpa1\lliI Ha 'IJI. 4, aJI. 1 OT 3aKoHa 3a orpaHU'IaBaHe Ha 06mHHHTC OT 140 06mHHH lanpHJI 2008 ThproBcKH 06cKT a,i(MuHHcTpaTHBHoTO perYJIHpaHe H r.l aLlMHHHCTpaTHBHlliI KOHTpOJI BbPXY KbM MaPT 2009 r. PClKHMbT e CTonanCKaTa LlCHHOCT OTMeucu B 110 06m:HUH B bbllrapHli. 1II3TO'lHI, MTCIl, MOCB, MIl ,[(0 12.2008 r. 1- prupafiOTBaHe Ha MeTo,[(onOrHR 3a H3BbpiliBaHe Ha npen;BapHTeJIHa nbJIHa MC, MHE, MAAAP, oueHKa Ha Bb3,[(eHcTBHeTo Ha npOeKTH Ha HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe; X M, MTCIl, MOCB, MIl - pa3pafiOTBaHe Ha KpHTepHH 3a li3fiop Ha npOeKTH Ha HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe, Ha 12.2008 r. MC, MME, MJlAAP, Komo ,[(a ce npaBRT npe,[(BapliTenHH nbnHH oueHKli Ha Bb3'[(eHcTBHeTo, KaKTO H M, MTCIl, MOCB, Ha YCJIOBHR li pe,[( 3a nnaHlipaHe H3BbpmBaHeTo Ha TaKHBa ou;eHKH B xo,[(a Ha Ix MIl li3rOTBRHe Ha 3aKOHo,[(aTeJIHaTa llPVI palVla Ha MC; - npoMeHli B 3aKoHa 3a OrpaHH'IaBaHe Ha a,[(MliHlicTpaTliBHoTO peryJIlipaHe li 12.2008 r. MC,MIl aAMliHlicTpaTliBHHR KOHTPon (B HaCOKa nOAofipRBaHe Ha KOHTPOJIHHR MeXaHli3bM IH LlP.), 3aKoHa 3a HopMaTliBHliTe aKTOBe (B HaCOKa BbBeJK,n:aHe Ha ~ll ~nHa rrpe,[(BapmenHa ou;eHKa Ha Bb3'[(eHcTBHeTO), Y CTPOHCTBeHliR npaBHJIHHK Ha MliHliCTepCKHR CbBeT li Ha HerOBaTa a,[(MliHlicTpaUHR (3a onpeAeJUlHe Ha !X KEHHR OnepaTBBBB QeJlB B MepKII CPOK OTrOBOpBB OT 04.2008 r. MC, pecopHH - CTapTHpaHe Ha H3B'hpIIlBaHeTO Ha n'hpBHTe OlWHKH Ha B'h3,ueiicTBHeTO; MHHHcTepcTBa OT 01. 2009 MC, pecopHH, - cTapTHpaHe Ha H3B'hpIIlBaHeTO Ha 3a,u'hJDKHTeJIHH oueHKH Ha Bb3,ueiicTBHeTo no r. MHHHCTepCTBa pa3pa60TeHHTe KpHTepHH H MeTo,uOJIOrIDI; I OT 09.2009 r. MC, pecopHH - H3B'hpIIIBaHe Ha nOCJIe,uBallla oueHKa Ha Bb3,ueiicTBHeTO; MHHHCTepCTBa -I MxpKa 2.4. C'h3,uaBaHe Ha 3HaHIDI H YMeHIDI B a,uMHHHCTpauIDITa 3a npHJIaraHe Ha oueHKa Ha Bb3p;eiicTBHeTO Ha npOeKTH Ha HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe. p;o 12.2008 r. - paJpa60TBaHe Ha nporpaMa 3a 06Y'leHHe, C'h06pa3eHa C MeTOp;OJIOrIDITa 3a MC, MME. M)J,AAP H3B'hpIIIBaHe Ha OUeHKa Ha B'h3,ueiicTBHeTo; H I1IlAEM OT 12.2008 r. - npOBe)Kp;aHe Ha 06Y'leHHe 3a JIeKTOpH; MC, MME, M)J,AAP Ix H I1nAEI1 OT 01.2009 r. - npOBe)Kp;aHe Ha 06Y'leHHe Ha CJIY)KHTeJIH OT a,uMHHHCTpauIDITa; MC, MME, M)J,AAP Ix HMnAEH - paJpa60TBaHe Ha nporpaMa 3a 06Y'leHHe, C'h06pa3eHa C MeTo,uOJIOrIDITa 3a H3B'hpIIIBaHe Ha ou,eHKa Ha B'h3p;eiicTBHeTo; MHpKa 2.5. 3aCHJIBaHe Ha KOHTpOJIa H OT'leTHocrra. - B'hBe)K,llaHe Ha 3a,u'hJI)KeHHeTO npoeKTHTe Ha HOpMaTHBHH aKTOBe, B'hBe)K,llaUlH OT 01.2009 r. MC ap;MHHHCTpaTHBHH pe)KHMH H perJIaMeHTHpamH npHJIaraHeTO HM, ,ua 6'h,uaT BHaCHHH B MHHHcTepcKIDI CbBeT CJIe,u npep;BapHTelIHO KOHcYJITHpaHe CbC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH, CbC 3BeHOTO 3a no-,u06po peryJIHPaHe H C'hC 3a,u'hJI)KHTeJIHa nne, reJIHa oueHKa Ha JH)51J,.;ik"'l>l'lvlV, 09.2008 r. M)lAAP - CTapTHpaHe Ha Ap;MHHHCTPaTHBHHH pemcThp npeAOCTaBHHe Ha aKTyarrHa H TOQHa HH$opMau,IDI OTHOCHO C'hlllecTBYBalllHTe perYJIaTOpHH pe)KHMH H!X ap;MHHHCTpaTHBHH yCJIyrH; 12.2008 r. M)lAAP - e$eKTHBHo H3n0Jl3BaHe Ha A,uMHHHCTPaTHBHIDI pemcThp 3a KOHTPOJI Ha , ! Oll3Heca B'hPXy a)J,MllHllcTpllpaHeTO Ha pe)KHMllTe; e)Kero,uHO, M. MC - H3rOTBaHe Ha e)KerOp;eH ny6JIHQeH ,uOKJIaA 3a H3n'hJIHeHHe Ha nOJIHTHKaTa 3a no- MapT iJ,06po peryJIHpaHe; KpaH Ha 2008 AOn, MC, M)lAAP MHpKa 2.6. Pa3IIIHpHBaHe Ha 06xBaTa Ha iJ,aHHHTe H no,u06pHBaHe Ha ,uOCThna ,uo ~,; r. HH$OpMaUHH B PerHCThpa Ha 06lllecTBeHHTe nOpb'lKll. 03.2009 r. perYJIaTOpHHTe MxpKa 2.7. Pa3pa60TBaHe Ha HH,uHKaTopH 3a H3MepBaHe Ha H3n'hJIHeHHeTO 3a opraHH, MC ,ueiiHocrra Ha KOHTpOJIHHTe opraHH. 03.2010 r. perYJIaTOpHHTe MxpKa 2.8. OueHKa Ha H3n'hJIHeHHeTO Ha ,ueiiHocrra Ha KOHTPOJIHHTe opraHH. opraHH, MC IJ,EJI 3. AKTHBH3HPAHE HA ,[(HAJIOrA C'hC 3AHHTEPECOBAHHTE CTPAHH nOCTOHHeH BCHQKH HHCTHTyuHH MapKa 3.1. 3a,u'hJI)KHTeJIHO, CBoeBpeMeHHo H e$eKTHBHo KOHCYJITHpaHe C'hC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH. MapKa 3.2. Pa3pa60TBaHe H BHe,upHBaHe Ha nOJIHTHKa 3a 3a,u'hJI)KHTeJIHO H nPHllO)l{EHHE 3 OUepaTBBHH QeJIH HMepKH CpoK OrroBoPHR 0 0. . . 0.:1 . . . . . . CTRHJJ.apni H rrpaKTHKa OT EBporreiicKIDI Cb103. 09.2008 r. IMC, MMET, - pa3pa6oTBaue Ha rrpOl(e}l.ypH 3a KOHcymal(HH; Ix M,MAP OT 09.2008 r. MC, M,MAP, - o6yqeHIDl Ha a}l.MHHHCTpal(IDlTa 3a rrpOBe)J(}l.aHeTO Ha KOHCYJITal(HH KaTO '!aCT OT MIIAEM rrpoueca Ha ou:eHKa Ha Bb3}l.eiicTBHeTo; Ix 03.2009 r. MC 1- pa3pa6oTBaHe Ha HOB MO}l.YJI H $YHKl(HOHaJIHOCT Ha rrOpTaJIa 3a 06rn;eCTBeHH KOHcYJITaU:HH 3a rrpe}l.J10JKeHIDl OT 6H3Heca, HerrpaBHTeJICTBeHIDl ceKTop HX Irpa)J(}l.aHHTe 3a rrotJ,06pHBaHe Ha perymfpaueTO; MHpKa 3.3. KOHCYJITauHH C'bC 3aHHTepeCOBaHH rpynH OT CpCAHTe Ha 6H3Hcca OTHOCHO nOCTOHHeH MME, MC, pecopHH l>I.UUHa POJIJI B CHCTCMaUI Ha 01\eHKa Ha B'b3,ll,CHCTBHCTO. MHHHCTepCTBa ' 10.2008 r. MC MHpKa 3.4 ,lJ,a ce Y}l.bJ1JKH cpoKa 3a KOHcymaUHH CbC 3aHHTepeCOBaHHTe CTpaHH . Qpe3 H3MeHeHHe Ha 3aKoHa 3a HopMaTHBHHTe aKTOBe. . rrOCTOHHeH PecopHH MHpKa 3.5. 3atJ,bJ1JKHTeJIHO ny6JIHKYBaHe Ha HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe, cBbp3aHH C MHHHCTepCTBa atJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHOTO perYJIHpaHe, tJ,a 6btJ,aT ny6JIHKYBaHH Ha nOpTaJIa 3a 06rn;eCTBeHH KOHCYJITaUHH HaH-MaJIKO 30 }l.HH npetJ,H BHaCHHeTO Ha 3acetJ,aHHe Ha i MHHHcTepcKIDl CbBeT. II,EJI 4. YC'hB'hPllEHCTBAHE HA PErYJIHPAHETO HA OB:u.-HHCKO HHBO H YKPEllBAHE KAllAII,HTETA HA OBJIACTHO H OBUJ,HHCKO HHBO 3A llPOBElK,lI,AHE HA )1,OBPH PErYJlATOPHH llOJIHTHKH i MHpKa 4.1. ilperne}l. Ha atJ,MHHHcTpaTHBHoTO perYJIHpaHe H atJ,MHHHcTpaTHBHIDl KOHTPOJI BbPXY CTonaHCKaTa }l.eHHOCT Ha 06rn;HHCKO HHBO. OT 06.2008 r. - aHaJIH3 Ha BbBe}l.eHHTe peJKHMH Ha 06rn;HHCKO HHBO; MC, M)1,AAP, X }l.O 02.2009 r. HCOPI> 02.2009 r. - OTMHHa Ha He3aKoHocbo6pa3Ho BbBe}l.eHH peJKHMH; 06rn;HHCKH CbBeTH, 06JIaCTHH Ix ynpaBHTeJIH , 05.2009 r. 1- npe}l.JIOJKeHHH 3a 3aKOHO}l.aTeJIHH npoMeHH C ueJI YCbBbpUIeHcTBaHe Ha MC, KMeTOBe, I KOHTPOJIa BbPXY peryJIHpaHeTo Ha MeCTHO HHBO; : 06l.UHHCKHTe CbBeTH, 06JIaCTHHTe ynpaBHTeJIH, HCOPI> <'<' iMHpKa 4.2. CpaBHHTeJIeH aHaJIH3 Ha perYJIaTOpHHTe npaKTHKH Ha 06l.UHHCKO " <.s OT 09.2008 r. MC, M,MAP, HHBO. }l.O 09.2009 r. HCOPI> MHpKa 4.3. Y cbBbpUIeHcTBaHe }l.eHHOCTTa Ha opraHHTe Ha MeCTHOTO caMoynpaBJIeHHe. 02.2009 r. - ChltJ,aBaHe Ha HaCOKH 3a no-tJ,06po perYJIHpaHe Ha 06rn;HHCKO HHBO; MC, M,MAP, MIIAEI1, HCOPI>, KMeTOBe, o6rn;HHcKH IX CbBeTH, 06JIaCTHH ynpaBHTeJIH L OoepaTBBHB QeJlB B MepKII CPOK OrroaoPHB BB.... .,. · .1_.. "co 02.-07.2009 - pa3rrpOCTpaHeHlIe Ha ,Z:\o6pme rrpaKTIIKII; Me, M,nAAP, , r. llI1AEll, HeOP}), , KMeTOBe, 06mllHcKII C'bBeTII, o6rracTHII , yrrpaBIITerrll 02.2009 r. - pa3pa60TBaHe Ha nrraTKEHHR I llOCTU llOCTU He llocTuruaTo HaD'bJIuo rHaTa rHaTa Mora TO nO-CKOpO IJ,eJIU nOCTurHa BhB B ~a e 06paTHOTO Ta BUCOKa HHCKa npe~e Ha ~eJITa CTeneH CTeneH HK ·;'t,C,f ~,;/, ,~,;r'; !,." ; ·;;'~'ii'j!t!' 1.1.(J(JujjJ~_~ ", ", .', I )J;a YJIeCHlI H HaC'bpqH H3B'bpIllBaHeTO Ha CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHOCT, KaTO orpaHIlqH )l,0 06IlleCTBeHO OnpaB)l,aHH rpaHHllH a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHOTO perYJIHpaHe H a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHH KOHTPOJI, OC'bIlleCTBHBaHH B'bpXY HeH OT )l,'bp:lKaBHHTe opraHH H OT opraHHTe Ha MeCTHOTO caMoynpaBJIeHHe. 7t· ~.! · .!",i'/0"';', "1fC'V " ';:i 114, t , ·... I~,,::;. 2 3aIllHTa Ha cB060)l,HaTa CTonaHCKa HHHllHaTHBa. i 3 .HCHO OqepTaBaHe Ha rpaHHllHTe 3a a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHa HaMeca B CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHOcT Ha lleHTpaJIHO H Ha MeCTHO HHBO. I 4 OrpaHHqaBaHe H nOCTOHHHO HaMaJlHBaHe Ha 06IlleCTBeHo HeOnpaB)l,aHOTO 06peMeHHBaHe Ha CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHocT. i I 5 i TOqHO )l,e$HHHpaHe Ha BH)l,OBeTe pe:lKHMH, KOHTO peryJIHpaT CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHocT. 6 YBeJIHqaBaHe Ha np03paqHOCTTa npH B'bBe)K)l,aHe Ha peryJIaTOpHH pe:lKHMH. 7 OrpaHHQaBaHe B'bBe)K)l,aHeTO Ha HOBH peryJlaTHBHH . pe:lKHMH (JIHlleH3HOHHH HJIH perHcTpallHOHHH) Qpe3 H3HCKBaHeTO 3a H3rOTBHHe Ha MOTHBHpaHo CTaHOBHIlle 3a He06xo)l,HMOCTTa OT TOBa peryJIHpaHe H npe)l,BapHTeJIHO YBe)l,OMHBaHe Ha 3acerHaTHTe JIHu,a. 8 IIpeMaxBaHe Ha HopMaTHBHHTe npe)l,nOCTaBKH, I KOHTO MoraT )l,a )l,OBe)l,aT )l,0 OrpaHHQaBaHe Ha KOHKYpeHllHHTa. I 9 HaMaJIHBaHe H3TOQHHllHTe Ha KopynllHH Qpe3 OrpaHHQaBaHeTO Ha )l,HCKpellHoHHaTa BJIaCT Ha a)l,MHHHcTpau,HHTa. 10 OCHrypHBaHe Ha ny6JIH'IHOCT B pa60Tam Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe opraHH no npHJIaraHeTO Ha HopMaTHBHHTe aKToBe, CB'bp3aHH C a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHo peryJIHpaHe H a)l,MHHHcTpaTHBeH KOHTPOJI Ha CTonaHCKaTa )l,eiiHOCT, KaKTO H MOTHBHTe 3a TSIXHaTa npOMHHa. L···· 1:3. tlJ fI61IU 11 CTaH)l,apTH3HpaHe Ha )l,OKYMeHTau,HHTa no Pa3JIH'IHHTe pe:lKHMH Ha a)l,MHHHcTpaTHBHo i perYJIHpaHe H KOHTPOJI. i npI!1JlO>KEHI!1E 4 ""--"" I Han'b.J1Ho rHaTa I II';"'. IIOCT" nOCTHrHaTo rHaTa TO no-clwpo He Mora i ll.e.J1H nOCTHrHa B'bB B )),a ' e 06paTHOTO Ta ' BHCOKa HHCKa npelle Ha lIe.J1Ta i CTeneH cnoeH i HR 12 ! i KOMnroThpH3HpaHe HnH npHBelK,lJ,aHeTO B neCHa 3a I ynoTpe6a wopMa Ha Cbrn.eCTBYBarn.HTe perHc1'pH. 13 I Y CbBbpmeHCTBaHe Ha BbTpeIllHOBeAOMCTBeHaTa I i KOOp,lJ,HHaIJ,IDl. 14 Y cbBbpmeHcTBaHe Ha KOOp,lJ,HHaIJ,HHTa Me)l(,lJ,Y ! : pa3nHQHH Be,lJ,OMCTBa, BKnroQHTeJIHO ,lJ,ocThna ,lJ,O i i cb,lJ,e6HH perucTpH H perucTpH no rpalK,lJ,aHCKOTo i CbCTOjlHHe. 15 BbBe)l(,lJ,aHe Ha o6cnylKBaHe Ha npHHIJ,Hna "Ha e,lJ,HO rHme" . 16 , 3aCHnBaHe Ha nOcne,lJ,Barn.HjI KOHTpon BbPXY CTonaHCKaTa ,lJ,eUHOCT Qpe3 npoBepKH Ha MHCTO H ! 8. I1o))'pe.1leTe no BalKHOCT TpllTe l\eJIll, KOIITO ca OOCTllrHaTll B Hail-rom!Ma CTeneH B HalJaJIOTO Ha 2010 r. Ii KOMeHTllpailTe nplilJliHIITe 3a T031i ycnex? (noJl3BailTe HOMepal\IlHTa OT B'bnpOC 7) 8.1. Ha n'bpBO MHCTO, l\eJI N~ 8.2. Ha BTOpO MHCTO, l\eJI N2 8.3. Ha TpeTO M}lCTO, l\eJI N2. 9. I1o.1lpe.1leTe no BaJKHOCT B o6paTeH pe.1l TpllTe l\eJIIi, KOIITO ca nOCTllmaTH B Hail-MaJIKa CTeneH IiJlIi 3a KOHTO pe3YJITaThT e no-cKopO o6paTeH Ha nOCTaBeHIiTe l\eJIIi B HalJaJIOTO Ha 2010 r. Ii KOMeHTlipaHTe npHlJHHIiTe 3a T031i Heycnex? (nOJl3BaHTe HOMepaQH.HTa OT B'bnpOC 7) 9.1. Ha mpBo MHCTO, l\eJI N!l 9.2. Ha BTOpO M}lCTO, l\eJI N2 9.3. Ha TpeTo MHCTO, l\eJI N!! 10. Ol\eHeTe no CKaJIaTa OT 1 )),0 5 CTeneHTa, B KO}lTO H36poeHHTe npHlJHHH Cn'bBaT eqlHKacHoTo npHJIaraHe Ha 30APAKC)l,. 1 - MHoro BIiCOKa 2 - BHcoKa 3 - HHcKa 4 - MHoro HHCKa 5 - He Mora .1la npel\eH.H (Mom!, OT[OBOpeTe Ha BceKH pe.1l) nocneASal..qa ou,eHKa Ha S'b3AeHCTSHeTO Ha 30APAKCA »npli1nO)KEHIi1J1 IIpuquua OueHKa i He)l;OCTaTh4eH 6pOH a.llMHHHCTpaTHBHH CJIYJKHTeJIH, KOHTO .lla H3nbJIHHBaT 1 .lleHHOCTH no npHJIaraHeTo Ha 3aKOHa. i i HHcKa KOMneTeHTHOCT Ha a.llMHHHCTpau;mITa - Hen03HaBaHe Ha 3aKOHOBHTe I 2 H3HCKBaHn1i:. J10llIa opraHH3aU;HH B a.llMHHHCTpaTHBHHTe CTPYKTYPH, KOHTO He rapaHTHpa 3 HaBpeMeHHoTo pa3rJIeJK.llaHe Ha nO.lla.L(eHHTe OT 6H3Heca .llOKYMeHTH. HeJKeJIaHHe .lla ce npeMaxHaT Bb3MOJKHOCTHTe 3a ynpaJKHHBaHe Ha BJIaCT OT 4 a.llMHHHcTpaU;HHTa Ha.ll 6H3Heca. I )KeJIaHHe Ha PbKOBO.llHTeJIH Ha u;eHTpaJIHO HHBO .lla oCHrypHT cpHHaHcoB 5 pecypc 3a CbOTBeTHHTe HHCTHTYU;HH. i )KeJIaHHe Ha pbKoBO.llHTeJIH Ha MeCTHO HHBO.lla oCHrypHT cpHHaHcoB pecypc 3a 6 CbOTBeTHHTe 06~HHH. i I 7 )KeJIaHHe Ha a.llMHHHCTpaU;HHTa .lla 3ana3H Bb3MOJKHOCTHTe 3a KopynU;HH. 8 Hen03HaBaHe Ha Bb3MOJKHOCTHTe, npc.llOCTaBHHH OT 3aKOHa, OT 6H3Heca. CJIa6H Bb3MOJKHOCTH Ha opraHH3aU;HHTe Ha 6H3Heca .lla HaJIaraT BHJK.llaHHHTa 9 CH Ha u;eHTpaJIHO H MeCTHO HHBO. 110 J1Hnca Ha .llOCTaTh4HO MOllI,HH H opraHH3HpaHH n06HTa Ha 6H3Heca. )KenaHHe Ha 6paHllIoBHTe opraHH3aU;HH no 3aKOHOB nbT .lla CH rapaHTHpaT. nonY4aBaHeTo Ha Cpe.llCTBa 4pe3 H3.llaBaHeTO Ha CbOTBeTHHTe .llOKYMeHTH 3a 11 npaBocnoc06HoCT. I )KenaHHe Ha nOJIY4HJIHTe "JIHu;eH3" HJIH "pa3pellIHTeJIHO" 6H3HecH .lla i 12 OrpaHH'IaBaT KOHKypeHU;HHTa. I J1Hnca Ha a.llMHHHCTpaU;HH, KOHTO .lla e H3pH4HO OTrOBOpHa 3a npHJIaraHe Ha i 13 3aKoHa. J1Hnca Ha eKcnepTeH nOTeHU;HaJI 3a H3nbnHeHHe Ha H~KOH H3HCKBaHHH Ha· 3aKoHa, KaTO HanpHMep 3a.L(bJIJKeHHeTO 3a H3rOTBHHeTO Ha ou;eHKa Ha 114 Bb3.lleHCTBHeTO npe.llH npHeMaHeTo Ha HOBH HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe. .ll.pyru (H36poHTe B cne.llBamHTe pe.llOBe): nPHnO>KEHHE 4 11. I10Ll.KperuITe JIM HarrpaBeHMTe rrpe)lJIO)KeHM5I? He, I )),a, )),a, cJle~ ceramHOTO He, no He Mora ~a npe~JlOJKeHHe aHaJlH3 H CbCTOBHHe CKOPO 6e3ycJloBHO npeneH . OneHKa CJle~Ba ~a ce 06paTHoTo i 3ana3H ! H I 11 HaMamIBaHe 6pOH Ha I i i JUfIJ,eH3HOHHHTe pe)f(HMH. I 1 , HaMaJIHBaHe 6pOH Ha . 12 perHCTpaI\HoHHHTe pelKH~ I -. 3 · OrpaHHqaBaHe B'b3MO)f(HOCTHTe I · Ha MeCTHaTa BJIaCT Ll,a B'bBe)f(LI,a' I pe)f(HMH qpe3 rrpaBoTO CH Ha MeCTHO HOPMOTBOpqeCTBO. 14 1 Pa3111HpHBaHe npaKTHqeCKOTO I I · rrpHJIaraHe Ha "M'bJIqaJIHBOTO i i C'brJIaCHe". I I i 5 I HaMaJIHBaHe Ha cpOKOBeTe 3a I · OTrOBOP Ha aLl,MHHHCTpaIVUlTa. i 6 HaMaJIHBaHe qeCTOTaTa Ha npoBepKHTe (Ha OCHOBara Ha ,rrpHHIJ,Hna: rrO-Ma'lKO Ha 6pOM' i IrrpoBepKH, HO rrO-BHCOKH rJI06H I I 3a HapYllleHHHL _ _._ _.. . 17 HaJIaraHe Ha rrO-BHCOKH I rrepCOHaJIHH mo6H Ha aLl,MHHHCTpaIJ,mna rrpH i · HeCrra3BaHe Ha 3aKOHa. - ---.- ... .. i 8 OrrpocTHBaHe Ha rrpoIJ,eLl,ypaTa rro rrOLl,aBaHe Ha Ll,OKYMeHTH (6pOM, BHLI, Ll,OKYMeHTH - HarrpHMep, qaCT OT H3HCKBaHHTe · Ll,OKYMeHTH Ll,a ce 3aMeHHT C I Ll.eKJIapaIJ,HH). i I i ..- -..- - . I 9 · Y BeJIHqaBaHe Ha 3aKOHOBHTe 1 ! B'b3MO)f(HOCTH Ha 6H3Heca Ll,a ce caMoperyJIHpa. 10 CTPYKTypHpaHe Ha aLl,MHHHCTpaTHBeH 'KOMTO Ll,a ce opraH, B'b3JIO)f(aT Ha I i i MOHHTOp HHThT H KOHTpOJI'bT. i r __+-B_'b~XYH3rr'bJIHeHHeTOHa3a~K~O~H~a~.4-__________r-________ -r________--~--------+-------4 11 YBeJIHqaBaHe GpOH H oGxBaTa Ha HHI}>0pMaIJ,HOHHHTe KaMrraHHH 3a 3an03HaBaHe Ha 06~ecTBeHocTTa, 6H3Heca H · aLl,MHHHCTpaIJ,HHTa C'bC 3aKOHa H i CB'bp3aHHTe C Hero HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe. · B'bBe)f(Ll,aHe Ha oGyqHTeJIHH rrporpaMH 3a aLJ,MHHHCTpaIJ,HHTa Ha IJ,eHTpa'lHO H MeCTHO HHBO 3a rr HJIaraHe Ha 3aKOHa. _.._ _ _' - _ _ _ _ _-.l_ _ ._ _- ' _ _ _ _ _ _ _....J'-_ _ _ _ _ _ l _ _ _ _---.J _ _ .._ _..._ nOClleAB31l.\3 04eHK3 H3 Bb3AeHCTBHeTO H3 30APAKCA »rlPlo1nO>KEHIo1S1 He, He Mora .11.a, cJle,ll ceralUHOTO He, no- .11.a, ,Ila llpe,llJlOiEeHHe aHaJlH3 H C'bCTOSfHHe CKOpO tie3ycJloBHO npeQeR OQeHKa CJIe,llBa ,Ila ce otipaTHoTo Sf 3ana3H 13 YBeJUIIJaBaHe Ha 3a,uemIHH.SI 61O,u)KeT 3a KOHcYJITaHTCKH yCJIyfH 3a ,ueHHocTH. H3HCKBaHH OT 3aKOHa HanpHMep. H3fOTB.SIHe Ha ou:eHKa Ha Bb3,ueHcTBHeTo 3a BceKH i HOBonpHeMaH HopMaTHBeH aKT I I 14 )J.pym npe,uJIO)KeHH.SI (onmlleTe): i 12. HanpaBeTe BalIIHTe KOMeHTapH no npe.l1.J10)KeHHHTa B ropHHH B'hnpoc. llpe.l1.JlOiKeHHe KOMeHTap I HaMaJI.SIBaHe 6p05£ Ha JIHu:eH3HOHHHTe pe)KHMH. i 2 HaMaJI>lBaHe 6po>£ Ha pemcTpaIJ,HOHHHTe pe)KHMH. OrpaHHIJaBaHe Bb3MO)KHOCTHTe Ha MeCTHaTa BJIaCT ,ua BbBe)K,ua pe)KHMH IJpe3 npaBoTo 3 CH Ha MeCTHO HOPMOTBOpIJeCTBo. I 4 Pa3Ump.SlBaHe npaKTHIJeCKOTO npHJIaraHe Ha "MbJIIJaJIHBOTO CbrJIaCHe". I i 5 HaMaJI.SIBaHe Ha cpoKoBeTe 3a oTroBop Ha a,uMI.JHHCTpaU:H>£Ta. I HaMaJI.SIBaHe IJeCTOTaTa Ha npoBepKHTe (Ha OCHOBaTa Ha npHHU:Hna: nO-MaJIKO Ha 6POH I I 6 npoBepKH, HO nO-BHCOKH fJI06H 3a HapYllIeHH>£). i I HaJIaraHe Ha nO-BHCOKH nepCOHaJIHH fJI06H Ha a,uMHHHCTpaU:H.SITa npH Hecna3BaHe Ha I I 7 3aKOHa. . i ! OnpocT>£BaHe Ha npou:e,uypaTa no no,uaBaHe Ha ,uoKYMeHTH (6pOH, BH,u ,uoKYMeHTH - I HanpHMep. IJaCT OT H3HCKBaHHTe ,uoKYMeHTH ,ua ce 3aMeH.SIT C J~eKJIapaU:HH). 8 i · YBeJIHIJaBaHe Ha 3aKOHOBHTe Bb3MO)KHOCTH Ha 6H3Heca,ua ce caMoperyJIHpa. I 9 CTPYKTYPHpaHe Ha OT,ueJIHO 3BeHO (a,uMHHHCTpaTHBeH opraH), Ha KoeTO ,ua ce Bb3JIO)KH 10 KOHTPOJ1bT BbPXY H3nbJ1HeHHeTO Ha 3aKOHa. YBeJUiIJaBaHe 6po.Sl H 06XBaTa Ha HH!f.>0pMaU:HOHHHTe KaMnaHHH 3a 3an03HaBaHe Ha 06meCTBeHOCTTa, 6H3Heca H a,uMHHHCTpaU:H>£Ta CbC 3aKOHa H CBbp3aHHTe C Hero 11 HopMaTHBHH aKTOBe · BbBe)K,uaHe Ha 06YIJHTeJ1HH nporpaMH 3a a,uMHHHCTpaU:H>£Ta Ha u:eHTPaJIHO H MeCTHO 12 · HHBO 3a npHJ1araHe Ha 3aKoHa. I YBeJ1HIJaBaHe Ha 3a,uemIHH>£ 61O,u)KeT 3a KOHcYJ1TaHTCKH yCJ1YfH 3a ,ueHHocTH, : H3HCKBaHH OT 3aKOHa - HanpHMep H3fOTB>£He Ha ou:eHKa Ha Bb3,ueHcTBHeTo 3a BceKH 13 i HOBonOHeMaH HOOMaTHBeH aKT. i nPlAnO>KEHIAE 4 13. I1Ma nH KOHKpeTHH TeKCTOBe B 30APAKCJJ" KOHTO HCKaTe,ll,a KOMeHTHpaTe H/HnH Cne,ll,Ba ,ll,a ce npOMemlT? 13.1. He 13.2. il:a, a HMeHHO .....................................·............................................ 14. )l(enaeTe nH ,ll,a CnO,ll,CnHTC Olll.C HCllI.O, KoeTO 6H ,ll,OnpHHCcno 3a nO,ll,06p5IBaHC Ha TCKCTOBCTe Ha 30APAKCJJ, HnH npHnaraHCTO MY? llpUAo;m;eHue 5: AH(LIlua Ha omZ060pume ua aauHmepe C06aHume cmpaHu ua 6'bnpOCHUKa om cOlJuo/lOZU'leCKOmO npoy'l6aHe Ou.eHK3 H3 nOCTHraHeTO H3 u.eJlHTe, 33JlOiKeHH B 30APAKC,ll.4o 3a u;emue Ha amUIH3a OTrOBopHTe ca rpynHpaHH B )l,ByMepHa CKaJIa: · I10cTHrHaTH BbB BHCOKa CTeneH; · HenOCTHrHanf u;eJIH (rrocTHrHaTH B HHCKa cTerreH). OT aHaJIH3a Ha OTrOBopHTe Ha Bbrrpoca "KaK Ou;eH}lBaTe CTerreHTa Ha rrOCTHraHe Ha u;eJIHTe Ha 30APAKC,I.( KbM HalfaJIOTO Ha 2010 r." MO)Ke )l,a ce HarrpaB}lT CJIe)l,HHTe H3BO)l,H: .:. lJ,eJIH, rrOCTHTHaTH BbB BHCOKa CTerreH. Ha)l, 70% OT peCrrOH)l,eHTHTe ClfHTaT, lfe peaJIH3HpaHeTo Ha u;eJITa "TOlfHO )l,eq,HHHpaHe Ha BH)l,OBeTe pe)KHMH, KOHTO peryJIHpaT CTorraHCKaTa )l,eHHOCT" e rrOCTHrHaTO BbB BHCOKa CTerreH 41. I1OJIOBHHaTa H Ha)l, rrOJIOBHHaTa OT OTrOBOpHJIHTe rrOCOlfBaT KaTO nOCTHrHaTH BbB BHCOKa CTerreH CJIe)l,HHTe u;eJIH Ha 3aKOHa: · ,I.(a YJIeCHH H HaCbplfH H3BbpIIIBaHeTO Ha CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHOCT, KaTO orpaHHlfH )l,0 06II.J;eCTBeHO OnpaB)l,aHH rpaHHU;H a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHOTO peryJIHpaHe H a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHH}l KOHTPOJI, OCbII.J;eCTB}lBaHH BbPXY He}l OT )l,bp)KaBHHTe opraHH H OT opraHHTe Ha MeCTHOTO caMoyrrpaBJIeHHe; · 3aII.J;HTa Ha CB060)l,HaTa CTorraHCKa HHHU;HaTHBa; · >ICHO OlfepTaBaHe Ha rpaHHU;HTe 3a a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHa HaMeca B CTonaHCKaTa )l,eHHOCT Ha u;eHTpaJIHO H Ha MeCTHO HHBO; · OrpaHHlfaBaHe B'bBe)K)l,aHeTO Ha HOBH perYJIaTHBHH pe)KHMH (JIHu;eH3HOHHH HJIH perHCTpaU;HOHHH) lfpe3 H3HCKBaHeTO 3a H3rOTB}lHe Ha MOTHBHpaHO CTaHOBHII.J;e 3a He06xo)l,HMOCTTa OT TOBa perYJIHpaHe H rrpe)l,BapHTeJIHO YBe)l,OM}lBaHe Ha 3acemaTHTe JIHU;a · ·:. HenOCTHrHaTH u;eJIH. Ha)l, 80% OT aHKeTHpaHHTe ClfHTaT, lfe He ca rrOCTHrHaTH CJIe)l,HHTe u;eJIH Ha 3aKOHa: · YBeJIHlfaBaHe Ha rrp03palfHOCTTa npH BbBe)K)l,aHe Ha peryJIaTOpHH pe)KHMH; · HaMaJI}lBaHe H3TOlfHHU;HTe Ha KopyrrU;H» lfpe3 orpaHHlfaBaHeTO Ha )l,HCKpeU;HOHHaTa BJIaCT Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaU;H}lTa; · OCHryp}lBaHe Ha ny6JIHlfHOCT B pa60TaTa Ha a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHHTe opraHH rro rrpHJIaraHeTO Ha HopMaTHBHHTe aKTOBe, CBbp3aHH C a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBHO perYJIHpaHe H a)l,MHHHCTpaTHBeH KOHTPOJI Ha CTorraHCKaTa )l,eHHOCT, KaKTO H MOTHBHTe 3a T}lXHaTa rrpOM}lHa; · YCbBbprneHCTBaHe Ha BbTpernHOBe)l,OMCTBeHaTa KOOp)l,HHaU;H}l; · Y CbBbprneHCTBaHe Ha KOOp)l,HHaU;H}lTa Me)K)l,y Pa3JIHQHH Be)l,OMCTBa, BKJIIOlfHTeJIHO )l,OCThrra )l,0 cb)l,e6HH pemCTPH H perHCTpH no rpa)K)l,aHCKOTO CbCTO}lHHe. 40 ):(eJI'bT Ha nOJIY'l.eHHTe H 06pa60TeHH AO M. jIHyapH 2010 f. OTfOBOPH B'b3J1H3a Ha OKOJIO 40 npOIJ,eHTa OT 06IIJ,0 nPHIlO>KEHHE 5 HaLJ, 70% OT oTrOBOpliJIliTe ca li36pOliJIli CJIeLJ,HliTe lJ,eJIli KaTO HerrOCTlirHaTli: · TIpeMaxBaHe Ha HopMaTliBHliTe rrpeLJ,rrOCTaBKli, KOliTO MoraT LJ,a LJ,OBeLJ,aT LJ,O orpaHIfIlaBaHe Ha KOHKypeHlJ,lina; · CTaHLJ,apTli3lipaHe Ha LJ,OKYMeHTalJ,mlTa rro Pa3JIW-IHliTe peJKliMli Ha aLJ,MliHliCTpaTliBHo peryJIlipaHe li KOHTPOJI; · BbBeJKLJ,aHe Ha 06CJIYJKBaHe Ha rrpliHlJ,lirra "Ha eLJ,HO rlillIe". nO)lpe~)laHe no Ba~HOCT Ha u:enHTe. TpliTe lJ,eml, KOliTO ca IIOCTlirHaTli B HaM-romIMa CTerreH LJ,O HatIKEHHfI TIOJJ;Kpena Ha HanpaSeHHTe npeJJ;JlOJKeHHH aT aHaJIlf3a Ha OTrOBoplfTe no HanpaBeHlfTe npe.[(JlO)l(eHlUI 3a MepKlf, KOlfTO )l,a )l,OBe)l,aT )l,0 nOBlfIIIaBaHe e$lfKaCHOCTTa Ha nplfJIO)l(eHlfeTO Ha 3aKOHa, MO)l(e )l,a ce HanpaB5IT CJIe)l,HlfTe lf3BO)l,lf: PeCnOH)l,eHTlfTe nO)l,Kpen5IT 6e3YCJl06nO CJIe)l,HlfTe npe)l,JIO)l(eHlf5I 42: · BbBe)l()l,aHe Ha 06yqlfTeJIHlf nporpaMlf 3a a)l,MlfHlfCTpaUlf5ITa Ha ueHTpaJIHO If MeCTHO HlfBO 3a nplfJIaraHe Ha 3aKOHa (nplf 90% OT oTrOBOplfTe); · YBeJIlfqasaHe Ha 6po5I If 06XBaTa Ha lfH$opMau,lfoHHlfTe KaMnaHlflf 3a 3an03HaBaHe Ha 06mecTBeHocTTa, 6lf3Heca If a)l,MlfHlfcTpau,lf5ITa CbC 3aKOHa If CBbp3aHlfTe C Hero HopMaTlfBHlf aKTOBe (nplf 80% OT oTroBoplfTe); · OnpOCT5IBaHe Ha npou,e)l,ypaTa no nO)l,aBaHe Ha )l,OKYMeHTlf (nplf 75% OT oTroBoplfTe). TIpe)l,JIO)l(eHlf5I, KOlfTO peCnOH)l,eHTlfTe nO)l,Kpen5IT, HO Clleo U36'bplU6ane na anllJlU3 U oqenKa: · HaMaJI}}BaHe qeCTOTaTa Ha npoBepKlfTe (Ha OCHOBaTa Ha nplfHUlfna: nO-MaJIKO Ha 6pOH npoBepKIf, HO nO-BIfCOKH rJI061f 3a HapYIIIeHH5I) (nplf 75%); · YBeJIlfqaBaHe Ha 3aKOHOBlfTe Bb3MO)l(HOCTH Ha 61f3HeCa )l,a ce caMoperyJIlfpa (nplf 75%); · YBeJIlfqaBaHe Ha 3a)l,eJI}}Hlf5I 61O)l,)l(eT 3a KOHcYJITaHTCKH yCJIyrlf 3a )l,eHH 0 CTIf, lf3lfCKBaHlf OT 3aKoHa (HanplfMep, 1f3rOTB5IHe Ha OB 3a BceKlf HOBonpHeMaH HopMaTIfBeH aKT) (nplf 75%). . TIpe)l,JIO)l(eHlf5ITa, KOlfTO nOJIyqaBaT nplfHu,lfnHa nO)l,Kpena, KaTO oTroBopHTe ce pa3npe)l,eJI}}T nopaBHo (50:50) Me)l()l,y ,,6e3YCJIOBHO" If "CJIe)l, aHaJIlf3 H ou,eHKa", BKJIlOqBaT: · HaMaJI}}BaHe 6po5I Ha perYJIaTOpHlfTe pe)l(lfMlf; · OrpaHlfqaBaHe Bb3MO)l(HOCTlfTe Ha MeCTHaTa BJIaCT )l,a BbBe)l()l,a pe)l(lfMlf qpe3 npaBoTo Clf Ha MeCTHO HOPMOTBOpqeCTBO; · Pa3IIIHp5IBaHe npaKTlfqeCKOTO npIfJIaraHe Ha "MbJIqaJIlfBOTO CbrJIaClfe"; · HaMaJI5IBaHe CpOKOBeTe Ha oTroBop Ha a)l,MlfHHCTpaUH}}Ta; · CTpYKTYplfpaHe Ha a.n;MHHHCTpaTlIBeH opraH, Ha KoiiTo .n;a ce B'L3JIO)KaT MOHHTOPlfHr'LT H KOHTPOJI'LT BbPXY H3nbJIHeHlfeTO Ha 3aKOHa. llpUAo3ICeHue 6: H3C1leiJ6uHe 6'bpxy pezYllumopHume pe3ICUMu HU MecmHO pU6Hutqe IJ,eJITa Ha TOBa H3CJIe,ll,BaHe e ,ll,a ce npoytIH, aHaJIH3Hpa H 06061ll,H npaKTHKaTa Ha npHJIaraHe Ha perYJIaTOpHH pe)KHMH Ha MeCTHO paBHHlU,e. 06eKT Ha H3CJIe)J,BaHe ca TpH 06Ill,HHH: Pa3rpa,ll" TpOHH H KrocTeH,ll,HJI. 1136paH e e,ll,HH pe)KHM, KOllTO e 061ll, 3a TpHTe 061ll,HHH - pa3perneHHe 3a TaKCHMeTpOBH npeB03H H no olll,e e,ll,HH pe)KHM, pa3JIH'leH 3a BCHKa 06lU,HHa, KaKTO CJIe,ll,Ba: 3a KrocTeH,ll,HJI - KaTeropH3aUHH Ha XOTeJIH; 3a Pa3rpa,ll, TbprOBCKO pa3perneHHe; 3a TpOHH pa3peIIIHTeJIHO 3a CTpOe)K. P83pemeHHe 38 T8KCHMeTPOBH npeB03H Pe)IYHKIJ,HHTe Ha KMeTa ce H3pa3HBaT B H3,ll,aBaHe Ha 3anOBe)J, 3a H3nbJIHeHHe Ha Ta3H OTrOBOPHOCT. CJIe)J, KaTO pa3peIIIHTeJIHOTO e nO)J,rOTBeHO OT a)J,MHHHCTpaUHHTa TOll ro nO)J,nHCBa. C HerOBa 3anOBe)J, ce OTHeMa propeIIIHTeJIHO 3a H3BbpIIIBaHe Ha TaKCHMeTpOB npeB03. IIpoue,ll,ypaTa no nO,ll,aBaHe Ha ,ll,OKYMeHTHTe CTaBa B ueHTbpa 3a 06cny)KBaHe Ha rpa)K)J,aHHTe (KEHl'IE 6 · IT'bPBO, peIlleHHaTa 3a 6poa, onpe,neJIaHeTO Ha MeCTOCToaHKHTe, pa3npe,neJIeHHeTO Ha KBOTHTe Me~y Pa3JIHqHH npeB03BaqH, KOHTPOJI'bT Ha HeJIeraJIHHTe npeB03BaqH ca npe,nocTaBeHH Ha MeCTHO paBHHr.u;e. TOBa e OCHOBaHHe Ta3H ,neHHocT ,na ce perrraMeHTHpa B MeCTHaTa HopMaTHBHa ype,n6a H ,na ce OC'br.u;eCTBaBa OT 06r.u;HHHTe; · BTOPO, 3ae,nHO C JKeJIaHHeTO ,na peryJIHpa OTHOIlleHHaTa B ceKTopa H ,na nOCTHrHe Te3H IJ,eJIH, o6r.u;HHaTa ce onHTBa ,na nOCTHrHe H ,npyrH HecBoHcTBeHH 3a npoIJ,e,nypaTa IJ,eJIH, KaTO HanpHMep ,na KOHTpOJIHpa KJIHeHTHTe Ha Ta3H yCJIyra qpe3 H3HCKBaHe Ha ,noKYMeHTH 3a JIHnCa Ha 3a,n'bJIJKeHHa K'bM MeCTHHa H ,n'bpJKaBHHa 6IO,nJKeT H oCHrypHTeJIHaTa CHCTeMa. · TpeTO, 6H3HeC'bT e nOCTaBeH B cHryaIJ,Ha ,na ,nOKa3Ba Ha o6r.u;HHaTa, qe He H ,l('bJIJKH ,naH'bIJ,H, KoeTO CTpYBa BpeMe H cpe,nCTBa 3a H3,naBaHe Ha Te3H ,nOKYMeHTH. B C'br.u;OTO BpeMe, 06r.u;HHaTa MOJKe ,na npOBepH B CBoaTa cJIyJK6a ,naJIH npeB03BaQ'bT H HerOBHTe IllO0PMYJ1HP 3a onpe)J,eJ1HHe Ha KaTerOpHHTa; · KonHe OT )1.0KYMeHTa 3a c06CTBeHOCT; · KomIe OT )1.0rOBOpa 3a HaeM; · )J,OKyMeHT, Y)1.0CTOBepHBaru BbBe)f()J,aHeTO Ha 06eKTa B eKCnJ10aTaIJ,HH; · HOTapH311HO 3aBepeHO n'bJIHOMoruHO, KoraTO 3aHBJ1eHHeTO ce nO)1.aBa OT nbJ1HOMOIll,HHK; · )J,OKYMeHT 3a nJ1aTeHa TaKca, CbrJ1. qJ1. 55,311.4 OT 3T. OT )J,eJ10BO)J,CTBOTO )1.0KYMeHTHTe ce nOJIyqaBaT OT )1.J1'b)f(HOCTHO J1HlJ,e, qJIeH Ha KOMHcHHTa no KaTerOpH3aIJ,HH. TOH CbCTaBH npoeKT Ha 3anOBe)1. 3a oTKpHBaHe Ha npolJ,ell.Ypa no KaTerOpH3alJ,HH Ha 06eKTa. TH ce nO)1.nHCBa OT KMeTa, KOHTO H3)J,aBa H BpeMeHHo Y,L(OCToBepeHHe C'bC CpOK Ha )J,eHcTBHe OT 2 MeCelJ,a. KOMHcmna nOCeIll,aBa 06eKTa B )J,BYMeCeqeH CpOK (,L(OKaTO e B CHJIa BpeMeHHoTo Y)1.0CTOBepeHHe) H C'b6J1IO)J,aBaHKH MHHHM311HHTe H3HCKBaHHH no 3aKOHa, onpe,L(eJ1H KaTeropHHTa My. IIpe)J,J1ara Ha KMeTa ,L(a H3,L(a)J,e 3anOBe,L( 3a C'bOTBeTHaTa KaTeropHH. KMeThT nO)1.nHCBa 3anOBe)J,Ta, nOpbqBa ce KaTeropHMHa CHMBOJ1HKa H CJIe,L( HeMHOTO nOJIyqaBaHe Te ce BpbqBaT Ha CbOTBeTHOTO 3aBe)J,eHHe. IIpolJ,ell.YPHTe H )1.oKyMeHTHTe 3a THX ca npe)J,cTaBeHH Ha ye6 CTpaHHlJ,aTa Ha 06Il1,HHaTa. Te 06aqe He MoraT ,L(a ce nO,L(a)1.aT no eJ1eKTpOHeH nbT, 3aIll,OTO CbmaCHO qJ1. 11 OT Hape,L(6aTa, qaCT OT qJ1eHOBeTe Ha eKCnepTHaTa KOMHCHH (CJ1Y)f(HTeJ1H Ha 06Il1,HHCKaTa a)J,MHHHcTpalJ,ml) npeme)f()1.aT nO,L(a)J,eHHTe ,L(oKyMeHTH 3a nbJ1HOTa H HCTHHHOCT. He ce )1.0nycKa npHeMaHe Ha 3aHBJIeHHe 3a KaTerOpH3alJ,H5l, 6e3 )J,a ca npHJ10)f(eHH BCHqKH, H3HCKBaIll,H ce no Hape)J,6aTa ,L(oKyMeHTH. IIpHeMaHeTo Ha )J,oKYMeHTHTe Tp5l6Ba )1.a 6b,L(e cbnpOBO)1.eHO C nJIaTeHa TaKca. TOBa 3aTpY)1.HHBa nOJ1yqaBaHeTo no eJIeKTpOHeH nbT. CPOK'bT 3a H3)1.aBaHe Ha peweHHe e ,L(BYMeCeqeH H e npe,L(nHCaH OT 3aKoHa 3a TypH3Ma. CPOKbT e ,L(OCTaThqeH 3a H3B'bpWBaHe Ha onHcaHHTe ,L(eHCTBHH. HaM311HBaHeTO My rue 3aTpY)J,HH 06Il1,HHHTe, KOHTO HMaT r0J151M 6pOH 3aBe,L(eHH5l H XOTeJ1H. IIpe3 2009 r. 06Il1,HHa KIOCTeH)1.HJ1 e KaTerOpH3Hp311a 06Il1,o 53 06eKTa, OT KOHTO 42 3aBe)J,eHHH 3a xpaHeHe H pa3BJIeqeHHe H 11 XOTeJ1a. TaKCHTe 3a YCJ1yraTa He ce onpe,L(eJIHT OT 06Il1,HHCKHH CbBeT, a ca npe,L(nHCaHH OT 3T B TapHq,H He e SH~HO H!'i lC!'iT,;} n,;},>,;} '1'"'" l'0pMaIJ,lfOHeH MaCHB Ha cTan;lfoHapHHTe ThprOBCKH o6eKTlf, H3B'hpmBaIlJ,H ThprOBCKa )J,eHHocT Ha TepHTOplf}lTa Ha 06IlJ,lfHa Prorpa)J,. B Hape)J,6aTa T03lf pe)KlfM e onpe)J,eJIeH KaTO perlfcTpaulfoHeH. T'hprOBCKo y)J,ocToBepeHlfe ce lf3)J,aBa KaKTO nplf oTKplfBaHe Ha HOB ThprOBCKlf 06eKT, TaKa If npH npOM}lHa B 06CTO}lTeJICTBaTa T.H. npOM}lHa Ha HaeMaTeJI. IJ,eJITa 3a B'hBe)KJJ,aHeTO Ha T03lf pe)KlfM, cnope)J, Hape)J,6aTa, e )J.a ce C'h3)J.a)J.e H nO)J.)J.'hp)Ka lfHQ:>opMaUlfOHeH MaClfB 3a opraHH3aUH}lTa Ha ThproBcKaTa )J,eHHOCT B 06IlJ,HHaTa, 3a )J.a ce OCbIlJ,eCTB}lBa KOHTPOJI, KOHTO e BMeHeH KaTO 3a)J.bJI)KeHlfe Ha 06IlJ,lfHaTa no pe)J.lfua )J.pyflf 3aKOHlf. OCbIlJ,eCTB}lBa ce If Bp'h3Ka C npe)J,CTaBlfTeJIlfTe Ha T03lf 6lf3Hec. HHQ:>opMan;lfOHHlfJIT MaClfB "CTaUHOHapHlf ThprOBCKlf 06eKTH" ce lf3rpa)KJJ,a If nO)J.)J.bp)Ka OT 06IlJ,HHCKaTa a)J,MlfHlfCTpaIJ,lf}l If C'h)J,bp)Ka: · Blf)J. H HalfMeHOBaHlfe Ha ThproBCKlfJI o6eKT; · A)J.pec Ha ThprOBCKlf}l 06eKT; · lfpMa, ce)J,aJIlfIlJ,e, a)J.pec Ha ynpaBJIeHlfe If TeJIeQ:>OH Ha ThprOBeua; · HMe Ha JIlfueTO, npe)J,CTaBJI}lBaIIJ,O ThprOBen;a; · HOMep If )J,aTa Ha y)J.OCTOBepeHlfeTO 3a BnlfCBaHe; nocneABaw.a ou,eHKa Ha Bb3AeMCTBHeTO Ha 30APAKCA »nPlflnO>KEHIfIH · HOMep If ,lI,aTa Ha 3anOBe,ll,Ta 3a Y,lI,'bJDKeHO pa60THO BpeMe. KOHTpOJ1HlfTe $YHKIJ,lfM Ha 06lll,MHCKaTa a,ll,MlfHlfCTpaIJ,lf}I no OTHOllleHlfe Cna3BaHeTO Ha Hape,ll,6aTa Ha OC M pernaMeHTlfTe B ,lI,PymTe HopMaTMBHlf aKTOBe, CB'bp3aHM C ThprOBCKaTa ,lI,eMHOCT, ce OTHaC5lT ,lI,O: Ona3BaHe Ha 06lll,eCTBeHlf5l pe,ll, - KOHTPOJ1 3a Cna3BaHe Ha pa60THOTO BpeMe; no 3aKOHa 3a 3alll,MTa Ha nOTpe6MTeJ1MTe - KOHTPOJ1 Ha IJ,eHlf If ,lI,Pym; 3aKOHa 3a YCTPOMCTBO Ha TeplfTOplf5lTa 06eKThT B'bBe,ll,eH J1lf e B eKCIIJIOaTaIJ,lf5l If T.H. TIpOIJ,e,ll,yplfTe no lf3,l1,aBaHe Ha ThprOBCKO pa3pelIleHlfe If ,lI,OKYMeHTHTe 3a T5lX ca ny6J1lfKYBaHlf B ye6 CTpaHlfIJ,aTa Ha 06lll,lfHaTa. 06Pa3IJ,lf Ha 3a5lBJ1eHlfeTO MoraT ,lI,a ce lf3Tern5lT. TIO,ll,aBaHeTO Ha ,lI,OKYMeHTlfTe o6aqe He MO)l(e ,lI,a CTaHe no eJleKTpOHeH n'bT. KnlfeHTlfTe ce 06CJIY)I(BaT Ha e,ll,HO mlIle. ,lJ,oKYMeHTlfTe ce nO,ll,aBaT B'bB $pOHT o$lfca Ha 06lll,lfHaTa. [OTOBlfTe ,lI,OKYMeHTlf (Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlfeTO) ce nOJIYqaBaT Ha C'blll,OTO M5lCTO. T'bproBeIJ,'bT nO,ll,aBa 3a5lBJ1eHlfe no 06pa3eIJ,. K'bM 3a5lBJ1eHlfeTO ce nplfJ1araT KOnlf5l OT: · Y,lI,OCTOBepeHMe 3a aKTYMHO C'bCT05lHlfe OT ThprOBCKM5l perlfCThp; · ,lJ,OKYMeHT, Y,lI,OCTOBep5lBalll, KO,ll, no EHK/EYJICTAT; · ,lJ,oKYMeHT, ype)l(,ll,alll, co6CTBeHOCTTa lfJ1lf npaBa 3a nOJ13BaHe Ha o6eKTa; · ,lJ,OKYMeHT, Y,lI,OCTOBep5lBalll, B'bBe)l(,lI,aHeTO Ha 06eKTa B eKCnJ10aTaIJ,lf5l; · Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlfe 3a perlfCTpaIJ,lf5l Ha 06eKTa B PHOK03 - Pa3rpa,ll" KoraTO TOBa e Heo6xo,ll,lfMO; · HOTaplfMHo 3aBepeHO n'bJ1HOMOlll,HO, aKO 3a5lBJ1eHlfeTO ce IIO,ll,aBa OT n'bJ1HOMOlll,HlfK; · ,lJ,oKYMeHT, Y,lI,OCTOBep5lBalll, J1lfnCaTa Ha 3a,ll,'bJ1)1(eHlf5l KbM 06lll,lfHaTa K'bM ,lI,aTaTa Ha nO,ll,aBaHe Ha MOJI6aTa. B'bTpelIlHaTa npOIJ,e,ll,ypa no o6pa6oTKa Ha ,lI,OKYMeHTMTe e CJ1e,ll,HaTa: TIplfeTlfTe ,lI,OKYMeHTlf ce npe,ll,aBaT OT $pOHT - o$lfca B ceKTOp "T'bprOSlf5l", npOBep5lBaT ce, o6pa6oTsaT ce If rOTOBOTO Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlfe ce Bp'blll,a Ha rlflIleTO 3a npe,ll,aBaHe Ha J1lfIJ,eTO. CpOK'bT 3a lf3,l1,aBaHe Ha pa3pelIllfTeJ1HOTO e 14 ,lI,Hlf OT nOCThnBaHe Ha ,lI,OKYMeHTlfTe. CJ1e,ll, nO,ll,nlfCBaHe Ha Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlfeTO OT KMeTa Ha 06lll,lfHaTa lfJ1lf YII'bJ1HOMOlll,eHO OT Hero ,lI,J1'b)l(HOCTHO J1lfIJ,e, TbprOBCKlf5lT 06eKT ce BIIlfCBa B lfH$opMaIJ,lfOHHM5l MaClfB "CTaIJ,lfOHapHlf ThprOBCKlf 06eKTlf". KMeThT Ha 06lll,lfHaTa OTKa3Sa lf3,l1,aSaHeTo Ha Y,lI,ocTosepeHlfeTo nplf mmca Ha H5lKOM OT lf3lfcKyeMlfTe ,lI,OKYMeHTlf. OTKa3'bT MO)l(e ,lI,a ce 06)1(MBa no pe,ll,a Ha MMlfHlfCTpaTlfSHO-npOIJ,eCYMHlf5l KO,ll,eKC. CpOK'bT e ,lI,OCTaThqeH 3a npOBepKa Ha ,lI,OKYMeHTlfTe If lf3rOTB5lHe Ha Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlfeTO. TIpe3 2009 r. 06lll,lfHa Pa3rpa,ll, e H3,l1,Ma 275 ThprOBCKlf Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlf5l. YCJ1yraTa e 6e3IIJ1aTHa. AHMlf3'bT Ha npaKTMKaTa no lf3,l1,aBaHe Ha ThprOBCKlf Y,lI,OCTOBepeHlf5l ,lI,aBa OCHOBaHlfe ,lI,a ce OIIpe,ll,eJ1lf, qe T03lf pe)l(lfM e B'bBe,ll,eH He3aKOHOC'bo6pa3HO If CJ1e,ll,Ba Be,ll,Hara ,lI,a 6'b,ll,e OTMeHeH. PalpemeHHe la CTpoe)l( Pe)l(MM'bT e B'bBe,ll,eH Ha OCHOBaHMe Ha 3aKoHa 3a YCTpOMCTBO Ha TeplfTOplf5lTa (3YT). TOll e onpe,ll,eJ1eH KaTO pa3pelIlMTeJ1eH. IJ,eJ1Ta 3a B'bBe)l(,lI,aHeTO My e perYJ1lfpaHe If KOHTpOJ1 S'bpXY CTpOlfTeJICTBOTO. TIp0IJ,e,ll,YPlfTe If ,lI,OKYMeHTlfTe, Heo6xo,ll,lfMlf 3a lf3,l1,aSaHe Ha pa3pelIllfTeJ1HO 3a cTpoe)l(, ca npe,ll,CTaBeHlf B ye6 CTpaHlfIJ,aTa Ha 06lll,lfHaTa. ,lJ,OKYMeHTlf He MoraT ,lI,a ce IIO,ll,a,ll,aT no eJ1eKTpOHeH n'bT. B 06lll,lfHaTa e opraHlf3lfpaHO 06CJ1Y)I(SaHe Ha e,ll,HO rlflIle. TIO,ll,aBaHeTO Ha ,lI,OKYMeHTlfTe ce lf3B'bplIlBa B IJ,eHThpa 3a 06CJ1Y)I(BaHe Ha rpa)l(,lI,aHlf K'bM a,ll,MlfHlfCTpaIJ,lf5lTa, K'b,ll,eTO snOCJ1e,ll,CTBlfe ce IIOJ1yqaBa If pa3pelIllfTeJ1HOTO. npa.1nO>KEHa.1E 6 )J,OKYMeHTaUI-UITa ce rrO,L(aBa B ueHTbpa, Kb,L(eTO ce rrpoBepHBa ,L(aJIH e OKOMIlJleKTOBaHa, CbfJIaCHO H3HCKBaHHHTa H ce 3arrnama orrpe,L(eneHaTa TaKca. OT ueHThpa TH ce rrpe,L(OCTaBH Ha HaqaJIHHK OT,L(en "TCY", KoifTO H pa3rrpe,L(enH KbM CBOH CrreUHaJIHCTH 3a rrpoBepKa H 0,L(06pHBaHe. O,L(06peHHTe rro BCHqKH qaCTH rrpOeKTH ce BpbmaT rrpH HaqaJIHHK-OT,L(en "TCY", KoiiTo rrO,L(rOTBH pa3peIlleHHeTo 3a CTpOe>K H ro rrO,L(HaCH Ha rnaBHHH apxHTeKT Ha 06mHHaTa 3a rrO,L(rrHC. )J,OIK,L(aHHHbT H rronyqaBa. CPOKbT 3a rrpe,L(OCTaBHHe Ha ycnyraTa e 7 ,L(HH, KoraTO ,L(OKYMeHTaUHHTa e BHeCCHa C ,L(OKJIa,L( 3a oueHKa Ha CbOTBeTCTBHeTO Ha rrpocKTa CbC CbIUCCTBeHHTe H3HCKBaHHH Ha CrpOC>KHTe, H 30 ,L(HH, KoraTO ,L(OKYMeHTaUHHTa e 6e3 ,L(OKJIa,L(. Crropc,L( rrpe,L(CTaBHTen Ha 06IUHHa TpOHH CPOKbT, orrpC,L(eneH OT 3YT, e HOPMaJICH. HaMaJIHBaHeTO My 6H 3aTpY,L(HHnO KaqeCTBCHOTO 06pa60TBaHe Ha ,L(OKYMeHTHTC. TIpe3 2009 r. 06IUHHaTa C H3,L(aJIa 262 6p. Pa3pCIllHTCnHH 3a CTpOe>K. KnHcHTHTC rrnaIUaT TaKCa, KOHTO e pernaMcHTHpaHa C "Hape,L(6a 3a orrpe,L(eJIHHe H a,L(MHHHCTpHpaHc Ha MeCTHHTe TaKCH H l.\CHH Ha YCnyfH Ha TCPHTopHHTa Ha 06IUHHa TpOHH". Pa3MepbT Ha TaKCHTe e orrpe,L(eneH OT 06IUHHCKHH CbBeT Ha 6a3a OCTOHHOCTeH Tpy,L( Ha aHra>KHpaHHTc CrreUHaJIHCTH 3a H3BbpIllBaHe Ha ycnyraTa. TaKCaTa nOKpHBa H3BbPIllCHHTC Pa3XO,L(H OT a,L(MHHHCTpaUHHTa; HeHHHHT pa3Mep ce onpe,L(CnH OT 06IUHHCKHH CbBeT B 3aBHCHMOCT OT BH,L(a Ha crpoHTcnHHH 06cKT H HcrOBHTC pa3McpH. IIplLllo:nceHue 7: JIuqenauoHHu pe:HC1l.M.u u ct>tqecmayautqu pezucmpu ct>2.IlUCHO U3UCKaUHUSlmu HU 30APAKC,lf Pe.BMI~eii:BOeT OpraODO HopMaTHBeo 8KI' IlanH"IBeOa JIB..e03HpaOeTO nyfiml"leo pel'BeT'bp 1. liaHKOBa )J.eHHOCT, liHIi liaHKH 3aKOH 3a t. ,[la, 3a 6aHKH. )J.eHHOCT KaTO )J.PY)KeCTBO Kpe)J.HTHHTe MHCTHTY1um 3a eJIeKTpOHHH napll, 3aKOH 3a nJIaTe)KHllTe 2. He, 3a )J.PY)KecTBa )J.eHHocT KaTO nJIaTe)KHa 3a eJIeKTpOHHll napH, ycnyrH II nJIaTe)KHllTe HHCTllTYLlHJI, KaKTO H )J.eHHocTH KaTO CllCTeMH )J.eHHocT KaTO CHCTeMeH nJIaTe)KHa onepaTop Ha llJIaTe)KHH HHCTHTYLlHJI, KaKTO II CHCTeMH. )J.eHHocTll KaTO CllCTeMeH onepaTop Ha IIJIaTe)KHH . CHCTeMH. 2. 3acTpaxoBaTenHa )J.eHHocT KKEHrr1E 7 OpraH DO HOpMaTIlBeB au HUB"IRe Ba ~B~eB3Hpa_B_eT0_-4________~ ______________+-ny ___"I_e_B p_erReTbp-4 __ __6nR __ _____ 26., J],ellHOCTII B ofiJIacrra Ha J],KEBP 3aKOH 3a eHepreTHKaTa )1,a eHepreTlfKaTa. r---=-+~~ ------t--=.-----~.---I--.-~-- - . -..---~-+-----------I 27. I13B'bpillBaHe Ha AJIP 3aKoH 3a fie30nacHo )1,ellHoCTII, CB'bp3aHlf C II3nOJI3Bane Ha MpeHaTa M3IlOJI3BaHe Ha MpeHII eHeprIDI C'bOp'b)[(eHIDI II MpeH MaTepIIaJI II )1,pyrn II3TO·iHllU.II Ha llOHH3H aIQH JI'bqeHIDI. 28. Ynpa)[(H.!IBaHe Ha MPPE - J],MpeKll,IDl 3a 3YT CTpOllTeJIeH na)1,30p npH Hau.IIOHaJIeH Hape)1,fia N!! 9/22.05.200 I r. H3rpa)[()1,aHe Ha cTpOMTeJIeH KOHTPOJI 3a JIIIueH3IIpaHe Ha JIllu.aTa, cTpollTeJIHH ofieKTII ynpa)[(H5IBaIQII cTpOIITeJIeH I . Ha)1,30Q 29. I13B'bpilIBaHe Ha MTI1TC - I1A 3aKoH 3a )[(eJIe30n'bTHIDI )1,a )[(eJIe30n'bTeH npeBo3 Ha ,,)KeJIe30n'bTHa TpaHcnopT II'bTHIIU,II WIIJIll TOBapII II a)1,MHHIICTpall,lliI" npoBepKa Ha TeXHIIqeCKaTa II3npaBHocT Ha B03IIJIaTa II npaBoCnOCOfiHocrra II ·-l KBaJIIICPllKau,ll5ITa Ha nepCOHaJIa. 30. I13B'bpillBaHe Ha MTI1TC - I1A 3aKoH 3a )1,Bll)[(eHIIe no He ofiIQeCTBeHII npeB03ll Ha ,,ABTOMOfiIIJIHa n'bTllIQaTa Il'bTHIIUII II TOBapII C a)1,MllHIICTpaU.ll5I" TH aBTOMOfillJIeH TpaHCIlopT, BKJIlOqllTeJIHO Me)[()1,YHapO)1,eH. I I I 3l. I13B'bpWBaHe Ha IIpOBepKH MTI1TC He Ha TeXHIIqeCKa eo AI"'''''""' no n'bTIIIQaTa ll3IlPaBHOCT Ha Il'bTHII IIpeB03HII Cpe)1,CTBa, peMOHT II TeXHllqeCKO I o6cny)[(BaHe Ha TaKIIBa r£pe)1,c!!i~ _ _.. I I --' '32: I13B'bpWBaHe Ha KPC 3aKOH 3a nOIQeHCKllTe )1,a YHllBepCaJIHaTa IlOIQeHCKa yCJIyrn yCJIyra IIJIII Ha yCJIym, BKJIlOqeHII B 06XBaTa Ha YHllBepCaJIHaTa IlOIQeHCKa YCJI:l:::ra. .--. 33. IhB'bpwBaHe Ha KPC 3aKoH 3a IIOIQeHCKMTe - i- nOIQeHCKM napIIqHll npeBO)1,M. 34. I13B'bpWBaHe Ha )1,ellHOCT MlliTC fJ], I yCJIym 3aKoH 3a rpa)[()1,aHCKOTo I"' He KaTO JIeTIIIQeH OIlepaTOp, " fpa)[()1,aHCKa B'b3)1,yxonJIaBaHe OIlepaTOp IlO Ha3eMHO B'b3)1,yxOIlJIaBaTeJIHa 06CJIY)[(BaHe HJIll a)1,MllHMCTpau,llJl" B'b3)1,yweHnpeB03Baq. 35. TeXHIIqeCKO 06CJIY)[(BaHe MTI1TC - fJ], 3aKoH 3a rpa)[()1,aHCKOTO He II peMOHT Ha aBMau.HOHHa "fpa)[()1,aHCKa B'b3)1,yxOnJIaBaHe I I TeXHIIKa. B'b3)1,yxOIIJIaBaTeJIHa I a)1,MHHHcTpall,lliI" I I I 136., fIPOII3BO)1,CTBO, BHOC KPC 3aKOH 3a He II/HJIII pa3npOCTpaHeHHe )1,aJIeKoc'bo6IQeHIDITa LJ.;:npe_arenHH pan.o C'bOp'b)[(eHIDI 3a I r a)[()1,aHCKH HY)[()1,ll. I - ~ ~------~-~-~ ..... r-Dl'"r I nocneABall\a ou.eHKa Ha B'b3AeMCTBMeTO Ha 30APAKCA »np(.1nOH